Economic Damage Threshold Research Articles

Relações entre intensidade da doença, refletância da radiação solar e rendimento de grãos no patossistema ferrugem da folha de trigo Embrapa 16

Em experimentos com o cultivar de trigo Embrapa 16 conduzidos em Passo Fundo e Não-Me-Toque nas safras de 1999 e 2000 houve uma relação inversa entre a incidência foliar da ferrugem da folha do trigo, a severidade, o número de pústulas por centímetro quadrado e a área abaixo da curva de progresso da doença com o rendimento de grãos, e uma relação direta entre a refletância da radiação solar, na faixa de 810 nm, com o rendimento de grãos. A refletância da radiação solar na faixa permitiu estimar o rendimento de grãos do trigo, a severidade da doença e o número de pústulas cm-2. As equações da função de dano com maior R² obtidas pela análise de regressão permitem o cálculo do limiar de dano econômico (LDE) em diferentes estádios fenológicos da cultura. O LDE pode servir de critério indicador do momento para o controle da ferrugem da folha do trigo. Os danos causados pela doença atingiram um máximo de 43%, com uma média de 40 %.

Effect of 6-Methoxybenzoxazolin-2-one (MBOA) on the Reproduction Rate of the Grain Aphid (Sitobion avenaeF.)

Partial host-plant resistance could make a substantial contribution to reducing the damage caused by economically important grain aphids and, therefore, to reduced insecticide use. Naturally occurring hydroxamic acids, in particular 2,4-dihydroxy-7-methoxy-1,4-benzoxazin-3-one (DIMBOA), have been shown to be involved in the resistance of cereals to insects. DIMBOA is unstable in aqueous solutions and has been reported to decompose to 6-methoxybenzoxazolin-2-one (MBOA). MBOA was tested on grain aphids living on artificial diet incorporated with MBOA. From 0 to 0.1 mM, the intrinsic rate of increase (rm) increased. From 0.1 to 0.3 it decreased by 73%. The rm was calculated to be 0 at 1.0 mM. Consequently, even low concentrations of MBOA may reduce the aphid multiplication to a level below the economic damage threshold. Therefore, it is possible to breed wheat varieties with a sufficiently high content of DIMBOA to decrease grain aphid populations.

Life history data of the rosy apple aphid Dysaphis plantaginea (Pass.) (Homopt., Aphididae) on plantain and as migrant to apple

The rosy apple aphid Dysaphis plantaginea (Passerini) is a key pest in western European apple orchards; the economic damage threshold is so low that outbreaks cannot be forecasted. A mass rearing of the species on plantain (Plantago lanceolata L.) was initiated, with the aim to infest apple trees with either the autumn migrants, gynoparae and males, or the egg-laying females (oviparae). Here, data are presented about the propagation of the species on plantain, on the production of autumn migrants under laboratory conditions, and on the duration of juvenile development and reproductive capacities of both gynoparae and oviparae. Under long-day conditions (18 h light/day) on plantain, the thermal constant for the duration of juvenile development was 166 dd (day-degrees) above the lower development threshold of 5.1 °C, and daily larviposition amounted to 1.87 times the temperature (°C)minus 0.8, above a lower threshold of 4.3 °C. Between 32 and 36 larvae were produced by the young female before the first larvae become adult and their reproduction started to overshadow their mother’s. A plant freshly infested with 12 reproducing females and transferred to short-day conditions (12 h light/day) yielded up to 5,000 autumn migrants, with males in the majority. The first gynoparae appeared after about 25 days at both 16 and 20 °C, and males appeared after 40 and 33 days, respectively. Young adult gynoparae produced most of their about ten offspring right after landing on apples, unless temperature was well below 15 °C. The duration of juvenile development of these oviparae appeared to be rather variable and their egg-laying so protracted that each of these females needs to survive several weeks to produce a handful of winter eggs. With reproductive capacities of up to 14 progeny/female for gynoparae and 7.4 for oviparae, release of one gynopara in the field could theoretically lead to the deposition of 100 winter eggs.

Estimation of production losses caused by the coffee berry borer (Coleoptera: Scolytidae) and calculation of an economic damage threshold in Togolese coffee plots.

The coffee berry borer, Hypothenemus hampei (Ferrari) (Coleoptera: Scolytidae), which exists in all coffee producing zones, is a major pest. The seriousness of this scolytid was assessed in Togolese plots spread over five agroclimatic zones, by determining the attack rate from a sample of coffee trees. The work was carried out over 2 yr and revealed that weight losses were proportional to the attack rates. The average infestation rates were 5.64% in the first year and 6.36% in the second year, while total production losses amounted to 2.60% and 3.18%, respectively, for the same periods. Generally speaking, attack rates in the plots were low and varied considerably within a given zone. Plantations located on plateau were more severely attacked than those in the plains. A relationship was established between total losses and the cost of insecticide treatment; this relationship was used to calculate an economic damage threshold beyond which control proves to be cost effective.

Estimation of Production Losses Caused by the Coffee Berry Borer (Coleoptera: Scolytidae) and Calculation of an Economic Damage Threshold in Togolese Coffee Plots

The coffee berry borer, Hypothenemus hampei (Ferrari) (Coleoptera: Scolytidae), which exists in all coffee producing zones, is a major pest. The seriousness of this scolytid was assessed in Togolese plots spread over five agroclimatic zones, by determining the attack rate from a sample of coffee trees. The work was carried out over 2 yr and revealed that weight losses were proportional to the attack rates. The average infestation rates were 5.64% in the first year and 6.36% in the second year, while total production losses amounted to 2.60% and 3.18%, respectively, for the same periods. Generally speaking, attack rates in the plots were low and varied considerably within a given zone. Plantations located on plateau were more severely attacked than those in the plains. A relationship was established between total losses and the cost of insecticide treatment; this relationship was used to calculate an economic damage threshold beyond which control proves to be cost effective.

Economic damage threshold model for pollen beetles ( Meligethes aeneus F.) in spring oilseed rape ( Brassica napus L.) crops

The pollen beetle ( Meligethes aeneus F.) is the most important pest in Danish oilseed rape ( Brassica napus L.) crops. The beetle can cause serious yield losses in both winter and spring oilseed rape crops, and for spring oilseed rape, more than 80% yield reduction can occur. Consequently, in most years, spring oilseed rape crops are treated with pesticides. In the period 1988–1997, 26 spring oilseed rape pesticide field trials were carried out. The pollen beetle infestation was expressed as beetle-days calculated as number of pollen beetles per plant per day and summarised from immigration until end of flowering. Damage caused by pollen beetles was calculated as the yield loss between treated and untreated plots and expressed as a per cent of treated plots. A multiple regression approach was taken, in which the yield loss (YL) was the response variable and beetle-days (BD), day degrees (DD) and precipitation before and after immigration of pollen beetles into the spring oilseed rape fields ( P), were the independent variables. The highest value of the regression coefficient and the smallest sum of squared residuals was obtained in a model with only four variables included. The variables were beetle-days, day degrees (DD 7b) and precipitation (P 7b) in 7 days before the start of immigration and day degrees (DD 7a) in 7 days after the start of immigration. The model can be written as YL=0.253BD+0.340DD 7b−1.721 P 7b−0.296DD 7a. ( r=0.76; p < 0.001; d f=139; F=46.02). The economic damage threshold for control of pollen beetles in spring oilseed rape crops can be calculated as 5.0% of the yield. If temperatures are average, the economic damage threshold can be calculated as being from 0.1 to 3.0 pollen beetles per plant depending on the amount of precipitation. Therefore, it can be concluded that the present economic damage thresholds for spring oilseed rape in Denmark of between 0.5 and 1.0 pollen beetle per plant are too crude and must be more differentiated with reference to reducing the application index of insecticides.

Inundative release of coccinellid beetles into eucalypt plantations for biological control of chrysomelid leaf beetles

Abstract 1 Inundative augmentative releases of adult coccinellid beetles were assessed for their potential to effectively supplement biological control of outbreak populations of the Eucalyptus leaf beetle Chrysophtharta bimaculata in Eucalyptus nitens plantations.2 Mixed groups of two species of overwintering coccinellids, Cleobora mellyi and Harmonia conformis, were collected from the field then fed three diets in the laboratory prior to release. Both species were released in the summer into two E. nitens plantations with economically damaging Chrysophtharta populations.3 Differences between dispersal of coccinellids fed the three diets were slight; beetles brought straight out of overwintering before release were initially slower moving onto trees.4 Numbers of coccinellids on trees in monitoring plots decreased exponentially with time, and populations had returned to prerelease levels 7 days after release. The number of coccinellids recaptured decreased with increasing distance from the release point with very few coccinellids per tree at 70 m distance. Dispersal of C. mellyi away from the release plot was slower than that of H. conformis.5 Numbers of coccinellids on trees were significantly related to predation levels of C. bimaculata with a large decrease in the C. bimaculata population to below the economic damage threshold in plots where the numbers of coccinellids were high.6 The results of this study suggest that inundative release of laboratory reared coccinellids is possible for biological control of C. bimaculata, although it may only be economically viable in small, environmentally sensitive areas.

Sensibilidade de Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici a alguns fungicidas

Em experimentos conduzidos no campo, na safra 2000, avaliou-se a sensibilidade do oídio do trigo nas cultivares de trigo (Triticum aestivum) BR 23 e OR 1 a alguns fungicidas. As avaliações da intensidade da doença foram feitas com base na incidência, severidade e área abaixo da curva de progresso da doença, realizadas aos sete, 14 e 21 dias após a pulverização dos fungicidas. O fungo agente causal do oídio, Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici, mostrou-se sensível aos fungicidas sistêmicos em ambas as cultivares. A maior sensibilidade foi ao fungicida triadimenol, considerando-se os valores absolutos na porcentagem de controle da doença. O enxofre, pelo curto período de proteção, não tem potencial de uso em trigo. Os danos no rendimento de grãos foram de 32% e 79% respectivamente para 'BR 23' e 'OR 1'. O controle do oídio, mesmo em cultivares altamente suscetíveis, como 'OR 1', pode ser eficientemente realizado com fungicidas sistêmicos recomendados pela pesquisa, não sendo detectada insensibilidade do fungo aos mesmos. No entanto, deve-se evitar o uso de sub-dose e controlar a doença com a incidência recomendada pela pesquisa com base no limiar de dano econômico.

Modelo de ponto crítico para estimar os danos causados pelo oídio em cevada

Em experimento conduzido no campo com a cultivar cevada (Hordeum vulgare) BR 2 gerou-se o gradiente do oídio pelo uso de fungicidas em tratamento de sementes de modo a se obter um gradiente da incidência da doença e do rendimento de grãos. Com esses dados, através de análise de regressão, obteve-se um modelo que permite estimar o rendimento de grãos da cevada, em função da intensidade do oídio, em diferentes estádios fenológicos da cultura. O melhor modelo foi representado pela equação Y = 2.978,3 - 7,75 X (R² de 0,83) para o estádio de afilhamento. A redução máxima no rendimento de grãos foi de 28,03%.

Development of an integrated pest management programme for cotton. Part 1: Establishing and utililizing natural enemies

The strategy for the control of cotton pests, notably Helicoverpa spp., in Australia is insecticide-dependent with limited consideration of the role of beneficial insects. A programme for the development of an integrated pest management (IPM) approach commenced in cotton fields at Norwood near Moree in New South Wales in 1992. In this approach, an alternative crop, lucerne (Medicago sativa), was used in an interplant system plus spraying of cotton with a supplementary food (Envirofeast®), which served to attract and retain predators in treated plots. The predator complex consisted of predatory beetles, bugs, lacewings and spiders. The deployment of these two components, interplants and predator retention, reduced the number of Helicoverpa spp. eggs, very small and small larvae (first, second and third stages), medium and large larvae (fourth and fifth stages) and resulted in a cotton yield (2.72 bales ha−1) that was significantly higher (p < 0.01) than the yield from the untreated control plot (0.59 bales ha -1 ). However, the yield from the interplants and food sprayed plot was significantly lower (p < 0.01) than in the insecticide-managed plot (7.12 bales ha−1). Whenever the ratio of predators to Helicoverpa spp. (pests) per metre row of cotton was S 0.5, Helicoverpa pest numbers were maintained below the economic damage threshold. Though not successful in suppressing Helicoverpa spp. numbers, to avoid significant yield loss, further improvement could be made by introducing other potential components to the IPM strategy.

Adult diapause morph of the brown stink bug, Euschistus servus (Say) (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae)

The brown stink bug, Euschistus servus (Say), is abundant throughout most of eastern North America and is commonly found feeding on soybean, mullein, beans, tomatoes, peas, cotton, wheat, corn, tobacco and peach. Color change in E. servus from green to reddish-brown was shown to be an indicator of reproductive diapause. Reddish-brown insects lived longer than green individuals, females laid no eggs, and males did not produce pheromone. The high mortality registered for the green colony of E. servus adults was associated with the physiological cost associated with reproduction. The main pheromone component of this species is methyl 2E,4Z-decadienoate, in agreement with previous work. The first generation of this species develops on noncrop hosts and the second generation often migrates to crops where they may then exceed economic damage thresholds. Traps or trap crops baited with pheromone to catch or concentrate females for destruction, or even a pheromone-based disruption of orientation behavior to decrease the mating success, are possible semiochemical techniques to suppress populations of second generation of E. servus.

Biology of the Legume Pod Borer, Maruca vitrata (Fabricius) and Its Damage to Pigeonpea and Adzuki bean

The biology, insect density-yield loss relationships, genotype reactions, and consumption and utilisation of food by the legume pod borer, Maruca vitrata (Fabricius) on pigeonpea (Cajanus cajan)and Adzuki bean (Phaseolus angularis) were studied. Post-embryonic development was completed in 20.2 to 22.6 days. Grain yield in plants infested with 2 and 4 larvae was the same as that in uninfested controls, while plants infested with 8 and 16 larvae suffered between 50–68% grain yield loss in pigeonpea and 61–71% in Adzuki bean. Food consumption by third instars was highest on ICPL 90011. This genotype had the lowest approximate digestibility (AD) and efficiency of conversion of ingested food (ECI). The significance of these results in relation to economic damage thresholds is discussed.

Introducing Encarsia lahorensisagainst Dialeurodes citriin Israel: a case of successful biological control

The parasitoid Encarsialahorensis has been present in Israel since its import in 1980 for biological control of Dialeurodes citri, a serious pest of citrus. The larvae of D. citri secrete honey dew, which is colonized by sooty mould fungi, leading to aesthetic impairment of the fruit as well as leaf drop and yield loss. In a process which took about 3years, the parasitoid reduced the pest to low levels and maintained the population beneath the economic damage threshold for several years. This study, carried out in a citrus orchard during the years1987–1991, was intended to demonstrate the existence of efficient biological control by comparing the pest populations before and after the unhindered introduction of the natural enemy to a new region. In the course of two years, the pest population decreased from a peak level of 122 eggs to 2–7 per half-leaf. Concurrently, the population of the vulnerable fourth nymphal in star decreased from a maximum of 12 to 3 perhalf-leaf. Thereafter, D. citri was maintained at this low level, with peaks of parasitism ranging from20 to 50%. It was concluded that D. citri is under successful biological control in Israel by the specific parasitoid E. lahorensis.

Evaluation of injectable abamectin to control natural infestations of Haematobia irritans (Diptera: Muscidae) in cattle.

The effect of 200 micrograms/kg of body weight of injectable 1% abamectin to control Hematobia irritans (L.) was evaluated in heifers treated every 45 or 63 d versus control heifers. Fly numbers were estimated every 7 d with additional counts on days 1, 4, and 10 after treatment. Samples of feces were obtained up to 28 d after treatment from treated and control heifers to culture H. irritans in the laboratory. The H. irritans population reduction for 14 d after treatment ranged from 51% (3rd treatment of heifers treated every 45 d) to > 73% in the 1st treatments of both groups of heifers and the 2nd treatment of the group treated every 63 d. Medication every 45 d did not provide a better control than treatment every 63 d. The abamectin arrested the immature stages for 7 d after the 1st treatment; this period increased to 28 d after the 3rd treatment but its effect on heifer infestation was low, probably because of fly immigration. Abamectin may help maintain H. irritans populations below the threshold of economic damage.

Strawberry fruit yield and quality responses to flower bud removal: A simulation of damage by strawberry blossom weevil (Anthonomus rubi)

SummaryThe effect of flower bud severing (with scissors) on the yield and fruit quality of strawberry (cv. Elsanta) grown on raised, polythene-mulched beds varied with plant size and numbers of flower buds per plant. On very small plants (with an average of seven flower buds and yielding 105 g of fruit per plant) severing reduced yield in direct proportion to the proportion of flower buds severed, irrespective of whether severing included or did not include removal of the primary (first node) flower bud. There was no evidence of crop compensation. On larger plants (with 24, 70 and 117 flower buds and yielding 0.34 kg, 0.73 kg and 1.16 kg of fruit per plant respectively) severing up to 12 buds per plant did not significantly affect yield: mean berry weight increased by up to 11% and the percentage fruit (by number) in quality class I increased from 67% to 72% in response to severing. Two mechanisms of yield compensation were, apparent i) an increase in mean berry weight, and ii) the maturing of alternative replacement flower buds. Severing slightly delayed by 1–2 d the date by when 10% and 25% of fruit was picked. Implications for the economic damage threshold for flower bud severing by the strawberry blossom weevil are discussed.

PLASMO: a simulation model for control of Plasmopara viticola on grapevine1

The problem of protecting grapevine against diseases is an old one, but in the last few years new techniques have been developed to reduce cost to the farmer and damage to the ecosystem. These are based on mathematical models describing the state of the plant‐parasite environment system. A model for forecasting development of grapevine downy mildew (Plasmopara viticola) is presented. The input variables are temperature, rainfall and leaf wetness (determining infection by sporangia), and RH and temperature (for incubation period). The model also takes into account the limited survival of spores. The output is expressed as %, disease progress. Field validation tests, performed in 1990, 1991 and 1992 in several vineyards in Toscana (central Italy) showed a good correlation between observed and simulated infections. The model allowed the number of treatments to be reduced without any increase in downy mildew damage. It could in future be integrated with grapevine growth and development simulation models in an expert system to determine infected tissue area and thus the economic damage threshold.

DAMAGE-ACTION THRESHOLDS FOR WEEDS IN NEWLY PLANTED APPLE ORCHARDS

The development and implementation of economic damage thresholds have helped to reduce insecticide and fungicide usage in fruit production. However, herbicides are still routinely applied by calendar date in orchards, because damage-action thresholds have not been established for weeds. For two years we have evaluated different temporal and spatial combinations of tree-row weed suppression in a newly planted apple orchard. Tree growth, nutrient uptake and groundcover species mixtures have been analyzed yearly. Observations to date indicate that the timing of weed suppression was more critical than the area, in both wet (1992) and dry (1991) summers. Few significant differences were observed comparing tree growth or nutrient uptake in 2.4 or 6m2 weed-free tree-row plots. Early summer weed control appeared to be more beneficial than mid- or late-summer control during both years. Grasses became dominant in early summer treatments, while broadleaf weed cover increased in late summer treatments. These observations indicate that treating a narrow band with post-emergence hebicides may be sufficient to ensure adequate apple tree establishment in some sites.

Evaluating the economic damage threshold for bont tick (Amblyomma hebraeum) control in Zimbabwe.

Controlling ticks and tick-borne diseases by frequent applications of acaricides (e.g., dipping) is costly, and can leave treated livestock vulnerable to epizootics of tick-borne diseases should the system of applying acaricides break down. The concept of only applying acaricides on an infrequent (strategic) basis often relies on the target tick population displaying a seasonal cycle. However, as adult bont tick (Amblyomma hebraeum) infestations in Zimbabwe's lowveld do not have a strictly seasonal pattern of occurrence, it is recommended that tick control only be applied when bont tick infestations are equal to, or greater than, their economic damage threshold. The economic damage threshold is the minimum average weekly standard female tick burden sufficient to cause damage equal in dollar value to the costs of applying tick control. Assuming that each standard female tick represents a 10 gram weight loss, the economic damage threshold (standard female ticks/week) is equivalent to the ratio of the producer price of beef (liveweight equivalent): per head cost of dipping (Eqn (3)). To illustrate the application of the threshold methodology, it was assumed that the producer price of beef was Z$1.63/kg (U.S.$0.33/kg) and that tick control cost Z$0.29/hd/dip (U.S.$0.06/hd/dip). This gave a threshold of 18 standard female ticks/head/week. Using tick counts obtained from 20 Brahman cattle held at Mbizi in southeastern Zimbabwe, it was shown that for the 1988 calendar year there were only 32 weeks when the economic damage threshold was met or exceeded. This is substantially less that the 44 dippings per year that have been, until very recently, legally required in Zimbabwe. Sensitivity analysis showed that a 10% rise in the cost of dipping reduced to 23 (a 28% decrease) the number of weeks when tick burdens exceeded the economic damage threshold. By further assuming that an acaricide application and residual effects will cause a 3-5 week interval before the next application may be required, the number of weeks when the tick burden was equal to or greater than the threshold of 18 standard females/week fell to just 9-12 weeks. Three factors may cause an alteration in the economic damage threshold: i) tick burdens may cause damage to the udders; ii) secondary infestations (e.g., screw-worm) may cause economic damage; and iii) nutritional stress of the cattle may reduce the actual average per tick weight loss.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

A comparison of vector population indices for forecasting barley yellow dwarf virus in autumn sown cereal crops

SummaryTwo approaches based on the concept of a vector population index are considered as possible deterministic elements for an empirical forecast of barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV) in autumn sown cereals. The first, an aerial vector index, is a further elaboration of the infectivity index proposed by Plumb, Lennon &amp; Gutteridge (1981), which assumes that virus damage is a function of the number of infective migrant alatae of the two main aphid vectors, Rhopalosiphum padi L. and Sitobion avenae F., integrated over time from crop planting or emergence. The new formulation, however, excludes holocyclic alate morphs (i.e. males and gynoparae) of the former species, which, although generally abundant in autumn, are nevertheless perceived as relatively unimportant virus vectors since they colonise only the alternative woody host, Prunus padus (the bird‐cherry tree). The second approach, a crop vector index, is a more fundamental departure which argues that field populations of viruliferous aphids, both alatae and apterae, which have already colonised cereals, may be a better criterion of potential virus spread than the density of aerial migrant vectors. This index retains a similar integral form, but evaluates crop exposure to BYDV as accumulated infectious aphid‐days. A method is described whereby this function can be derived from irregular or infrequent aphid samples in the crop. Both methods, unlike Plumb's (1976) original concept, produced indices which were significantly related to subsequent virus infection and yield loss in winter barley at Long Ashton (S.W. England, UK), 1978–1986. The best models were obtained with the crop vector index, fitted to observed virus infection by generalised linear regression using a complementary log‐log link function, or to observed yield loss by simple linear regression using a log transformation of yield (r = 0.84 in each case; compared with r‐values &gt; 0.65 for the aerial vector index, and &gt; 0.35 for Plumb's (1976) index). However, the residual errors and hence confidence limits of these fitted regressions were too large for predicting damage that was significantly less than a reasonable economic damage threshold for BYDV control.Analyses of the separate components of each index showed a good general relationship between aphid infectivity and the severity of crop infection, confirming the epidemiological importance of this factor. The functional expressions of aphid density, however, were not significant. This evident weakness in the models, and alternative approaches to BYDV forecasting are discussed.

Economic damage thresholds of Spodoptera littoralis (Boisd.) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) on cotton in Egypt

A simple but effective method is presented of assessing damage caused by the cotton leafworm, Spodoptera littoralis, on cotton. A minimum economic damage threshold of 10 000 egg masses/ha was found to be a practical level for most years in Fayoum, Egypt.