Researchers and practitioners with an interest in a holistic conception of landscape argue for more deliberate approaches to plan, develop and manage landscapes (e.g. Beilin et al. 2012; Bohnet 2008; Dramstad and Fjellstad 2011, 2013; Musacchio 2009, 2013; Pearson and McAlpine 2010; Potschin and Haines-Young 2006; Tress et al. 2003; Wu 2013). These scholars argue that in order for landscapes to be considered sustainable they must fulfil multiple functions and values, including the provision of healthy food, clean water, fresh air, livelihoods and recreational opportunities, productive and healthy ecosystems, as well as reflecting on aesthetic and cultural values. To date, landscape theory and practice has advanced the possibilities with its focus on the development of new paradigms, conceptual frameworks, new governance models, and tools and processes on how to effectively engage with multiple stakeholders. These are intended to improve discussions about potential trade-offs between competing landscape values, effects of land use and management changes, and decisions about future landscapes (e.g. Beilin et al. 2012, 2013, 2014; Bohnet and Smith 2007; Bohnet 2010; Bohnet et al. 2010, 2011a, b; Angelstam et al. 2013; Kasemir et al. 2003; Sayer et al. 2013; Van Paassen et al. 2011). However, recognition of new paradigms, complex decision frameworks and models is just a first step in the dynamic reality that is the quest for sustainable living and species survival. As an example, we can integrate food production regimes within vastly more polycultural landscapes and achieve conservation goals without sequestering land in isolation from food systems if we recognise the need to constantly negotiate the meaning and character of sustainability (Estrada-Carmona et al. 2014; Milder et al. 2014; Scherr and McNeely 2008). This special issue in sustainability science originated in the collaboration between the two guest-editors. We are landscape scholars and research practitioners. We work across multiple disciplines to gain a better understanding of the complex dynamics that arise from interactions between multi-scalar social and ecological systems, i.e. landscapes, to inform theory and practice. With the idea in mind that farming and the production of food present key challenges in most landscapes, we organised a session on sustainable landscapes at the Agri-Food XX 2013 resistance, resilience and security conference, held at the University of Melbourne from 2 to 5 December 2013. Six papers in this special issue were presented at that organised session. All other papers were from the open call for papers on the journal’s webpage or invited contributions. We have been building this special issue with a tacit or explicit recognition that the sixteenth century concept of ‘landskip’ itself has always provided a ‘view’ that intended to be inclusive, and tie the visible elements of that view I. C. Bohnet CSIRO, Land and Water Flagship, Cairns, Australia