Duration Tuning Research Articles

Neural Mechanisms Underlying Selectivity for the Rate and Direction of Frequency-Modulated Sweeps in the Inferior Colliculus of the Pallid Bat

This study describes mechanisms that underlie neuronal selectivity for the direction and rate of frequency-modulated sweeps in the central nucleus of the inferior colliculus (ICC) of the pallid bat (Antrozous pallidus). This ICC contains a high percentage of neurons (66%) that respond selectively to the downward sweep direction of the bat's echolocation pulse. Some (19%) are specialists that respond only to downward sweeps. Most neurons (83%) are also tuned to sweep rates. A two-tone inhibition paradigm was used to describe inhibitory mechanisms that shape selectivity for sweep direction and rate. Two different mechanisms can create similar rate tuning. The first is an early on-best frequency inhibition that shapes duration tuning, which in turn determines rate tuning. In most neurons that are not duration tuned, a delayed high-frequency inhibition creates rate tuning. These neurons respond to fast sweep rates, but are inhibited as rate slows, and delayed inhibition overlaps excitation. In these neurons, starting a downward sweep within the excitatory tuning curve eliminates rate tuning. However, if rate tuning is shaped by duration tuning, this manipulation has no effect. Selectivity for the downward sweep direction is created by an early low-frequency inhibition that prevents responses to upward sweeps. In addition to this asymmetry in arrival times of low- and high-frequency inhibitions, the bandwidth of the low-frequency sideband was broader. Bandwidth influences the arrival time of inhibition during an FM sweep because a broader sideband will be encountered sooner. These findings show that similar spectrotemporal filters can be created by different mechanisms.

Neural Mechanisms Underlying Selectivity for the Rate and Direction of Frequency-Modulated Sweeps in the Auditory Cortex of the Pallid Bat

Frequency-modulated (FM) sweeps are common in vocalizations, including human speech. Selectivity for FM sweep rate and direction is present in the auditory cortex of many species. The present study sought to determine the mechanisms underlying FM sweep selectivity in the auditory cortex of pallid bats. In the pallid bat inferior colliculus (IC), two mechanisms underlie selectivity for FM sweep rate. The first mechanism depends on duration tuning for tones that arises as a consequence of early inhibition generated by an excitatory tone. The second mechanism depends on a narrow band of delayed high-frequency inhibition. Direction selectivity depends on a broad band of early low-frequency inhibition. Here, the contributions of these mechanisms to cortical FM sweep selectivity were determined in pentobarbital-anesthetized pallid bats. We show that the majority of cortical neurons tuned to echolocation frequencies are selective for the downward direction and rate of FM sweeps. Unlike in IC neurons tuned in the echolocation range, duration tuning is rare in cortical neurons with similar tuning. As in the IC, consistent spectrotemporal differences exist between low- and high-frequency sidebands. A narrow band of delayed high-frequency inhibition is necessary for FM rate selectivity. Low-frequency inhibition has a broad bandwidth, early arrival time, and creates direction selectivity. Cortical neurons respond better to slower FM rates and exhibit broader rate tuning than IC neurons. Relative arrival time of high-frequency inhibition is slower in the cortex than in the IC. Thus whereas similar mechanisms shape direction selectivity of neurons tuned in the echolocation range in the IC and the cortex, only one of the two mechanisms underlying rate selectivity in the IC is present in the cortex.

The role of GABAergic inhibition in shaping duration selectivity of bat inferior collicular neurons determined with temporally patterned sound trains

A previous study has shown that duration selectivity of neurons in the inferior colliculus (IC) of the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus becomes sharper with increasing pulse repetition rate (PRR). The present study examines the role of GABAergic inhibition in improving duration selectivity of bat IC neurons with PRR by means of iontophoretic application of GABA as well as its antagonist, bicuculline. Duration selectivity of IC neurons is studied by plotting the duration tuning curves with the number of impulses per pulse against the pulse duration. Duration tuning curves of IC neurons are described as band-, short-, long- and all-pass in terms of filtering properties to sound duration. Bicuculline application produces more pronounced broadening of duration tuning curves at high than at low PRR. Conversely, GABA application produces more pronounced narrowing of duration tuning curves at low than at high PRR. In either case, sharpening of duration selectivity of IC neurons with increasing PRR is abolished during drug application. The duration tuning curves of IC neurons progressively broadens with recording depth. Broadening of duration tuning curves during bicuculline application is more pronounced for neurons at upper than at deep IC. This progressive decrease in duration selectivity with recording depth is discussed in relation to spatial distribution gradient of GABA A receptors in the IC. Possible biological significance of these findings relevant to bat echolocation is discussed.

Duration Selectivity of Neurons in the Inferior Colliculus of the Big Brown Bat: Tolerance to Changes in Sound Level

At and above the level of the inferior colliculus (IC), some neurons respond maximally to a limited range of sound durations, with little or no excitatory response to durations outside of this range. Such neurons have been termed "duration tuned" or "duration selective." In this study we examined the effects of varying signal amplitude on best duration, width of tuning, and first spike latency of duration tuned neurons in the IC of the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus. Response areas as a function of stimulus duration and intensity took a variety of forms, including open (V-shaped), narrow and level tolerant (U-shaped), or closed (O-shaped). The majority (82%) of duration tuned neurons had narrow U-shaped or O-shaped duration response areas. Those with narrow U-shaped response areas retained their duration tuning across a broad dynamic range, < or = 50 dB above threshold, whereas those with O-shaped response areas were narrowly tuned to both stimulus duration and amplitude. For about one-half (55%) of the neurons with either a U- or O-shaped response areas, best duration (BD) changed by <1 ms across the range of suprathreshold amplitudes tested. Changes in BD most often took the form of a shift to slightly shorter durations as stimulus level increased. For the majority (65%) of U- and O-shaped neurons, 50% width of duration tuning changed by <2 ms with increasing amplitude. Latency of response at BD remained stable across changes in sound level, suggesting that the relative strengths of excitatory and inhibitory inputs to duration tuned neurons remain in balance over a wide dynamic range of sound pressure levels.

Combined representations for frequency and duration in detection templates for expected signals

When trying to detect a tonal signal in a continuous broadband noise, listeners attend selectively to both the frequency and the duration of the expected signal. However, it is not known whether they monitor separate or combined representations of these two attributes. To investigate this question, a probe-signal method was used to measure the detectability of signals of expected and unexpected durations at two expected frequencies. The four listeners expected only one of two signals to be presented at random: a brief tone at one frequency or a long tone at another frequency. For each signal frequency, the detectability of the signals of unexpected duration decreased to near chance as the difference between the expected and unexpected duration, at that frequency, increased. The frequency specificity of this duration tuning indicates that both the frequency and the duration of an expected stimulus are represented in a single template.

The role of GABAergic inhibition in shaping the response size and duration selectivity of bat inferior collicular neurons to sound pulses in rapid sequences

Natural sounds, such as vocal communication sounds of many animal species typically occur as sequential sound pulses. Therefore, the response size of auditory neurons to a sound pulse would be inevitably affected when the sound pulse is preceded and succeeded by another sound pulse (i.e., forward and backward masking). The present study presents data to show that increasing strength of GABAergic inhibition relative to excitation contributes to decreasing response size and sharpening of duration selectivity of bat inferior collicular (IC) neurons to sound pulses in rapid sequences. The response size in number of impulses and duration selectivity of IC neurons were studied with a pulse train containing 9 sound pulses. A family of duration tuning curves was plotted for IC neurons using the number of impulses discharged to each presented sound pulse against pulse duration. Our data show that the response size of IC neurons progressively decreased and duration selectivity increased when determined with sequentially presented sound pulses. This variation in the response size and duration selectivity of IC neurons with sequentially presented sound pulses was abolished or reduced during bicuculline and GABA application. Bicuculline application increased the response size and broadened the duration tuning curve of IC neurons while GABA application produced opposite results. Possible mechanisms underlying increasing strength of GABAergic inhibition with sequentially presented sound pulses are presented. Biological significance of these findings in relation to acoustic signal processing is also discussed.

Evidence for auditory signal-detection templates tuned to both the frequency and duration of an expected signal

When trying to detect a tonal signal in a continuous broadband noise, listeners attend selectively to both the frequency and the duration of the expected signal. However, it is not known whether they monitor separate, or combined, representations of these two attributes. To investigate this question, a probe-signal method was used to measure the detectability of signals of expected and unexpected durations at two expected frequencies. Four listeners were led to expect one of two signals to be presented at random: a brief tone at one frequency or a long tone at another frequency. For each signal frequency, the detectability of the signals of unexpected duration decreased to near chance as the difference between the expected and unexpected duration, at that frequency, increased. Thus, signals of each expected duration were rarely detected when they were presented at a frequency not associated with that duration. The frequency specificity of this duration tuning indicates that both the frequency and the duration of an expected stimulus are represented in a single signal-detection template. [Work supported by NIH.]

Ambiguities in sound-duration selectivity by neurons in the inferior colliculus of the bat Molossus molossus from Cuba.

This study examines duration selectivity in auditory neurons of the inferior colliculus of the bat Molossus molossus (Molossidae, Chiroptera) from Cuba. Three main types of duration selectivity, short-, band-, and long-pass, as previously described in other species, are present in M. molossus. The range of best durations in the inferior colliculus of this species approximates the durations of their echolocation calls, suggesting that, as has been shown in other species of bats and frogs, the filter mechanism that produces duration tuning is selective for species-specific sounds relevant to behavior. Duration coding in M. molossus is not unambiguous because approximately 30% of the short- and band-pass neurons respond best to two different stimulus durations. This bimodal duration selectivity could be explained by time delayed excitatory inputs that coincide with an inhibitory rebound. In addition, the effect of stimulus intensity on duration selectivity was tested. For most of the neurons (78%), duration selectivity was affected by absolute sound pressure level and/or small changes of sound pressure. In this respect, the processing of stimulus duration by collicular neurons seems to be more complex in M. molossus than in other species studied so far.

Corticofugal modulation of duration-tuned neurons in the midbrain auditory nucleus in bats.

Animal sounds, as well as human speech sounds, are characterized by multiple parameters such as frequency, intensity, duration, etc. The central auditory system produces neurons tuned to particular durations and frequencies of sounds emitted by a species. In bats, "duration-tuned" neurons are mostly sensitive to short durations and high frequencies of sounds used for echolocation. They are scattered in the frequency maps of the inferior colliculus and auditory cortex. We found that electric stimulation of cortical duration-tuned neurons modulates collicular duration-tuned neurons in both duration and frequency tuning only when collicular and cortical neurons paired for studies are within +/-4 ms in best duration and within +/-6 kHz in best frequency. There are four types of modulations: sharpening or broadening of duration tuning, and lengthening or shortening of best duration. Sharpening is observed in "matched" collicular neurons whose best durations are the same as those of stimulated cortical neurons, and it is accompanied by augmentation of the auditory responses at their best durations. The other three types of modulations are observed in "unmatched" collicular neurons whose best durations are different from those of stimulated cortical neurons. Lengthening or shortening of best duration is linearly related to the amount of the difference in best duration between collicular and cortical neurons. Corticofugal modulation is specific and systematic according to relationships in both duration and frequency between stimulated cortical and recorded collicular neurons.

Duration tuning in the mouse auditory midbrain.

Temporal cues, including sound duration, are important for sound identification. Neurons tuned to the duration of pure tones were first discovered in the auditory system of frogs and bats and were discussed as specific adaptations in these animals. More recently duration sensitivity has also been described in the chinchilla midbrain and the cat auditory cortex, indicating that it might be a more general phenomenon than previously thought. However, it is unclear whether duration tuning in mammals is robust in face of changes of stimulus parameters other than duration. Using extracellular single-cell recordings in the mouse inferior colliculus, we found 55% of cells to be sensitive to stimulus duration showing long-pass, short-pass, or band-pass filter characteristics. For most neurons, a change in some other stimulus parameter, (e.g., intensity, frequency, binaural conditions, or using noise instead of pure tones) altered and sometimes abolished duration-tuning characteristics. Thus in many neurons duration tuning is interdependent with other stimulus parameters and, hence, might be context dependent. A small number of inferior colliculus neurons, in particular band-pass neurons, exhibited stable filter characteristics and could therefore be referred to as "duration selective." These findings support the idea that duration tuning is a general phenomenon in the mammalian auditory system.

Neural measurement of sound duration: control by excitatory-inhibitory interactions in the inferior colliculus.

In the inferior colliculus (IC) of the big brown bat, a subpopulation of cells ( approximately 35%) are tuned to a narrow range of sound durations. Band-pass tuning for sound duration has not been seen at lower levels of the auditory pathway. Previous work suggests that it arises at the IC through the interaction of sound-evoked, temporally offset, excitatory and inhibitory inputs. To test this hypothesis, we recorded from duration-tuned neurons in the IC and examined duration tuning before and after iontophoretic infusion of antagonists to gamma-aminobutyric acid-A (GABA(A)) (bicuculline) or glycine (strychnine). The criterion for duration tuning was that the neuron's spike count as a function of duration had a peak value at one duration or a range of durations that was >/=2 times the lowest nonzero value at longer durations. Out of 21 units tested with bicuculline, duration tuning was eliminated in 15, broadened in two, and unaltered in four. Out of 10 units tested with strychnine, duration tuning was eliminated in four, broadened in one, and unaltered in five. For units tested with both bicuculline and strychnine, bicuculline had a greater effect on reducing or abolishing duration tuning than did strychnine. Bicuculline and strychnine both produced changes in discharge pattern. There was nearly always a shift from an offset response to an onset response, indicating that in the predrug condition, inhibition arrived simultaneously with excitation or preceded it. There was often an increase in the length of the spike train, indicating that in the predrug condition, inhibition also coincided with later parts of excitation. These findings support two hypotheses. First, duration tuning is created in the IC. Second, although the construction of duration tuning varies in some details among IC neurons, it follows three rules: 1) an excitatory and an inhibitory event are temporally linked to the onset of sound but temporally offset from one another; 2) the duration of some inhibitory event must be linked to the duration of the sound; 3) an excitatory event must be linked to the offset of sound.

Temporally patterned pulse trains affect duration tuning characteristics of bat inferior collicular neurons

This study examines the effect of temporally patterned pulse trains on duration tuning characteristics of inferior collicular neurons of the big brown bat. Eptesicus fuscus, under free-field stimulation conditions. Using a 50% difference between maximal and minimal responses as a criterion, the duration tuning characteristics of inferior collicular neurons determined with pulse trains of different pulse durations are described as band-pass, long-pass, short-pass, and all-pass. Each band-pass neuron discharged maximally to a specific pulse duration that was at least 50% larger than the neuron's responses to a long- and a short-duration pulse. In contrast, each long- or short-pass neuron discharged maximally to a range of long- or short-duration pulses that were at least 50% larger than the minimal responses. The number of impulses of an all-pass neuron never differed by more than 50%. When pulse trains were delivered at different pulse repetition rates, the number of short-pass and band-pass neurons progressively increased with increasing pulse repetition rates. The slope of the duration tuning curves also became sharper when determined with pulse trains at high pulse repetition rates. Possible mechanisms underlying these findings are discussed.

Bicuculline application affects discharge pattern and pulse-duration tuning characteristics of bat inferior collicular neurons.

This study examines the contribution of GABAergic inhibition to the discharge pattern and pulse duration tuning characteristics of 101 bat inferior collicular neurons by means of bicuculline application to their recording sites. When stimulated with single pulses 56 (55%) neurons discharged 1 or 2 impulses (phasic responders), 42 (42%) discharged 3-10 impulses (phasic bursters) and 3 (3%) discharged impulses throughout the stimulus duration (tonic responders). Bicuculline application increased the number of impulses and changed the discharge patterns of 66 neurons. Using 50% difference between maximal and minimal responses as a criterion, the duration tuning characteristics of these neurons can be described as band-pass (20, 20%), long-pass (17, 17%), short-pass (33, 32%), and all-pass (31, 31%). Each band-pass neuron discharged maximally to a specific duration (the best duration) which was at least 50% larger than the neuron's responses to a long-duration pulse and a short-duration pulse. In contrast, each long- or short-pass neuron discharged maximally to a range of long or short duration pulses. Bicuculline application changed the duration tuning characteristics of 65 neurons. Possible mechanisms underlying duration tuning characteristics and the behavioral relevance to bat echolocation are discussed.

Neural tuning to sound duration in the inferior colliculus of the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus.

Neural tuning to different sound durations may be a useful filter for identification of certain sounds, especially those that are biologically important. The auditory midbrains of mammals and amphibians contain neurons that appear to be tuned to sound duration. In amphibians, neurons are tuned to durations of sound that are biologically important. The purpose of this study was to characterize responses of neurons in the inferior colliculus (IC) of the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus, to sounds of different durations. Our aims were to determine what percent of neurons are duration tuned and how best durations are correlated to durations of echolocation calls, and to examine response properties that may be relevant to the mechanism for duration tuning, such as latency and temporal firing pattern; we also examined frequency tuning and rate-level functions. We recorded from 136 single units in the central nucleus of the IC of unanesthetized bats. The stimuli were pure tones, frequency-modulated sweeps, and broadband noise. The criterion for duration tuning was an increase in spike count of > or = 50% at some durations compared with others. Of the total units sampled, 36% were tuned to stimulus duration. All of these units were located in the caudal half of the IC. Best duration for most units ranged from < 1 to 10 ms, but a few had best durations up to > or = 20 ms. This range is similar to the range of durations of echolocation calls used by Eptesicus. All duration-tuned neurons responded transiently. The minimum latency was always longer than the best duration. Duration-tuned units have best durations and best frequencies that match the temporal structure and frequency range of the echolocation calls. Thus the results raise the hypothesis that neurons in the IC of Eptesicus, and probably the auditory midbrain of other vertebrates, are tuned to biologically important sound durations. We suggest a model for duration tuning consisting of three components: 1) inhibitory input that is correlated with the onset of the stimulus and is sustained for the stimulus duration; 2) transient excitation that is correlated with the offset of the stimulus; and 3) transient excitation that is correlated with the onset of the stimulus but is delayed in time relative to the onset of inhibition. For the neuron to fire, the two excitatory events must coincide in time; noncoincident excitatory events are not sufficient.

Temporal Integration and Duration Tuning in the Dorsal Zone of Cat Auditory Cortex

The present study examined auditory cortical neurons, the responses of which depended on the duration of noise bursts. We recorded from 150 neurons with response latencies exceeding 30 msec and from 28 neurons with OFF responses to auditory stimuli in the dorsal zone of cat auditory cortex. Of 150 long-latency neurons, 132 displayed some form of duration selectivity. Seventy-eight were classified as selective for long durations. Among the long-duration-selective neurons, 30 responded only to noise burst stimuli with durations longer than a minimal threshold and were classified further as duration threshold neurons. Of 132 duration-selective neurons, 41 responded selectively to noise bursts of short duration; 13 showed maximal responses to noise bursts of a particular duration and could be regarded as duration-tuned neurons. OFF-response neurons included ones that were long-duration-selective, duration-tuned, and nonduration-selective. Duration tuning has been described previously only at the midbrain level in amphibians and bats. The present finding of sensitivity to sound duration in at least one region of cat auditory cortex indicates that this form of neural tuning may be important for hearing in all vertebrates, and for processing of sound at multiple levels in the auditory pathway. The duration tuning in the cat auditory cortex was much broader, and the best duration was distributed over a wider range than in the bat inferior colliculus. We suggest that the duration selectivity of the long-latency neurons results from integration along the time domain of a stimulus during the latent period.

Cortical Off Response Tuning for Stimulus Duration

To answer the question whether OFF response amplitude (firing rate) of visual cortical cells varies as a function of stimulus duration, a series of such cells from areas 17 and 18 of the cat were investigated with a stationary light bar, presented for different durations (10–3200 msec) over the receptive field. Out of a sample of 174 cells tested, 58 cells were found for which the OFF responses varied as a function of ON stimulus duration. Of these cells, 29 showed a continuous increase up to the longest duration tested, six showed a sharp tuning for medium range durations (between 50 and 400 msec) and the remaining 23 cells had an intermediate profile (increase to optimum followed by slight decrease). For some of these cells this tuning could be used to predict adequately the velocity tuning. Similar recordings in 13 lateral geniculate nucleus cells failed to show duration tuning. Copyright © 1996 Elsevier Science Ltd.

Neural Tuning for Sound Duration: Role of Inhibitory Mechanisms in the Inferior Colliculus

Duration is a biologically important feature of sound. Some neurons in the inferior colliculus of the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus, are tuned to sound duration, but it is unclear at what level the tuning originates or what neural mechanisms are responsible for it. The application of antagonists of the inhibitory neurotransmitters gamma-aminobutyric acid or glycine to neurons in the inferior colliculus eliminated duration tuning. Whole-cell patch-clamp recordings of synaptic currents suggested that inhibition produces a temporal frame within which excitation can occur. A model is proposed in which duration tuning arises when an early, sustained inhibitory input interacts with a delayed, transient excitatory input.