The cost of supporting traits that increase mating opportunities and maximize the production of quality offspring is paid in energy. This currency of reproduction is enabled by bioenergetic adaptations that underlie the flexible changes in energy utilization that occur with reproduction. This review considers the traits that contribute to variation in the capacity of an organ to produce ATP. Further, it synthesizes findings from studies that have evaluated bioenergetic adaptations to the production of sexually selected traits and performance during reproduction and the role of change in mitochondrial respiratory performance in the tradeoff between reproduction and longevity. Cumulatively, these works provide evidence that in selecting for redder males, female finches will likely mate with a male with high mitochondrial respiratory performance and, potentially, a higher probability of mitonuclear compatibility. Females from diverse taxa allocate more to reproduction when the respiratory performance of mitochondria or density of the inner mitochondrial membrane in the liver or skeletal muscle is higher. Finally, reproduction does not appear to have persistent negative effects on mitochondrial respiratory performance, countering a role for mitochondria in the trade-off between reproduction and longevity. I close by noting that adaptations that improve mitochondrial respiratory performance appear vital for optimizing reproductive fitness.