The effects of different mixing parameters (vacuum mixing and mixing time) on oat (70% oat flour) and wheat noodle dough were investigated on the basis of textural properties and gluten formation. The results showed that at a vacuum degree of −0.06 MPa and mixing time of 10 min, oat and wheat dough sheets exhibited the highest resistance to extension and glutenin macropolymer (GMP) content, and had the most compact and uniform gluten network. Compared with wheat noodle dough, oat dough had lower resistance to extension, lower tightly bound water content, and higher GMP content. Microstructural examination showed that oat noodle dough had a more aggregated distribution of gluten protein compared with wheat noodle dough under the optimum mixing parameters. Furthermore, the poor binding ability of vital wheat gluten with water molecules caused the indexes of oat noodle dough to be more strongly affected by the changes in mixing parameters than wheat noodle dough.