One of the most commonly held beliefs about children's sports is that they greatly develop participants' self-concepts and otherwise benefit players psychologically. But aside from that popular belief, does a first experience in a summer baseball program indeed contribute significantly to players' self-concept? In an attempt to answer this question, the Piers-Harris Children's Self-concept Scale was administered to 66 novice players and 99 nonplayers, 9 to 10 yr. old, before and after the baseball season. Of the former group, 35 subjects were players in a league which was highly competitive and 25 were players in a recreational league. The competitive league had the following characteristics: paid coaches, full uniforms, post-season playoffs and awards, all-star games, tryouts and drafts, no age-grouping, and games outside the residential area. The recreational league was characterized by volunteer coaches, no or limited uniforms (tee-shirts and caps), no post-season playoffs, tee-ball or pitching machines, everybody having a chance to play every game, players closely age-grouped, and games at parks close to residences. When all players were contrasted against all nonplayers, the players (M = 55.9) had a marginally higher (F1.l~ = 2.79, p < .09) mean self-concept than the nonplayers (M = 51.4) befoie the season. The significant main effect of league structure (PI,m = 4.85, p < .03) indicated that the mean self-concept of players in the competitive league (+4.2) increased more than that of recreational players (-0.3). The mean self-concept of the nonplayers increased significantly (from 51.4 to 56.1, p < .05) from the pretest to the posttest. When the data were analyzed in relation to the teams' season performance (win percentage), the main effect of team performance and the interaction of team performance and league structure were nonsignificant. It appeared that those in the competitive league significantly improved in selfconcept, whereas the recreational players remained the same over the baseball season. The increase for both nonplayers and competitive players suggests that the traditional Little League baseball was no more effective than various activities of nonplayers during the summer. Children must be intrinsically motivated by rheir activities for self-concept to increase (1, 2, 3). The higher mean self-concept of players than that of non-players before the season may reflecr a self-selection and intrinsic motivation.
Read full abstract