Economically Research Articles

Economic Analysis of Falls in a Private Hospital in Southern Brazil-A Case-Control Study.

In-hospital falls represent significant health and economic concerns, but previous studies regarding the economic cost of falls do not account for other cofounders (comorbidities and clinical aspects) in this cost evaluation. The aim of this study is to analyse the cost of in-hospital falls comparing those who had falls to nonfalls patients while accounting for several risk factors associated with falls. Data were collected from January 2020 to December 2022, in a private hospital in Brazil. The sample was divided into two groups: one with patients who fell and the other with nonfallers on a 1:2 ratio, and these groups were matched to avoid confounding variables. The median cost for patients who experienced falls was US$7520.26 compared to US$6144.24 for those without falls (p < 0.01). This trend was especially marked in men aged 20-40 who suffered falls and showed a significantly elevated median cost of US$29 722.02 distinguishing them from those without falls with a median cost of US$1179.48 (p < 0.01). Hospital falls significantly increase financial costs compared to nonfall cases, irrespective of comorbidities, length of stay or case-mix variations. The findings recommend a universal precautions approach to fall prevention in hospitals, targeting all hospitalised patients to effectively minimise the economic burden associated with in-hospital falls.

Optimizing Energy Yield and Economic Benefit of Renewable Energy Technologies for Urban Mediterranean Dwellings

Mediterranean European cities are characterized by high population density and limited space for large-scale implementation of renewable energy installations. This paper addresses the optimization of renewable energy installations in Mediterranean dwellings with the scope of increasing their energy contribution and cost-effectiveness. In a case study for Malta, the three technologies studied were solar photovoltaics, solar water heating, and heat pump water heating. Technical and economic analyses were performed on a number of reference configurations using Polysun software (version 2022.8). Sensitivity analyses were also conducted to study the impact that different technical and economic factors have on the performance of the configurations considered. Finally, comparisons were made between the techno-economic results obtained from the reference and sensitivity analyses. Based on data collected, the presence of renewable energy source (RES) technologies in the residential sector of Malta was characterized and correlated with the types of dwellings considered. Among the results obtained, it was found that although a solar RES installation may experience some shading, this does not mean that it is rendered economically unfeasible. Moreover, from the simulations conducted, electrical energy storage technology was considered as too premature unless strongly subsidized, making economic sense only in specific circumstances. On the other hand, although heat pump water heating technology is also relatively modern, it was concluded to be the most beneficial in terms of both energy yield and economic benefit, generally speaking. Furthermore, it was determined that in a higher occupancy dwelling, solar water heating (SWH) and heat pump water heating (HPWH) result in considerably more attractive energy savings.

Pharmacoeconomic analysis of rituximab and belimumab therapy in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus

The progressive course of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) with high activity and severe internal organs involvement requires the prescription of expensive biologic disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs (bDMARDs), rituximab (RTM) and belimumab (BLM), whose comparative clinical and economic efficacy has not been adequately studied.Objective: to evaluate the clinical and economic efficacy of RTM and BLM therapy in patients with SLE.Material and methods. The study included 50 SLE patients who were divided into two groups and received RTM (group 1, n=25) or BLM (group 2, n=25) therapy for 12 months. The clinical and economic analysis was performed with the cost-effectiveness method using the cost-per-responder (CPR) model. A clinically significant improvement in SLEDAI-2K (Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Disease Activity Index modified 2K; Δ ≥4) was considered a response to therapy. Direct and indirect costs were considered in the analysis.Results and discussion. Against a background of therapy, there was a decrease in SLE activity with a decrease in median SLEDAI-2K in group 1 from 12 [10.5; 18] to 8 [4; 10] and in group 2 from 10 [8; 14.5] to 4 [2; 4] (p&lt; 0.001 in both cases). A clinically significant improvement was observed in 56% of patients in group 1 and 72% of patients in group 2. The peculiarities of the BLM dosing regimen caused higher (1.7 times) total costs than in the case of RTM. According to the CPR value, RTM showed a greater benefit (1.3 times) than BLM (954 thousand rubles versus 1.25 million rubles). The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was 1.4 million rubles, which does not exceed the threshold of willingness to pay for a domestic patient.Conclusion. When comparing BLM and RTM therapy for SLE patients in real-life clinical practice, greater clinical and economic efficiency was demonstrated for RTM. BLM therapy was found to be “cost-effective”.

Leveraging extensive soil, vegetation, fire, and land treatment data to inform restoration across the sagebrush biome

ContextWidespread ecological degradation has prompted calls for massive global investments in ecological restoration, yet limited resources necessitate efficient application of restoration efforts. In western North America, altered fire regimes are increasing the scale of restoration needed to preserve the sagebrush (Artemisia species) biome but prioritizing and implementing effective restoration is complicated by the vast and heterogeneous sagebrush landscape, which includes gradients in climate, disturbance, and species composition.ObjectivesTo develop spatially explicit and context-dependent estimates of treatment efficacy and sagebrush recovery rates.MethodsWe leveraged a suite of spatio-temporally extensive datasets to evaluate the influence of restoration treatments and environmental conditions on trends in post-disturbance sagebrush cover, with an emphasis on understanding differences between sites recovering naturally and sites receiving restoration treatments. We used estimates from these models to develop spatially explicit projections for sagebrush recovery, conditional on disturbance, restoration practice, and environmental conditions.ResultsWe found seeding Artemisia spp. increased sagebrush cover over time relative to natural recovery, but this relationship depended on spring soil moisture availability and treatment methods. Natural recovery was positively influenced by soil moisture and sagebrush cover and negatively influenced by cumulative burns and annual herbaceous cover, while the influence of perennial herbaceous cover varied with soil moisture.ConclusionsOur results provide biome-wide insights and spatially explicit tools that can inform economic cost-effectiveness analyses, restoration prioritization tools, and other scientific endeavors to ensure managers have the tools and information needed to effectively steward the sagebrush biome in a rapidly changing world.

Epistemic silences, subversive politics: post-disaster economic assessments as technologies of persistent coloniality and route to an emancipatory climate justice agenda in the Caribbean

ABSTRACT Economic analyses of losses and damages or post-disaster needs assessments (PDNAs) are silent about the longstanding reparatory claims related to the legacies of African enslavement, colonial violence and indigenous dispossession that compound uneven racialized geographies in the Caribbean. This paper unpacks these so-called ‘objective’ valuations drawing attention to their (neo)liberal framings, technocratic underpinnings, and historical origins in the Caribbean plantation economy. Using case studies of catastrophic hurricanes Matthew (2016), Irma (2017) and Dorian (2019) in Haiti, Antigua and Barbuda, and The Bahamas respectively, the paper exposes critical tensions, knowledge hierarchies, and contradictions embedded within empirical assessments that justify and prioritize preferred policies of powerful international development, financial and governance institutions. PDNAs under-value and neglect important community and local knowledge, solidarity practices, cultural institutions, and relational ethics in the face of climate disasters in these Caribbean islands. Taking a Black geographies and political economy approach, the paper addresses the limitations and risks associated with PDNAs, deemed political tools or technologies of climate disaster that reinforce oppression. To advance an emancipatory climate justice agenda to enable more radical reparative measures and possibilities, the paper suggests that analyses and political strategy must be grounded in people's history, cultural, ethical, and communal governance practices.

Thermodynamics and economic analysis of a two-stage desiccant cooling (TSDC) system based on biomass heating used for greenhouse application

Thermodynamics and economic analysis of a two-stage desiccant cooling (TSDC) system based on biomass heating used for greenhouse application

Modeling and economic analysis of block absorber (RadFrac) performance with stage variations for post-combustion CO2 capture

This study presents a comprehensive modeling and economic evaluation of a Monoethanolamine (MEA)-based post-combustion carbon capture (PCC) absorber unit. The simulation provides detailed insights into the absorber's internal profiles, including temperature gradients and the percentage of CO2 captured, with a particular focus on the effects of varying the number of stages and absorber diameters. Validation against experimental data demonstrated close alignment between simulated and observed values, with an average Root Mean Square Deviation (RMSD) of 0.018 and 4.0129, respectively, confirming the reliability of the simulation in capturing the complex dynamics of the absorber.The economic analysis, conducted using the Aspen Process Economic Analyzer (APEA), simplified the complex relationship between absorber segmentation, capital and operational costs, and absorber diameter. The study revealed that increasing the absorber diameter and the number of stages leads to a significant rise in Total Capital Cost (TCC), Total Operating Cost (TOC), Equipment Cost, and Total Installed Cost (TIC), with the highest costs observed at a stage number of 90 and a diameter of 1.0 m. However, the analysis identified an optimal configuration at an absorber diameter of 0.45 m with either 10 or 20 stages. This setup effectively balances cost and CO2 capture efficiency, offering a more economical solution compared to configurations with larger diameters and higher stage numbers, which substantially increase expenses. The findings highlight the critical trade-offs between operational efficiency and capital expenditure, stressing on the crucial role of absorber diameter in determining the economic feasibility of the absorber block in PCC systems.

Optimization of Manure-Based Substrate Preparation to Reduce Nutrients Losses and Improve Quality for Growth of Agaricus bisporus

With the growing world population, food demand has also increased, resulting in increased agricultural waste and livestock manure production. Wheat straw and cow dung are rich nutrient sources and, if not utilized properly, may lead to environmental pollution. Keeping in view the cultivation of Agaricus bisporus on straw/manure-based substrate, the current study aimed to optimize the conventional manure preparation technique to reduce nutrient losses and keep the quality of manure at its best. The treatments were considered as traditional and optimized schemes for mushroom substrate preparation. The results achieved herein indicated that the nutrient losses were low in the optimum scheme. For carbon (C), the loss was 43.55% at the substrate stage in the traditional scheme and reduced to 37.75% in the optimum scheme. In the case of nitrogen (N), the loss was 22.01% in the traditional scheme and was lower (18.49%) in the optimum scheme. The nutrient concentration in Agaricus bisporus was higher with the optimum scheme compared with the traditional scheme. It was 1.74% for C, 7.17% for N, 3.58% for phosphorus (P), and 4.92% for potassium (K). The optimum scheme also improved the Agaricus bisporus yield per unit area (84.55%) and the total yield (28.92%). The net income of the optimum scheme was 102.95% higher compared to the traditional scheme. The economic analysis also revealed that the benefit–cost ratio of the optimum scheme was high (48.86%) compared with the traditional scheme. This study concludes that the use of the optimum scheme can better utilize the wheat straw and cow manure waste for substrate preparation and reducing nutrient losses. In addition, the final mushroom residue can also be used as a leftover substrate for further utilization.

Innovations for Holistic and Sustainable Transitions

Energy system planning has evolved from a narrow focus on engineering and supply works towards addressing more complex, multifactorial challenges. Increasingly challenged by climate change, extreme events, economic shocks, and altered supply demand patterns, the analysis of energy systems requires holistic approaches based on data-driven models, taking into account key socio-economic factors. We draw insights from reviewing the literature, indicating the need to cover the following major gaps: the shift to transdisciplinary approaches, incorporating environmental system analysis; resilient and sustainable energy designs based on flexible portfolios of renewable mixes; the integration of socio-economic aspects, economic analyses and behavioural models to ensure energy systems are not only technically sound but socially acceptable and viable; the need for stakeholder engagement considering the human angle in energy security and behavioural shifts. Responding to these pressing challenges and emerging needs, the Global Climate Hub (GCH) initiative, operating under the UN Sustainable Development Solutions Network, offers a conceptual framework, leveraging transdisciplinary approaches. In this Concept Paper, we present for the first time the idea of the GCH as a framework that we believe has the potential to address the modern holistic needs for energy system analysis and policymaking. By setting the conceptual/theoretical ground of our suggested approach, we aim to provide guidance for innovative combinations of cutting-edge models, socio-economic narratives, and inclusive interaction with relevant stakeholders for the development and the long-term implementation of sustainable pathways.

Improved access and care through the implementation of virtual Hallway, a consultation platform in Nova Scotia: preliminary findings from a feasibility evaluation

BackgroundWhile previous studies have examined various platforms that enable providers to connect, Virtual Hallway (VH) stands out with its unique features. The value add is that this online platform connects primary care providers and specialists for synchronous phone-based conversations and aims to reduce referrals and enhance the quality of referrals. VH allows providers to easily log in, select the required specialty, book call times, receive reminders, and have calls documented, ensuring a high connection rate. In May 2022, the provincial health authority in Nova Scotia, a Canadian province, and VH initiated a feasibility study facilitated through the Health Innovation Hub in Nova Scotia. The goal was to enable primary care providers to connect with specialists, thereby reducing wait times and unnecessary referrals, and facilitating timely access to relevant clinical direction for patients. The current evaluation assessed utilization, value for money in economic analysis, and consultation experiences.MethodsThe study used post, cross-sectional, and cost-benefit study designs. We collected data through various methods, including administratively recorded utilization, theory-driven surveys, and cost data. Utilization was measured by the number of completed consults and the number of healthcare professionals using the VH platform. We analyzed the data using a combination of descriptive statistics and a cost-benefit analysis, which also involved conducting probabilistic sensitivity analysis.ResultsThe study found that approximately 84% of the VH consultations avoided needing in-person specialist referrals. The return on investment was 1.8 (95% CI: 0.8 to 3.0), indicating that the monetary value of the measurable benefits associated with VH exceeded the value of the resources invested. The provider experience survey revealed high satisfaction levels with VH across user groups, with 92% of specialists and 96% of primary care providers reporting being satisfied or highly satisfied with their experience. These positive indicators of provider experience were further supported by the fact that 97% of respondents agreed or strongly agreed that they intended to continue to use VH in their practice, and 97% of respondents agreed or strongly agreed that they would recommend VH to a colleague.ConclusionsThe study suggests that VH was well-received by users, with high levels of satisfaction reported and a reduced need for in-person referrals. It also represented value for money. Further research could explore how the availability of virtual health services can lead to reduced utilization of healthcare resources among different groups of patients.

Techno-economic optimization and feasibility of PCM-based seasonal thermal energy storage systems for district heating and cooling

Phase change materials (PCM) are an attractive seasonal thermal energy storage solution for load shifting due to relatively high energy density. Nevertheless, the choice of the right design parameters, such as storage size and phase-change temperature, is nontrivial, as these are tightly linked to the expected seasonal operation of the storage. This paper presents a combined design and operation optimization framework for sizing PCM-based seasonal thermal storage, which can capture dynamic behaviour of the storage in sensible and latent phases, and its impact on the efficiency of connected heat pumps and chillers. The proposed method, formulated as a mixed integer quadratically-constrained programming problem, was applied to a case study of heating-dominated district. It was found that the optimal PCM melting temperature equals to the heating demand supply temperature, thus removing the need of a heat pump to discharge the storage. The optimal operation of storage requires a full charging and discharging cycle of both latent and liquid phase. Higher CO2 emission price does not lead to a significant reduction of CO2 emissions, but the storage size does, leading to a higher heating coverage ratio of the storage, and consequently CO2 emissions and cost savings, which can be further enhanced with PV integration. The economic analysis indicates that, unless other benefits such as storage volume reduction are accounted for, PCM cost should drop by a factor 4 to make this solution economically viable for seasonal storage.

The decriminalization of illicit drugs in British Columbia: a national evaluation protocol

BackgroundOn January 31st, 2023, the province of British Columbia (BC), Canada, was granted a federal exemption allowing adults (aged 18 +) to possess up to 2.5 g of select illicit drugs. The exemption will be in place for three years (2023–2026), marking the first formal decriminalization of illicit drug policy reform in Canada. BC’s decriminalization initiative is premised on several goals. This project seeks to evaluate each of these goals and their individual and combined contributions to determine the overall success of this policy.MethodsThe following protocol paper provides a detailed outline of a five-year (2022-2027) national evaluation of BC’s decriminalization initiative, as well as the specific objectives, methodologies, and planned analyses for eight interrelated sub-studies that comprise the evaluation. These sub-studies fall under the following five topical areas of research: 1) people who use drugs (PWUD), 2) the police and the criminal justice system, 3) the general public, 4) the health services system, and 5) an economic analysis. Additional research activities may also be explored.ResultsThe overall evaluation and specific sub-study designs were informed by intensive stakeholder engagement. The evaluation was developed in collaboration with an international expert committee who came together to undertake a nominal group technique to decide on the final evaluation design and corresponding logic model. The evaluation will also employ an advisory board and individual sub-study working groups comprised of experts and PWUD who will oversee the development and implementation of the overall evaluation as well as each sub-study.DiscussionThis evaluation will draw on implementation science research practices to evaluate and understand the full impacts of this novel drug policy experiment. Results will be widely disseminated through manuscripts, reports, presentations, and infographics, which will be adapted and tailored for specific audiences. The protocol identifies several anticipated challenges and limitations. This evaluation’s evidence-based findings will be poised to offer pivotal insights that can shape and refine the discourse on drug policy and will serve as a critical resource for understanding the multifaceted impacts of decriminalization.

Modelling ℤ-valued time series with Skellam thinning-based INAR(1) process

ABSTRACT Non-stationary count time series, which are small in value and show a trend having relatively large fluctuation, are commonly encountered in real-world applications. Differencing is a commonly employed method to transform a non-stationary time series into a stationary one. However, the differenced count time series is defined on Z and cannot be fitted by the mainstream count time series models, which are defined on N 0 . Although some integer-valued autoregressive (INAR) models based on the signed thinning operator have been proposed for fitting Z -valued time series, these models still encounter difficulties in terms of data generation mechanism, model selection, and parameter estimation. These difficulties may pose challenges for practitioners in practical applications. Therefore, this article utilizes the reparameterized version of the Skellam (Poisson difference) distribution to construct a new thinning operator, thereby introducing a class of Z -valued time series models. Strict stationarity, ergodicity, statistical properties, and parameter estimation methods of the processes are detailedly discussed. An application to the monthly counts of newly listed companies illustrates that the new model is superior in data analysis of finance and economics.

Transport innovations in the cracks: reading for potential post-growth transport and mobilities with Deleuze and Guattari

ABSTRACT The post-growth literature has recently started to engage with transport and mobilities in more depth. However, despite its radical societal critique, it has done so largely in ways that either reproduce recommendations of the sustainable mobilities paradigm or apply context-independent post-growth frameworks without sustained empirical analysis. The literature has thereby largely “closed down” more open-ended explorations of what kind of transport and mobility futures are desirable and possible from a post-growth perspective. This article seeks to remedy this by highlighting the role of innovative practices in bottom-up initiatives that have been invisibilised, in expanding our imaginaries of possible post-growth transport and mobility futures. It builds on Deleuze and Guattari’s concept of the minor, an orientation towards difference-in-itself emerging immanently, to explore such innovative and experimental practices that may be of interest for post-growth transformations. We illustrate the minor’s usefulness by studying two bottom-up initiatives, a French railway cooperative and a German “rolling supermarket”, which we examine with a view towards “difference” that allows for open-endedness and the generation of questions. This article contributes to post-growth transport and mobility scholarship by advocating for a shift in three analytical focal points, building on the minor’s generativity: moving from a-contextual recommendations to examinations of socio-spatially specific transformation (1), from a concern for the “right” modes of transport to minorities (2), and from a near-exclusive focus on the public sector to a more diverse range of economic actors and practices (3).

Economic Decisions and Cultural Trauma: A Sociological Exploration of Macro-level Policies and Societal Perceptions

The article delves into the intricate relationship between macroeconomic policies and cultural trauma. It argues that economic decisions, typically confined to corporate and legislative realms, significantly impact communities by shaping collective memories, identities, and psychological distress. The study highlights historical events like The Great Depression and the COVID-19 pandemic, underscoring their transformative impacts on societal consciousness and cultural narratives. The article emphasizes the role of macroeconomic choices, such as fiscal policies and trade agreements, in creating collective experiences that transcend economic outcomes. Using examples like trade liberalization in Brazil, it demonstrates how economic policies can lead to diverse societal perceptions and narratives. The article also examines the role of media, public discourse, and societal leaders in shaping public perceptions of these decisions. Central to the study are the contributions of cultural sociologists like Jeffrey C. Alexander, who propose that cultural trauma arises more from societal narratives around an event rather than the event itself. The study stresses the need for a comprehensive approach that integrates economic analysis with sociological insights, highlighting the importance of understanding economic decisions beyond their immediate financial implications. Conclusively, the article posits that macroeconomic decisions have profound and lasting impacts on societies, influencing collective identities and memories. It advocates for policies and scholarly approaches that acknowledge the broader societal ramifications of these decisions.

Drying ripe mangoes using a step-down industrial microwave-hot air belt dryer

A microwave-hot air belt dryer (MHABD) showed high specific energy consumption (SEC) due to its limited material processing capacity and extended drying time. Thus, this research presents the development and performance evaluation of an industrial microwave-hot air belt dryer (IMHABD) for drying Namdokmai Sithong mango slices. The IMHABD system, optimized using the COMSOL Multiphysics program, features a 0.9 m × 4.08 m × 0.5 m chamber with 36 magnetrons having a maximum microwave power of 28,800 W (each magnetron produces 800 W) at a frequency of 2,450 MHz. Two drying methods were studied, step-down microwave power drying (IMHABD-S) and constant microwave power drying (IMHABD-C). IMHABD-S, with a power range of 150–350 W combined with hot air at 65 °C, outperformed IMHABD-C, delivering enhanced drying rates, improved color attributes, and reduced shrinkage, along with decreased hardness and toughness values. All dried slices had a water activity lower than 0.6. An IMHABD-S operated at 350 W for 1.5 h showed the lowest SEC. Economic analysis revealed strong support for the IMHABD process, with a net present value (NPV) of 13,647 USD, an internal rate of return (IRR) of 15%, and a 4.95-year payback with a 10-year service life, highlighting its technical efficacy and economic viability for mango drying applications.

An early economic analysis of medical cannabis for the treatment of chronic pain

ABSTRACT Background Cannabis-based medicinal products (CBMPs) are increasingly demonstrating effectiveness in treating a wide range of conditions, with a relatively high safety profile in clinical usage compared to other prescription pain medications and few contraindications. Consultation and other prescription-related costs are, at present, higher for CBMPs than for some other treatment options, leading to some concern around wider prescribing. Research design and Methods An early cost-effectiveness model was developed to estimate the impact of prescribing CBMPs alone and/or in addition to analgesics, physiotherapy, and cognitive behavioral therapy for chronic pain in the UK for 1 year. Results Due to their comparative effectiveness, CBMPs were found to be cost saving. Various scenarios were model tested; in all scenarios where CBMPs decrease pain-level states, less resource use is required. Increased efficacy of 5% was conservatively assumed based on current Real-World Evidence. In this scenario, CBMPs were significantly more cost-effective, and as costs relating to the prescribing of these continue to fall, relative savings are predicted to increase. Conclusion These findings highlight the substantial cost saving that CBMPs may represent for the treatment of chronic pain patients, and the benefits for healthcare providers as a treatment for this often hard-to-treat population.

Optimizing cord pyramid solar distillers: A comprehensive study on square baffles, reflectors, and phase transition materials

Limited access to safe drinking water is a critical global issue, particularly in areas with inadequate infrastructure. Solar stills offer a promising alternative for such regions. This study investigates the influence of square baffles within a modified solar still design on its overall efficiency. Additionally, the integration of reflectors is explored to enhance both evaporation and condensation rates. Furthermore, the effectiveness of a paraffin wax phase change material (PCM) combined with silver nanoparticles is assessed within the modified still. Thermo-economic analyses are conducted to evaluate the economic feasibility of the proposed system. The findings demonstrate a significant improvement in distillation yield. The modified still with square baffles achieved a yield of 9800 mL/m2.day compared to 3550 mL/m2.day for the reference still, representing a 193 % increase. Moreover, incorporating the nano-PCM at an optimal configuration (25 cords) resulted in a further 265 % productivity increase for the modified still with both square baffles and reflectors. This configuration also achieved an efficiency of 63 %. Economic analysis revealed a minimal cost difference between the reference still (0.014 $/L) and the modified still with square baffles and nano-PCM (0.01 $/L). In terms of environmental impact, the modified still exhibited a lower annual CO2 emission of 28.8 tons.

Economic Growth and Democratic Political System in Developing Countries

The relationship between a democratic political system and economic growth has been the focus of debate in recent years. This article is a contribution to the economic analysis of the relationship between democracy and economic growth. Using an econometric illustration of panel data from twenty developing countries, in a period from 2000 to 2021, Fixed-effect, random-effect and GMM model estimates show that a democratic political regime positively affects economic growth in developing countries. This result is explained by the importance of the role of democracy in implementing economic and social reforms, encouraging investment, opening up trade and protecting civil liberties and political powers.

Can molecular oscillation technology be used as an alternative to acid injection to prevent the clogging of emitters in drip irrigation systems?

AbstractIn this study, molecular oscillation technology (Merus ring), developed to prevent calcification, biofilm formation and corrosion in piping in industrial water treatment systems, was compared as an alternative to acid injection to prevent the clogging of emitters by chemicals, and fresh and saline water were compared on the basis of system performance parameters (coefficient of variation, distribution uniformity, Christiansen uniformity, emission uniformity) and economic aspects. The results revealed that both acid injection and the Merus ring in saline and fresh water resulted in significantly higher average emitter flow rates than the control treatment. Both the Merus ring and the acid injection achieved higher performance parameters with fresh water than with saline water. Acid injection was found to be more effective in preventing clogging of the emitters than the Merus ring when saline water was used. Compared with fresh water, saline water increases emitter clogging. The economic analysis revealed that the Merus ring was more economical ($204.3 ha−1) than acid injection with both fresh water ($318.2 ha−1) and saline water ($578.6 ha−1). Therefore, the Merus ring could be a reliable and environmentally friendly alternative to acid injection to prevent the clogging of emitters in drip systems when saline water is used.