This study investigates the impact of pre-treatment intensity on biogas production in anaerobic digestion processes using three different substrates: BPWSB, TWSB, and PWSB. The experimental design includes semicontinuous tests with various pre-treatment levels (PTLs) to analyze specific methane yields and process stability indicators. Reactor performance comparisons reveal differences in methane production profiles among substrates, with GWSB generally outperforming BPWSB and PWSB. Additionally, PTL4 consistently yields higher specific methane yields than PTL3 and PTL2 across all substrates due to its greater surface area. The specific methane yields for BPWSB, TWSB, and PWSB are comparable but not identical. The highest specific methane yield was produced by BPWSB for PTL2 (M=225.6, SD=57.7), while the lowest was produced by GWSB (M=181.2, SD=51.9). The results suggest that the specific methane yields for BPWSB, TWSB, and PWSB are similar but not identical. Again, BPWSB PTL3 (M=255, SD=63.5) differed significantly from the others, whereas GWSB had the lowest specific methane yield (M=211.7, SD=56.6). Likewise, BPWSB PTL4 outperformed the other substrates (M=290.3, SD=69.3), while GWSB PTL4 had the least (M=218.3, SD=69.4). Intensive pre-treatment shows no detrimental effects on system stability, with reduced foaming tendency observed at higher pre-treatment intensities. These results indicate that carefully choosing pre-treatment methods can boost methane yields while addressing operational difficulties, emphasizing the significance of pre-treatment in sustainable waste management and renewable energy generation. Future studies could investigate further pre-treatment methods and their long-term impacts on biogas output and system stability, offering more comprehensive insights into process refinement.
Read full abstract