Ecological Paradigm Research Articles

What makes a successful industrial heritage park?—China's experience based on the ecosystem cultural services perspective

<abstract> <p>The transformation of downtown industrial spaces is prevalent in cities in China and the global South. Because of economic development and social transformation, former factories no longer carry out production activities and are abandoned. Industrial heritage parks, as integrated urban parks with new cultural and ecological paradigms, provide unique cultural ecosystem services (CES) that contribute to the sustainable development of urban renewal. Assessing their CES to identify public satisfaction is essential for urban green space planning and management and for enhancing human well-being. Thus, we tried to investigate public perceptions of CES in industrial heritage parks and explored the relationship between public satisfaction with CES and high-quality industrial heritage parks. Using importance-satisfaction analysis (ISA) to assess CES based on public perceptions, the cultural ecosystem services importance satisfaction analysis (CES-ISA) framework was established. Two successful examples of industrial heritage renewal in China, Qijiang Park, and Shougang Park were selected as case studies. The results indicated that: ⅰ) There is a positive correlation between public importance-satisfaction feedback at the cultural level and high quality industrial heritage parks; ⅱ) the recreational, aesthetic and cultural heritage, and spiritual services provided by industrial heritage parks were the types of CES most valued by the public; ⅲ) improving the sense of place service is key to enhancing public satisfaction and promoting the sustainability of industrial heritage parks; ${\rm{iiii}}$) the CES-ISA framework can identify differences between public perceptions of importance and satisfaction with CES. It is beneficial to obtain management priorities for cultural services in industrial heritage parks.</p> </abstract>

Uncertainties about waste using an online survey and review approach: Environmentalist perceptions, household waste compositions and views from media and science

Abstract Waste generation and subsequent plastic pollution pose a major threat to both human and environmental health. Furthering our understanding of waste at individual levels can inform future waste reduction strategies, education and policies. This study explores the components and perceptions among individuals using survey data combined with a mini-review. An online Qualtrics survey was distributed pre-COVID-19 following a global social media challenge, Futuristic February, which directed participants to collect their nonperishable waste during February 2020. Participants were asked about their waste generation, perceptions toward waste and plastic pollution issues, and environmental worldview using the New Ecological Paradigm (NEP) scale (n = 50). We also conducted a mini-review of eight waste and plastic pollution statements from our survey in both popular media and scientific journal articles. Survey results indicated participants had an overall pro-ecological worldview (M = 4.32, SD = 0.88) and reported cardboard and paper (66%) as the most commonly occurring nonperishable waste category. Across categories, food packaging was the most common waste type. Participants were most uncertain about statements focusing on bioplastic or biodegradable plastic, respectively (44% and 30%), while the statement on microplastic toxicity obtained 100% mild or strong agreement among participants. Uncertainty for reviewed statements varied depending on the topic and group. Popular media and scholarly articles did not always agree, possibly due to differences in communication of uncertainty or terminology definitions. These results can inform future policy and educational campaigns around topics of misinformation.

Psihometrijske karakteristike skale nove ekološke paradigme na srpskom uzorku

Climate change is a growing threat to humanity. Coping with its potentially disastrous effects will require a widespread behavioural change at both the societal and individual levels. Theory and empirical research have emphasised the role of pro-environmental attitudes as antecedents of pro-environmental behaviour. Using a large community Serbian sample (N=871 of adult population), assessed with face-to-face interviews, we searched for the psychometric characteristics of the New Ecological Paradigm scale (NEP), a widely used instrument for assessing the pro-environmental attitudes worldwide. The dimensionality of Dunlap's NEP scale has been called into question frequently, because previous studies revealed three, four, or only one dimension. Hence, there is an ongoing call for the scale's further validation. This has been the first time that the psychometric characteristics of the NEP scale were tested on a large adult sample in Serbia. Further, we tested its predictive power to explain environmental behaviour (using the Environmental Behaviour Questionnaire).

Переводчик как субъект экотранслатологии

The article attempts to establish the connection between Russian-language and Chinese-language concepts that define the modern interdisciplinary ecological paradigm in approaching language, culture, text, discourse, and their interlingual and intercultural interaction in the process of translation. The research is based on the concepts of ecotranslatology developed by Chinese scholars and translation ecology presented in the works of Russian authors. Both concepts form the methodological basis of the research. Within the scope of translation ecology, the concept of translation space developed by L. V. Kushnina is examined, with cognition, synergy, and harmony being its key notions. The ecological approach has expanded the understanding of the fields within the translation space where synergies of meanings occur, leading to harmony, and introduced the notion of an ecofield that deals with eco-senses and eco-concepts. In the realm of ecotranslatology, Hu Genshen, a well-known figure not only in China but also in the West, introduces ideas of ecological balance, multidimensional transformation of text, adaptation to the eco-environment, which determines the ecological nature of translated text and leads to semantic proportionality. The present study deals with texts in three languages – Russian, French, and Chinese. Poetic texts by S. Yesenin and prose texts by V. Bianki were used as originals. Their translations into French and Chinese were analyzed, allowing the authors to perceive an expanded panorama of eco-translation discourse. As a result of the research, the importance of the eco-translation approach to the analysis of translation processes in terms of language-meaning perception and language-meaning generation is demonstrated, leading to the conclusion about the possibility of integrating these two scientific schools to cognize the underlying principles of the translation process and enhance its quality.

Застосування теорії змін в екологізації бізнесу

The article summarizes scientific approaches to the development of the theory of changes in the greening of business. The scientific and methodological approaches to understanding the basics of the theory of change have been developed. The features of the application of the theory of change in the greening of business are presented. The specifics of the development of the theory of changes in the greening of business on the example of Ukraine are revealed. It is determined that for the Ukrainian realities, the greening of business is implemented mainly in the formal plane in the context of compliance with the norms and standards of environmental development, ensuring environmental taxation, control of environmental pollution standards, which slows down the development of the component of the Ukrainian environmental business and hinders the innovative introduction of elements of the ecological paradigm in our country. The theory of change is a rigorous but necessary process by which groups and stakeholders in planning activities formulate their long-term goals and define the conditions that they believe should precede the achievement of these goals. These conditions are modeled as desired outcomes, organized graphically in a causal structure. Change theory describes the types of interventions (a single program or a coordinated initiative) that lead to the outcomes depicted in the outcome map. Each intervention is linked to an outcome in a causal system, revealing the often complex web of actions required to bring about change. Several factors have been found to make it difficult for multinational companies to take action against climate change, such as a lack of certainty about climate policy, a lack of green technologies, and a lack of return on investment. The use of green practices also remains limited in the International Health Standards (IHR) in both developed and developing countries, due to limited access to finance and skills, lack of information and knowledge about innovation, and, in some cases, poor enforcement of rules. It is determined that for a better and more effective application of the norms and provisions of the theory of changes in the greening of business, it is relevant to introduce professional courses for managers and environmental managers of companies, which will direct the professional training of management staff to the implementation of effective environmental changes in business. It is also relevant to introduce the State-based programs to stimulate the development of greening business in terms of indirect (tax incentives for businesses that implement environmental innovations) and direct incentives for the implementation of environmental changes (preferential lending for greening business).

O CONCEITO DE SUSTENTABILIDADE NA MISSÃO DA IGREJA CATÓLICA

The search for sustainable development has always been the target of clashes in the model assumed by today's society. In this sense, it is assumed that the Catholic Church can contribute decisively to this discussion, since, as an institution with more than 2000 years of existence, it has a legacy of socio-environmental teachings that permeate its missionary action in the world. In 2015, Pope Francis strategically published, shortly before COP 21, the social Encyclical Laudato Si, on care for our common home. The document consolidates the principles of the Church's social doctrine, brings the paradigm of integral ecology and proposes the participatory methodology of Laudato Si circles, for the implementation of actions within the local sphere. In this article, the objective was to contribute to a deeper understanding of the sustainability guidelines and practices addressed in the encyclical Laudato Si and, with that, to offer five proposals for local solutions to socio-environmental issues that compromise life and ecosystems as a whole. For this, a bibliographical and exploratory research was carried out, from which it was observed convergence between the social principles consolidated in Laudato Si and sustainable practices, the central proposal of the 2030 Agenda.

Analysis of Environmental Awareness of Tourism Vocational Students in Central Lombok District

The aim of this study is to analyze the level of environmental awareness of Tourism Vocational School students in Central Lombok Regency. The Central Lombok region has various tourism potentials, both natural and cultural potential. The level of environmental awareness of students greatly determines the implementation of behavior to protect the community's environment in implementing various tourism programs in Central Lombok Regency. One of the Basic Competencies of Applied Science at Tourism Vocational Schools discusses waste handling in the tourism sector. This condition places Tourism Vocational School students as one of the main actors in implementing sustainable tourism. This study was conducted using quantitative descriptive research type. The strategy used in this study is an associative strategy. The research instrument in this study used a modified questionnaire from the Waikato Regional Council research report in 2013 entitled "Environmental Awareness, Attitudes and Actions and New Ecological Paradigm Combined Survey: A survey of residents of the Waikato Region ". The respondent sampling technique used in this study was convenience sampling, by distributing questionnaires to respondents using the Google Form application. 142 respondents completed the environmental awareness questionnaire. The results of the study show that the level of environmental awareness of Tourism Vocational School students in Central Lombok Regency is categorized as low

Resilience and the shift of paradigm in ecology: a new name for an old concept or a different explanatory tool?

In the shift from the balance of nature to the flux of nature paradigm, the concept of resilience has gained great traction in ecology. While it has been suggested that the concept of resilience does not imply a genuine departure from the balance of nature paradigm, I shall argue against this stance. To do so, I first show that the balance of nature paradigm and the related conception of a single-state equilibrium relies on what Eliot Sober has named the "Natural State Model (NSM)", suggesting that the NSM has instead been dismissed in the flux of nature paradigm. I then focus on resilience as the main explanatory concept of the flux paradigm. After distinguishing between two main different understandings of "resilience", namely engineering resilience and ecological resilience, I argue that the former is close to the concept of balance or stabilityand still part of the NSM, while the latter is not. Finally, I claim that ecological resilience is inconsistent with the NSM, concluding that this concept-being incompatible with the NSM-is not part of the balance of nature paradigm but rather a genuinely new explanatory tool.

Tornado In The Sea: A Media Transposition of the Barracuda Series Painting into a Musical Composition

This work is the manifestation of the transformation of Zaimie bin Sahibil’s painting, Barracuda Series, into musical form. The Barracuda Series painting presents the beauty and richness of the ocean bed as a utopian paradigm of the maritime ecology of the coastal community of Sabah, Malaysia. The composer was inspired by his own aesthetic experience when appreciating the painting. This aesthetic experience became the material object that was treated with the concept of media transposition and turned into a musical composition. The media transposition was implemented through the interpretation and transformation of the external and internal structural levels of the Barracuda Series painting. These elements were adapted to create musical elements as a form of innovation in the way the composition was created. the creation of this work involved a number of work stages that were implemented constructively through a method of creation. These stages included: an analysis of data sources, experimentation, contemplation, composition, and formation. The work process utilized the results of extra-aesthetic interpretation and intra-aesthetic transformation to create an innovative musical text. The musical composition Tornado in the Sea uses the instrumentation of piano, violin, and kalimba. The stages of creation included an analysis of data sources, experimentation, contemplation, arrangement, formation, and execution.

Exploring Directions for Uzbekistan Pre-service Science Teacher Education on the Ecological Environment

Abstract This study provides a comparative analysis of pre-service science teachers in Uzbekistan and Korea, exploring ecological footprint, ecological worldview, subjective happiness, and pro-environmental behavior. Using a questionnaire whose reliability and validity had been verified, an online and offline survey was conducted targeting pre-science teachers attending teacher education universities: in metropolitan areas in Korea and Uzbekistan. Independent samples t-tests revealed significant findings: Uzbekistani teachers exhibited a lower ecological footprint but shared a similar ecological worldview with their Korean counterparts, while also reporting higher levels of subjective happiness and pro-environmental behavior. The results emphasize the need for science education strategies tailored to Uzbekistan’s context, particularly the development of the new ecological paradigm (NEP). To enhance subjective happiness and pro-environmental behavior, we suggest employing pedagogical approaches such as case-based or phenomenon-based learning. This research underscores the importance of contextualization, with NEP development, and practical methodologies among Uzbekistani students.

EU green deal: between ecological transition and the struggle for power maintenance

Environmental, social, humanitarian, and economic crises are part of the contemporary world. The exceeding of Earth's limits manifests in various ways, including climate change, whose effects are already impacting various regions of the planet. Although this issue has been discussed for decades and subject to extensive international legal regulation, there are areas with significant potential for mitigation and adaptation to climate change that remain relatively unexplored. While traditional international trade arrangements are insufficient to promote well-being and the preservation of life on Earth, there is fertile ground for collaboration between international trade and climate change regimes. The European Green Deal, launched as a political project for ecological transition, has economic and trade-related objectives and implications. That stated, the overall objective of this research is to uncover the inconsistencies of the European Green Deal concerning ecological law parameters and its implications for global trade. This is a bibliographical research with descriptive purpose, deductive approach, and axiological interpretation. From the analysis of the European Green Deal based on selected parameters of ecological law, it was found that, although it reflects progress in the implementation of ecological law, the political project serves as a mechanism for maintaining power, reproducing the dominant capitalist logic, which diminishes its own transformative potential in the transition to an ecological paradigm.

Environmental Concerns, Communal Orientation, and Environmental Self-Efficacy as Predictors of Ecologically Conscious Consumer Behaviour Among Young Adults

The quintessential era of 21st century is well-known for rapid industrialization and growth. Expansion of industrialization has resulted in massive environmental damage leading to several environmental concerns such as global warming, pollution, non-biodegradable wastes, and frequent climatic changes. To combat the threat of environmental damage, ‘Green or eco-friendly products’ has gained enormous attention from both commodities producers and consumers. In no time, there has been an increase in demand for eco-friendly products by consumers globally. Reports have that the young population showed a vigilant interest in adapting to green marketing strategies as a part of their daily routine. However, it is crucial to understand the underlying psycho-social factors responsible for young consumers’ decision-making process while engaging in green purchase behaviour as they will be significantly contributing to nature being the proactive and highly conscious generation. Therefore, the present study aims to understand the role of environmental concerns or attitudes, communal orientation and environmental self-efficacy as the predictors of pro-environmental purchase behaviour among young adults. The cross-sectional survey study was conducted on 150 young adults between the age range of 18-34 years. Psychometric tools i.e., pro-environmental purchase behaviour scale (PPS) [1], new ecological paradigms scale (NEPS) [2], communal orientation scale (COS) [3] and environmental self-efficacy scale (ESE-20) [4] were used for data collection. Mean, standard deviation, Pearson correlation and regression analysis were computed to statistically analyse the obtained data. Findings of the study aid in gaining insight into motives and intentions related to pro-environmental behaviour engagement among young population. It will help in formulating better public and environmental interventions and policies for strengthening and safeguarding the environment and maintaining sustainability.

The new ecological paradigm and consideration of future consequences; an integrated approach

PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to narrow the research gap by examining the relationship between new ecological paradigm (NEP), consideration of future consequences (CFC), the intention to buy and the intention to pay a premium in the context of electric car (EC) purchase in India.Design/methodology/approachThis study used a structured questionnaire to measure the variables of the research. The study successfully obtained useable data from a sample of 491 consumers residing in India. The analysis of the variables and their relationships was done using structural equation modelling using SMARTPLS4 software.FindingsThe relationship between the values of NEP and CFC was observed in the context of electric cars that has a significant impact on the intention to buy and pay a premium. It also highlights the role of CFC future and CFC immediate on the intention to buy and between NEP and the intention to pay a premium.Research limitations/implicationsThe study only covers electric cars, and therefore further testing of these relationships is required in the context of other forms of environmentally friendly transportation. The results are generalizable across the potential consumers of EC but are even more pertinent to higher-income millennial consumers.Practical implicationsPotential buyers of electric cars, having a positive orientation towards the environment and also consideration for future consequence, were observed to have a stronger intention to buy EC. The study finds a way in increasing the intention to buy an EC by catalyzing environmental concern of consumers through CFC future.Originality/valueThis is the first study that has examined the NEP-CFC relationship, and provides evidence that the intention to buy an electric car is not only NEP (environmental concern)-dependent but also considers CFC's future orientation. This study adds the CFC aspect as another important variable regarding the purchase of EC, and proves that environmental concern is not the only moderating factor to buy an EC.

GENERATING GREEN ENTREPRENEURIAL INTENTION THROUGH ENVIRONMENTAL ATTITUDE

In line with the achievement of sustainable development goals (SDGs), environmentally friendly business is a new challenge in carrying out entrepreneurial activities. Research on the relationship between environmental attitudes and the formation of student intentions in green entrepreneurship is necessary. Entrepreneurship students at the Faculty of Economics and Business, Universitas Tarumanagara, were involved as respondents (n = 280) using a convenience sampling technique. The purpose of this study was to determine students' intentions in green entrepreneurship activities by considering environmental attitude variables proxied through the New Ecological Paradigm (NEP) in the preparation of instruments. The results of the validity test showed that only 10 indicators could be maintained as a measure of environmental attitudes with a Cronbach’s Alpha of 0.892 and a composite reliability of 0.911 so that both were in the satisfactory category. The results of structural regression testing show a significant effect of environmental attitudes on green entrepreneurship intentions at a significance level of 5 percent. R-square of 24.60 percent indicates the large contribution of environmental attitudes to this intention. The mechanism of the relationship between attitudes and intentions is in accordance with the theory of planned behavior while the transformation in the aspect of environmental sustainability is in line with the triple bottom line theory. Based on these results, it can be adapted to an educational approach or involving stakeholders in an entrepreneurship learning approach as a support for achieving Indonesia's SDGs in 2030.

Significance of the environmental value-belief-norm model and its relationship to green consumption among Chinese youth

The objective of this study was to examine the relationship between the variables of the value-belief-norm (VBN) theory and the adoption of green consumption behaviors among Chinese youth. The online survey questionnaire was distributed to a convenience sample of young Chinese consumers aged 18–35 years through the platforms WJX and WeChat. The data collection period spanned from September to December 2022. The analysis involved a total of 1074 participants, and the statistical technique employed was partial least squares structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM) using Smart-PLS 4.0. Common-method bias, multivariate normality, validity, and reliability were also assessed. The results revealed that biospheric values (BV), altruistic values (AV), the new ecological paradigm (EP), awareness of consequences (AC), the ascription of responsibility (AR), and personal norms (PN) significantly and positively influenced intention toward green consumption practices (IGP), which, in turn, had a significant positive influence on the adoption of green consumption practices (AGP). Additionally, GT did not moderate the association between IGP and AGP. This study contributes to the literature on green consumption by analyzing VBN theory’s influence on Chinese youth’s behavior toward green consumption practices to understand and promote green behavior. This study’s findings suggest that promoting ecological awareness and responsibility, developing green values and trust, and strengthening personal norms can encourage green consumption practices among Chinese youth. Policymakers, businesses, and marketers can benefit from these findings to promote green consumption and sustainability in China.

Pharmacy students' perceptions on environmental sustainability in pharmacy education and practice

BackgroundGiven the negative environmental impacts of pharmaceuticals, including their contribution to healthcare's carbon footprint, pharmacists have a role in responding to the climate and biodiversity crises. Knowledge and education are required to support transitions to environmentally sustainable pharmacy practice (ESPP). The aim of this study was to explore Australian undergraduate pharmacy students' knowledge and attitudes towards environmental sustainability and ESPP curriculum content. MethodsParticipants were surveyed using an anonymous online questionnaire deployed using Qualtrics. The questionnaire comprised of two main sections: the 15-item New Ecological Paradigm (NEP) scale to determine participants' environmental attitude score, and section on students' perceptions and curricular experience of environmentally sustainable practice which was adapted from previously published surveys. The invitation with survey link was disseminated via social media, Australian pharmacy student organisations, and direct approach. Quantitative data were reported descriptively. Qualitative data from responses to open-ended questions were analysed thematically using a reflexive, recursive approach. Incomplete survey responses were excluded from the analysis. ResultsOf the 164 complete responses, 99% had previously received information on environmental sustainability. However, only 10% were knowledgeable about ESPP and only 8.5% were aware of ESPP content in their pharmacy school curriculum. Importantly, 70% of respondents saw ESPP as relevant to their future pharmacy practice, and 94% believed the pharmacy profession has a responsibility to undertake sustainability initiatives in the delivery of pharmaceutical care. ConclusionsAustralian pharmacy students lacked knowledge of ESPP and few reported having curricular exposure to ESPP content in their pharmacy degrees. Therefore, ESPP content is an important area for development in pharmacy curricula.

Relational Narratives of Food in Design and Architecture Exhibitions

This paper investigates the narratives involved in the becoming public of an ecological, relational, and culinary culture through artistic mediums. Specifically, the question posed is this: how do food and cooking feature in some selected design and architecture exhibitions? The argument is developed through a series of thematic case studies that aim to affirm the presence in contemporary design, architecture, and exhibition-making of an ecological paradigm. The examples blur the lines of food and art by being proposed as processes of collective authorship happening in atmospheres of conviviality and hospitality. I bring forth the argument that developing exhibitions through the lines of hospitality can improve the quality of public engagement, and amplify a relational model which calls for the collective and entangled nature of all things. Alongside the potential of the arts of sparking a cognitive restructuring and shift in perspective, some risks associated with the mainstream model of society are considered. The final aim is to affirm the importance of relationships to oppose the neoliberal geopolitics of power which foster object-oriented perspectives.

Nepalese forestry professional's attitudes towards risk and uncertainty in adaptation decisions

The safeguarding of forests in the face of threats from climate change depends on important forest management decisions. As particularly vulnerable to the effects of climate change, developing countries like Nepal require concentrated efforts to adapt. However, a crucial element that is frequently disregarded is knowledge of the factors that influence these important decisions. In this study, we investigate how risk and uncertainty aversion among forestry professionals in Nepal, as well as their beliefs regarding climate change, influence their climate change adaptation decisions. We performed a comprehensive online survey with 117 participants, using the Theory of Planned Behavior and the New Ecological Paradigm as theoretical frameworks. The study used Holt and Laury's lottery choices methodology to assess risk and uncertainty attitudes statistically and includes a separate part on climate change adaptation. The study tested the hypotheses that (1) The higher the risk and uncertainty aversion of respondents, the stronger the tendency of changing management objectives and making adaptive decisions and (2) Forest professionals who are well informed about climate change tend to practice adaptive activities. However, the results falsify the first research hypothesis since risk and uncertainty aversion has no statistically significant effect on the likelihood of professionals to adapt to climate change, whereas a risk-averse attitude positively influences the intensity of adaptation strategies as the number of adaptive options applied by forest professionals (coefficient: 0.037, p-value: 0.075).). We argued that adaptation decisions are presumably affected by a legal barrier (42.3 percent) from policies and programs that limit the decision-making authority of forest professionals. The results also falsify the second hypothesis and shows that despite having a positive perception, forest professionals do not adapt until they have enough information to do this. We conclude that providing timely, relevant information, revising current legal frameworks, and delegating enough authority to forestry professionals acting on the ground are the key steps on the road to improved forestry adaptation.

Insights into eco-anxiety in Italy: Preliminary psychometric properties of the Italian version of the Hogg Eco-anxiety Scale, age and gender distribution

Eco-anxiety is a topic of extreme importance in Italy. The present study aimed to assess the preliminary psychometric properties of the Italian version of the Hogg Eco-Anxiety Scale (HEAS). Different internal structures of the HEAS were compared through confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and the four-factor model met the best criteria for adequacy of fit. Affective symptoms, rumination, behavioral symptoms, and anxiety about one's negative impact on the planet are the dimensions captured by the 13 items of the HEAS, consistent with the results of the original study. Results highlight good internal consistency for all four subscales of the HEAS making it an adequate instrument to assess eco-anxiety in Italy and enrich research on the topic. Correlations with Climate Change Anxiety Scale, New Ecological Paradigm Scale-Revised, and Self-Reported Pro-Environmental Behaviours were examined. Gender, age distribution and mean differences between countries were also explored.

The rising threat of peyssonnelioid algal crusts on coral reefs

For more than a century, coral reefs have been exposed to increasing anthropogenic disturbances that have profoundly altered their community structure. These perturbations continue to challenge coral reefs in new ways as ecological paradigms are recast in the Anthropocene Epoch1. In recent decades, macroalgal blooms have blighted Caribbean reefs2, but the appearance of aggressive peyssonnelioid algal crusts (PAC) that are rapidly increasing in abundance to become dominant members of the benthos on Caribbean and Indo-Pacific reefs is a novel phenomenon in tropical seas3. By pre-empting vacant space, overgrowing corals, deterring the settlement of coral larvae, and favouring a phase transition from coral to algae4, PAC are likely to accelerate the decline in dominance of corals on global reefs (Figure 1).