E2A Gene Products Research Articles

Analysis of the oligomerization of myogenin and E2A products in vivo using a two-hybrid assay system.

Members of the helix-loop-helix (HLH) family of proteins bind DNA and activate transcription as homo- and heterodimers. Myogenin is a muscle-specific HLH protein that binds DNA in vitro as a heterodimer with several widely expressed HLH proteins, such as the E2A gene products E12 and E47. We describe a method for detection of protein-protein interactions among HLH proteins in vivo in which dimerization through the HLH motif reconstructs a hybrid transcription factor containing the DNA-binding domain of yeast GAL4 linked to one HLH motif and the activation domain of VP-16 linked to another. We have used this assay to investiagate whether myogenin forms homomeric or heteromeric complexes in vivo and to determine whether growth factors and oncogenes that inhibit myogenesis influence myogenin's ability to dimerize. The results show that myogenin heterodimerizes with E12 and E47 in vivo, but it does not homodimerize to a measurable extent. Peptide growth factors, as well as the immediate early gene products c-Jun, v-Fos, and c-Myc, inhibit the activity of myogenin through a mechanism independent of its association with E2A products.

Subunit structure of cell-specific E box-binding proteins analyzed by quantitation of electrophoretic mobility shift.

Expression of insulin and immunoglobulin genes is dependent on the presence of E boxes (consensus sequence CAXXTG) within the enhancer regions. These sequences are recognized by cell-specific nuclear factors IEF1 (insulin enhancer factor 1) and LEF1 (lymphoid enhancer factor 1). Although IEF1 and LEF1 are distinct by several parameters, they are both recognized by antisera to the mouse helix-loop-helix (HLH) protein A1 (a homolog of the human protein E47, product of the E2A gene). This suggests that A1/E47 or a close relative is a component of both complexes. In order to further characterize the complexes, we have used in vitro translated DNA-binding proteins of known size to verify that electrophoretic mobility shift analysis can be used to estimate the molecular weight of DNA-binding proteins from both the HLH family and the leucine zipper family. Under the conditions used, migration is relatively insensitive to changes in protein charge. This analysis, in combination with mixing experiments between nuclear extracts and in vitro translated HLH proteins, indicates that IEF1 and LEF1 are dimeric complexes. IEF1 behaves as a complex of two proteins, one of which is 67 kDa and is recognized by antibodies to A1, and the second of which is 25 kDa. LEF1 on the other hand, appears to be a complex of two proteins of 67 kDa. The size of the 67-kDa subunits is consistent with that reported for the full-length E2A gene products. The 25-kDa subunit of IEF1 forms DNA-binding heterodimers with A1 but not MyoD and is present in a limited range of cell types, features characteristic of class B HLH proteins such as MyoD and achaete-scute. Taken together, the data support the idea that the E2A gene products are involved directly in regulation of insulin and immunoglobulin gene expression; regulation of the insulin gene apparently requires, in addition, the 25-kDa HLH protein (designated IESF1 for insulin enhancer-specific factor 1).

Inefficient homooligomerization contributes to the dependence of myogenin on E2A products for efficient DNA binding.

Myogenin is a muscle-specific transcription factor that can activate myogenesis; it belongs to a family of transcription factors that share homology within a basic region and an adjacent helix-loop-helix (HLH) motif. Although myogenin alone binds DNA inefficiently, in the presence of the widely expressed HLH proteins E12 and E47 (encoded by the E2A gene), it forms heterooligomers that bind with high affinity to a DNA sequence known as a kappa E-2 site. In contrast, E47 and to a lesser extent E12 are both able to bind the kappa E-2 site relatively efficiently as homooligomers. To define the relative contributions of the basic regions of myogenin and E12 to DNA binding and muscle-specific gene activation, we created chimeras of the two proteins by swapping their basic regions. We showed that myogenin's weak affinity for the kappa E-2 site is attributable to inefficient homooligomerization and that the myogenin basic domain alone can mediate high-affinity DNA binding when placed in E12. Within a heterooligomeric complex, two basic regions were required to form a high-affinity DNA-binding domain. Basic-domain mutants of myogenin or E2A gene products that cannot bind DNA retained the ability to oligomerize and could abolish DNA binding of the wild-type proteins in vitro. These myogenin and E2A mutants also acted as trans-dominant inhibitors of muscle-specific gene activation in vivo. These findings support the notion that muscle-specific gene activation requires oligomerization between myogenin and E2A gene products and that E2A gene products play an important role in myogenesis by enhancing the DNA-binding activity of myogenin, as well as other myogenic HLH proteins.

Inefficient homooligomerization contributes to the dependence of myogenin on E2A products for efficient DNA binding.

Myogenin is a muscle-specific transcription factor that can activate myogenesis; it belongs to a family of transcription factors that share homology within a basic region and an adjacent helix-loop-helix (HLH) motif. Although myogenin alone binds DNA inefficiently, in the presence of the widely expressed HLH proteins E12 and E47 (encoded by the E2A gene), it forms heterooligomers that bind with high affinity to a DNA sequence known as a kappa E-2 site. In contrast, E47 and to a lesser extent E12 are both able to bind the kappa E-2 site relatively efficiently as homooligomers. To define the relative contributions of the basic regions of myogenin and E12 to DNA binding and muscle-specific gene activation, we created chimeras of the two proteins by swapping their basic regions. We showed that myogenin's weak affinity for the kappa E-2 site is attributable to inefficient homooligomerization and that the myogenin basic domain alone can mediate high-affinity DNA binding when placed in E12. Within a heterooligomeric complex, two basic regions were required to form a high-affinity DNA-binding domain. Basic-domain mutants of myogenin or E2A gene products that cannot bind DNA retained the ability to oligomerize and could abolish DNA binding of the wild-type proteins in vitro. These myogenin and E2A mutants also acted as trans-dominant inhibitors of muscle-specific gene activation in vivo. These findings support the notion that muscle-specific gene activation requires oligomerization between myogenin and E2A gene products and that E2A gene products play an important role in myogenesis by enhancing the DNA-binding activity of myogenin, as well as other myogenic HLH proteins.

Functional activity of myogenic HLH proteins requires hetero-oligomerization with E12/E47-like proteins in vivo

In this report we provide four lines of evidence indicating that E12/E47-like proteins interact in vivo with the myogenic HLH proteins MyoD and myogenin. First, cotransfection of MyoD and E47 in COS cells indicates that these factors synergistically enhance transcription of a reporter gene containing an oligomerized MyoD-binding site. Second, mobility-shift assays of muscle cell nuclear extracts, “double shifted” with specific antisera, have identified complexes binding to the MEF1 site that contain either MyoD or myogenin in association with El 2/E47-like proteins. Third, association with E47 alters the phosphorylation state of MyoD. Fourth, C3H10T1/2 cells expressing antisense E2A transcripts contain low levels of E2A gene products and display less terminal muscle differentiation when infected with retroviral MyoD or when challenged to differentiate with 5-azacytidine treatment. In addition we demonstrate that MyoD, in conjunction with E12/E47-like proteins, is functioning as a regulatory nodal point for activation of several other downstream muscle regulators.