MDCK/Caco-2 assays serve as essential in vitro tools for evaluating membrane permeability and active transport, especially mediated by P-glycoprotein (P-gp). Despite their utility, challenges remain in quantifying active transport and using the efflux ratio (ER) to determine intrinsic values for active efflux. Such an intrinsic value for P-gp facilitated efflux necessitates knowing whether this transporter transports the neutral or ionic species of a compound. Utilising MDCK-MDR1 assays, we investigate a method for determining transporter substrate fraction preference by studying ER pH-dependence for basic, acidic and non-dissociating compounds. These results are compared with model fits based on various assumptions of transporter species preference. As an unexpected consequence of these assays, we also give evidence for an additional influx transporter at the basolateral membrane, and further extend our model to incorporate this transport. The combined influences of paracellular transport, the previously unaccounted for basolateral influx transporter, as well as potential pH effects on the transporter impedes the extraction of intrinsic values for active transport from the ER. Furthermore, we determined that using inhibitor affects the measurement of paracellular transport. While clear indications of transporter species preference remain elusive, this study enhances understanding of the MDCK system.