Thermodynamic changes on transformations of water in MCMs of 1.4 and 1.8 nm diameter cylindrical pores were investigated by measuring the specific heat, Cp,app, during cooling and during heating at 12 K/h rate in the 160–280 K range. The nature of the slow transformation was further investigated by measuring the dynamic specific heat by using temperature-modulated calorimetry. It led us to establish whether or not contributions to Cp,app are thermally reversible. We found that a thermally reversible, monotonic change in Cp,app of water occurs in 1.4 nm pore-MCM and a sigmoid-shape change occurs in 1.8 nm pore-MCM. Cp,app measured during cooling and during heating is found to be the same at T < 227 K for 1.4 nm pore-MCM, and at T < 232 K for 1.8 nm pore-MCM, as is the real component of the complex specific heat, Cp′. This shows that the sigmoid-shape change in Cp,app is not due to glass–liquid transition of water in the pores. This is further confirmed by showing that the Cp,app features observed for water...