It is obviously difficult, within the limited space at my disposal, enter into detail in the discussion of the points of view and emphases of the various writers in this symposium. Perhaps the most valuable procedure would be follow that of Mr. D. A. Wilkerson in his study of A Determination of the Peculiar Problems of Negroes in Contemporary American Society, but neither space nor time will allow this. I shall, therefore, attempt a comprehensive view of the problems as presented, and without reference the specific contributions, point out the good and bad points of the positions maintained. Of course, the discussion will be colored by my own point of view and perhaps my own prejudices. In spite of the fact that Mr. Wilkerson, in his study of the literature of education, comes the conclusion that education involves special consideration and requires a unique redirection and emphasis, the writers in the symposium, generally conclude that no special redirection or emphasis is necessary, and that the problem of education and its reconstruction is just a part of the need of educational redirection in America. Aside from an occasional emphasis in the necessity of reverting fundamentals, and an emphasis upon an old-time conventional school program for schools, and a more frequent just righteous indignation at the evident discrimination against the in the schools of the country, particularly in the South, the articles fall into a conventional mold in line with the general philosophy of American education, emphasizing the necessity of the reconstruction of the whole educational program in line with needs of education in a democracy. Moreover, if the word Negro should be extracted from the manuscripts the whole might be published as a general treatise on education and be a creditable publication. It is necessary here restate the purposes of the Yearbook and indicate what extent and in what way these purposes have been realized in the discussions presented. The purposes as expressed are: to take a comprehensive look at the education of Negroes as a whole, ascertain what, if any, reorganization or redirection may be necessary and how they may be most expeditiously effected. In such a comprehensive evaluation it would naturally be expected that, first, some broad appraisal of present status would be both necessary and desirable; second, that some examination be made of the needs which our present educational set-up is supposed serve, determine what form reorganization, or redirection should take, if found necessary, or where renewed efforts should fall, if more