media. The building of the Lower Columbia River Highway was every bit as difficult and importantas the more familiarColumbia River Highway. Oddly enough, the firstchampions of the roadwere bicyclistswho, seeking paths into the Portland countryside, flocked to the firstGood Roads Convention in 1896. When automobiles became practical, their owners then clamored forbetter roads. By 1912, politi cal agitation forbuilding good roads inOregon was led by Sam Hill, Simon Benson, Henry L. Pittock, C.S. "Sam" Jackson, and JuliusL. Meier, with the endorsement of Governor Oswald West. Before adequate roads were constructed, goods to and from Portland and Astoria were transported by steamers on the Columbia River. Loggers felled trees and used the river to raftthem to market until short logging rail roads were required to tap the forests farther from theriver. Obviously, a road adjacent to the river ? an area already partly cleared ? was thechosen route.The routeproved tobemore difficultthanfirstbelieved. The route through Beaver Valley required severalbridges to cross themeandering course of Beaver Creek, and the canyon passing Beaver Fallswas steep and rough. Crossing the 1300-foot Clatsop Crest at Bugby Point involved loops of road with grades up to five percent. Perpendicular rock bluffs as high as eight hundred feethad tobe stabilized against slides. Nevertheless, early travelers raved about the sweeping view from Bugby Point. Despite problems, the road was open for travel in 1915,just twoyears afterthe firstsurveys. Taylor has thoroughly researched the eco nomic and political forcesbehind thecomple tion of thehighway.To avoid distracting read erswith footnotes, he includes short sketches of a page or two to amplify information about key figures involved in thehighway construc tion,or toadd details about difficultproblems. This techniquemakes forquick absorption of the totaleffort from 1914to 1922 ineighty-eight pages, a bibliography, and an index.A succinct chronology of themajor events pertaining to the construction of theLower Columbia River Highway adds to easy understanding of the project. An interestingchapter of twenty-two pages guides any historian who seeks to trace the remnants of the original route,mile by mile. Brief sketches of settlements along that route,many of them altered or obliterated by laterreconstruction of thehighway, are useful and entertaining. The book isnarratedmostly from theview point ofpolitical and construction figures.The author might have included additional tales from thosewho actually built the road, physi cally. The book, however, iswell-organized and the research appears sound, takenmostly from original government documents and articles in news media. Itwill likely remain thekey source of information about building theLower Columbia RiverHighway forfuture researchers. For Oregon travelers, thebook is simply a good read. JoAnnRoe Bellingham,Washington AGREATDAYTO FIGHTFIRE: MANN GULCH, 1949 by Mark Matthews University ofOklahoma Press, Norman, 2007. Illustrations, maps, notes. 280 pages. $24.95 cloth. Wildfire is as old as the convergence of dry tinderand lightning,but the serious literature devoted to this ubiquitous force of nature is only a fewdecades old.Mark Matthews's book, A Great Day toFight Fire:Mann Gulch, 1949, enriches that literatureby offeringa book that isequal parts history,journalism, historical fic tion,and epitaph forthe thirteen men who lost their lives in 1949 on the Mann Gulch fire. On the afternoon ofAugust 5,1949, fifteen U.S. Forest Service smokejumpers parachuted into an obscure canyon above theMissouri 498 OHQ vol. 109, no. 3 River, northeast of Helena, Montana, to attack a routineblaze.Within a fewhours, thefirehad "spotted"below thecrew and quickly expanded into a roiling conflagration that overran the men, claiming the livesof twelve smokejump ers and one Forest Service fire guard. In the nearly sixtyyears thathave elapsed since that fateful day, numerous attempts have been made to unravel themystery of the tragedy, including technical monographs on fire behavior, personal narratives by those who had some connection to either thedeceased or the firefightingorganization at the time, and philosophical reflectionson thenature of the tragedy itself. Probably thebest known attempt tomake sense of the loss of lifeon theMann Gulch fire isNorman Maclean's classic, YoungMen and Fire (University of Chicago Press, 1992). To make direct comparisons between Young Men and Fire and A Great Day toFight Fire would be tomiss the point ofMatthews's book. Maclean's project was one of translat ing ostensive "catastrophe" ? "terror without consolation of explanation," asMaclean puts...