Dural Ring Research Articles

Identification of the Distal Dural Ring with Use of Fusion Images with 3D-MR Cisternography and MR Angiography: Application to Paraclinoid Aneurysms

The distal dural ring (DDR) represents the anatomic border between the extradural and intradural internal carotid arteries (ICAs). The purpose of this study was to examine whether 3D-MR cisternography and MR angiography (MRA) fusion images can identify the boundary between the CSF and the cavernous sinus, which might represent the DDR. Thirty-six consecutive patients with 39 ICA aneurysms were examined with use of MR fusion images with 3D-cisternography and MRA on a 1.5T unit. Two neuroradiologists evaluated the configuration of the carotid cave and the location of the aneurysms on fusion images and classified them as intradural, transdural, and extradural aneurysms. The borderline between the CSF and the cavernous sinus was visualized on fusion images in all patients. The carotid cave configuration in 72 ICAs was classified as having no dent (n = 31), a shallow dent (n = 27), and a deep dent (n = 14). The MR fusion images led to the classification of 39 ICA aneurysms as 21 intradural, 6 transdural, and 12 extradural. The interobserver agreement of MR fusion images was excellent (kappa = 0.80). Fusion images with 3D-cisternography and MRA yielded clear visualization of the boundary between the suprasellar cistern and cavernous sinus indicating the DDR. This imaging technique may provide additional information in consideration of a treatment option for paraclinoid aneurysms.

Intrasellar Rupture of a Paraclinoid Aneurysm with Subarachnoid Hemorrhage: Usefulness of MR Imaging in Diagnosis

Characterization of paraclinoid aneurysms may be difficult because of the complexity of anatomic structures involved, and differentiation between intradural and extradural lesions is crucial. We report a case of a patient with a unique presentation of a paraclinoid aneurysm with intrasellar hemorrhage in which the presence of intrasellar blood and the relationship of the paraclinoid aneurysmal neck and sac to the dural rings were elegantly demonstrated on MR imaging and were critical in choosing the target lesion for treatment.

Surgical consideration of the intraspinal component in extradural dumbbell tumors

Background The dumbbell tumor is considered a distinct group of tumors of the spinal nerve sheath owing to its intriguing clinical and radiological characteristics. More than half of dumbbell tumors are completely restricted to the extradural space, although preoperative MRI in some cases suggests the presence of intradural/extradural tumors. The aim of this retrospective investigation is to elucidate the clinical features and to suggest the surgical strategy to reduce the operating time and prevent additional complications in extradural type. Methods The medical records and radiological studies of 7 consecutive cases (4 male, 3 female, mean age 40.4 years) who underwent removal of the intraspinal component of their extradural dumbbell tumors between January 1996 and December 2005 were analyzed. Diagnosis and preoperative evaluation were performed with MRI and myelogram/CTs. Results The relationship of the tumor mass to dural sac in preoperative MRIs was so indistinct as to suggest an intradural mass in 5 cases. We found that extradural portion was covered with an attenuated dura and that the dural ring was invaginated into the intradural portion in these cases. Therefore, the author began with the epidural removal of the intraspinal and extraspinal component, followed by carefully extracting the intradural-like mass. Conclusions In conclusion, we suggest that invagination of the dural ring is the anatomical feature that may be confused with an intradural/extradural tumor during operations for extradural dumbbell tumors. Initial epidural mass removal, extraction of intradural/extradural tumors subsequent to dural opening, and affirmation of presence of intradural tumor remnant could save time during dumbbell tumor surgery.

Usefulness of MR Imaging for the Assessment of Nonophthalmic Paraclinoid Aneurysms

The neuroradiologic location of asymptomatic paraclinoid aneurysms is decisive for patient management. In a preliminary study, we designed a paraclinoid MR protocol (PMP) including high-resolution T2-weighted images in 2 orthogonal planes to define the inferior limit of the distal dural ring plane that represents the borderline between the intradural and extradural internal carotid artery. In this clinical study, we compared this protocol with digital subtraction angiography (DSA) for the location of paraclinoid aneurysms. During a 3-year period, we performed PMP and conventional angiograms in 14 consecutive patients with 17 asymptomatic paraclinoid aneurysms. Ophthalmic (superior) aneurysms were excluded. Two independent observers reviewed MR imaging data, and a third experienced neuroradiologist analyzed the conventional angiograms. MR imaging and conventional angiograms were independently analyzed, and interpretations obtained with each technique were compared. PMP allowed correct visualization of the aneurysms in all patients. No significant differences (P >.05) were found between the DSA and PMP for the measurement of the aneurysmal neck or sac. Interobserver agreement was good. MR imaging was discordant with conventional angiography regarding the position around the cavernous sinus of the aneurysmal neck and sac in 5 cases. PMP images were helpful for treatment decisions in 4 cases. PMP is an interesting tool that might be used in association with conventional angiography for the assessment of paraclinoid aneurysms.

Optic Strut as a Radiographic Landmark in Evaluating Neck Location of a Paraclinoid Aneurysm

The optic strut (OS) is a candidate landmark in computed tomographic (CT) angiographic scans for the discrimination of intradural and extradural/intracavernous aneurysms involving the paraclinoid segment of the internal carotid artery. The goal of this study is to examine and confirm the qualifications of the OS as a landmark in CT angiographic scans for the preoperative evaluation of aneurysms in this region. Seventeen consecutive patients with 18 unruptured paraclinoid aneurysms who underwent preoperative CT angiography scans and direct surgery between 1998 and 2005 were evaluated retrospectively. We focused on the relationships of the necks of aneurysms to the OS in CT angiographic scans and that of the necks to proximal dural rings during intraoperative examinations. Direct surgery revealed that 14 aneurysms, the necks of which were distal to the OS on CT angiographic scans, arose distal to the proximal dural rings. All aneurysms were clipped, except one exhibiting calcification of the neck. Three aneurysms, for which the neck was proximal to the OS on CT angiographic scans, revealed only a portion or nothing of their domes instead of their necks through the proximal dural rings after dissection of the distal dural rings. Dome coating with fibrin glue and a piece of muscle tissue or mere exploration was performed. Another aneurysm, of which the neck straddled the OS on CT angiographic scans, was found to arise across the proximal dural ring. Clipping of the neck was performed after dissection of the proximal dural ring. Of the source images of CT angiographic scans, the axial images were the most useful in evaluating the relationship of the neck of an aneurysm to the OS. On CT angiographic scans, the OS is a precise identification of the proximal dural ring that forms the superior border of the cavernous sinus. The aneurysms whose necks arise obviously distal to the OS on CT angiographic scans are able to be clipped without dissection of the proximal dural ring.

Anatomical and quantitative description of the transcavernous approach to interpeduncular and prepontine cisterns

The management of wide-necked, giant, or unsuccessfully coil-treated basilar apex aneurysms requires a wide exposure, for both working area and linear visualization of the basilar artery (BA). Cranial-based approaches, such as the transcavernous approach, have been proposed to deal with such aneurysms; whether abbreviated forms of this approach might provide similar exposure remains controversial. The authors examine this issue quantitatively. Four alcohol-preserved cadaveric heads injected with pigmented silicone were prepared for bilateral dissection. After completing an orbitozygomatic craniotomy, the surgeons worked in a reverse direction, performing the transcavernous approach in five steps: 1) posterior clinoidectomy; 2) cavernous sinus opening; 3) anterior clinoidectomy; 4) cutting of the distal dural ring; and 5) cutting of the proximal dural ring. Performing the complete transcavernous approach significantly increased the working area and linear exposure of the BA compared with abbreviated forms of the approach (p < 0.05). Opening the roof of the cavernous sinus significantly increased the working area compared with posterior clinoidectomy alone (p = 0.014); however, additional gains in exposure required completing the transcavernous approach. Resection of the anterior clinoid process combined with opening of only the distal dural ring did not significantly increase the working area or linear exposure of the BA. The complete transcavernous approach significantly increases the working area and linear exposure of the BA compared with the more conservative forms of approach.

Localisation en IRM des anévrismes carotidiens paraclinoïdiens

The distal dural ring plane (DDRP) separates the intracavernous from the supracavernous paraclinoid internal carotid artery. The purpose of this MRI protocol is to evaluate the position of this plane for the characterization of paraclinoid aneurysms. The protocol uses a T2 weighted sequence in two orthogonal planes (diaphragmatic and carotid planes) and two correlation lines in each plane. These lines pass through anatomo-radiological reference points correlated with the medio-lateral and antero-posterior margins of the DDRP. We use the intersection angle of these lines as the inferior radiological limit of the DDRP curve. An aneurysm located above this angle is supracavernous; an aneurysm located below this angle is intracavernous; an aneurysm crossing this angle is transitional. In difficult cases, this MRI protocol could help better characterize the exact localization of paraclinoid aneurysms on both sides of the cavernous sinus roof.

Ruptured Internal Carotid Artery Anterior Wall Aneurysm Identified During Vasospasm: Case Report

Aneurysms of the paraclinoid segment arising from the anterolateral wall of the proximal internal carotid artery (ICA) are usually located in the intradural space, and the proximal neck of the aneurysm is closely adjacent to the dural ring. Although most of these aneurysms can be identified by cerebral angiography, the top of the aneurysm can be flattened because of its relationship to the undersurface of the clinoid process. We report a rare case of a ruptured ICA anterolateral wall aneurysm that was not identified by initial angiography but was clearly observed at the time of vasospasm. A 59-year-old female patient was transferred to our hospital because of sudden loss of consciousness. Initial angiography failed to disclose any aneurysm except for one projecting to the right at the C3-C4 portion of the left ICA. A left frontotemporal craniotomy with drilling of the anterior clinoid process was performed 1 day after the onset of subarachnoid hemorrhage. Within the operative field, however, no hemorrhage was detected near the C3-C4 portion of the left ICA. Subsequent angiography performed during vasospasm clearly demonstrated a ruptured aneurysm in the anterior paraclinoid segment of the right ICA. After drilling the anterior clinoid process and cutting the dural ring, we successfully clipped the aneurysm. The aneurysm was saccular, with a broad neck that extended below the dural ring. Intraoperative inspection demonstrated that the dome of the aneurysm was in a subclinoid location, suggesting that most of the aneurysm might have been flattened by the dural ring at the time of initial angiography but before the onset of vasospasm. The presented case suggests that this type of aneurysm may be missed by routine angiography performed before and after vasospasm. If initial angiography fails to reveal the origin of the subarachnoid hemorrhage but computed tomography still discloses hemorrhage from an ICA aneurysm, repeated angiography should be considered within 14 days after the onset of subarachnoid hemorrhage to confirm whether the aneurysm has arisen from the anterior clinoid segment of the ICA.

Surgical Anatomy of the Ophthalmic Artery: Its Origin and Proximal Course

We examined the surgical anatomy of the ophthalmic artery (OA) by dissection of cadaver heads, evaluating the anatomic relationships between the origin of the OA and both its proximal course and surrounding structures. In addition, we demonstrated the surgical application of these anatomic features for safe surgical exploration of this region. Through anatomic dissection, the origin of the OA was examined in both sides of 25 formalin-fixed and 10 fresh cadaver specimens. The following parameters were evaluated: the location of the origin of the OA in relation to the dural rings, the topographic relationship of the paraclinoid region, and the location of the dural penetrating point of the OA in the optic canal. The OA originated from the internal carotid artery within the intradural space in 49% of cases, just above the upper dural ring in 37%, at the clinoid segment in 7%, and within the cavernous sinus in 6%. The dural penetrating point of the OA was anterior to the falciform ligament, and thereby in the optic canal, in 74% of cases, ventral to the falciform ligament in 19%, and posterior to the falciform ligament in 7%. The anterior circumference point of the upper dural ring, the point at which the upper dural ring intersects the anterior edge of the internal carotid artery, was more anterior to the falciform ligament in 40% of cases and ventral and posterior to the falciform ligament in 16.4% and 43.6%, respectively. Our anatomic findings demonstrate anatomic variation of the OA in terms of its region of origin. Several anatomic points that were noteworthy during surgical exploration of this region are discussed.

MRI location of the distal dural ring plane: anatomoradiological study and application to paraclinoid carotid artery aneurysms

The distal dural ring plane (DDRP) separates the intradural from the extradural paraclinoid internal carotid artery. The purpose of this study was to evaluate its position with MR imaging. The protocol used a T2-weighted sequence in two orthogonal planes: diaphragmatic (DIA-P) and carotid (CAR-P). The DDRP passes through four anatomoradiological reference points (RefP). We developed on a cadaveric model a correlation method supported by correlation lines and angles (CA) projecting the RefP toward the DDRP. RefP were correlated to the DDRP in 65-84% of cases in the DIA-P and 60-76% of cases in the CAR-P. CA were identified and correlated to the DDRP, respectively, in 87% and 60% of cases in the DIA-P, and 60% and 51% of cases in the CAR-P (failure often related to a lack of visibility of just one RefP). A higher tissular contrast in living subjects allowed the identification of CA in 90% and 80% of cases, respectively, in the DIA-P and the CAR-P. We propose that CA, when identified, should be considered as an approximation of the inferior radiological limit of the DDRP curve. In difficult angiographical cases, this MRI protocol could help to locate paraclinoid aneurysms on both sides of the cavernous sinus roof.

Enhanced Exposure of Carotico-Oculomotor Triangle Following Extradural Anterior Clinoidectomy: A Comparative Anatomical Study

To quantify and compare the carotico-oculomotor triangle (COT) area before and after extradural anterior clinoidectomy (AC). Ten cadaveric heads were dissected bilaterally. Before and after an extradural AC, the following points were measured: (1) the internal carotid artery (ICA) bifurcation to the tip of the anterior clinoid process (ACP) (A) and to the distal dural ring (A'), (2) the ICA bifurcation to the point where the oculomotor nerve becomes obscured by the tentorial fold (B) and to the porus oculomotoris after incision of the tentorial fold (B'), and (3) the tip of the ACP to the point where the oculomotor nerve becomes obscured by the tentorial incisura (C) and from the distal dural ring to the porus oculomotoris (C'). The area of the COT was calculated before and after AC (DeltaABC and DeltaA'B'C', respectively). The mean values were as follows: A: 9.15 +/- 0.93 mm, A': 13.45 +/- 0.82 mm; B: 7.80 +/- 1.24 mm, B': 9.90 +/- 1.21 mm; C: 7.15 +/- 0.99 mm, C': 9.3 +/- 1.26 mm; DeltaABC: 26.26 +/- 6.05 mm, DeltaA'B'C': 45.06 +/- 8.92 mm. Extradural AC enhances the exposure of the COT almost twofold. This increased exposure can be of significant help during resection of lesions of the parasellar and basilar apex regions.

Postoperative vasospasm of unruptured paraclinoid carotid aneurysms: analysis of 30 cases

This study was conducted to determine the incidence, severity, and causes of delayed vasospasm after clipping of unruptured paraclinoid aneurysms of the internal carotid artery (ICA). A retrospective analysis was made of 30 patients, who underwent clipping of unruptured paraclinoid aneurysms in our institution between 1991 and 1998. We compared angiograms before and after operation and classified them into two groups: vasospasm group and non-vasospasm group. Eleven variables were assessed as to their relationship to delayed vasospasm. There were 9 patients (30%) in the vasospasm group, of which 3 patients (10%) were clinically symptomatic. For all symptomatic patients, aggressive treatment, including triple-H therapy, was conducted with good outcome. The number of clips used (p<0.04) and temporary occlusion of the ICA (p<0.005) were statistically significant factors associated with the incidence of vasospasm. It is suggested that mechanical stimulation to the vascular wall of the ICA is responsible for causing spasm in addition to intraoperative bleeding around the dural ring.

Commentary

The study of the proximal distal dural ring has been of interest to skull base surgeons for many years. Numerous reports attempt to characterize these structures and to relate them to the surrounding anatomy. The evolution of skull base surgery, which includes less invasive techniques to treat aneurysms or radiosurgery for skull base tumors, applies even greater pressure for skull base surgeons to minimize the complications associated with surgery. This outstanding anatomical study by Beretta and coworkers helps skull base surgeons to fulfill this challenging obligation.

Radiographic Imaging of the Distal Dural Ring for Determining the Intradural or Extradural Location of Aneurysms

The effectiveness of several anatomical and radiological landmarks proposed to determine whether an aneurysm is located intradurally or extradurally is still debated. In anatomical and radiological studies, we examined the relationships of the distal dural ring (DDR) to the internal carotid artery (ICA) and surrounding bony structures to aid in the localization of aneurysms near the DDR. Anatomical relationships were examined by performing dissections on 10 specimens (5 formalin-fixed cadaveric heads). After the position of the DDR, optic nerve, and tuberculum sellae were marked with surgical steel wire, radiographs were taken in multiple projections. The only bony landmark consistently visible on radiographs was the planum sphenoidale. The superior border of the DDR is located at or below the level of the tuberculum sellae, which laterally becomes the superomedial aspect of the optic strut; thus, the optic strut marks the dorsal limit of the DDR. On 50 dry skulls, we measured the vertical distance between the planum sphenoidale and medial aspect of the optic strut (5.0 +/- 0.4 mm), the interoptic strut distance (14.4 +/- 1.4 mm), and the linear distance between the most posterior aspect of the planum sphenoidale (limbus sphenoidale) and the tuberculum sellae (6.0 +/- 0.5 mm). Using these measurements and the planum sphenoidale, tuberculum sellae, and optic strut as reference landmarks, we determined the location of the aneurysm relative to the DDR on angiographic images. In this way, we were able to identify whether lesions were intra- or extradural.

Proposed Classification of Segments of the Internal Carotid Artery: Anatomical Study With Angiographical Interpretation

The nomenclature and borders of the segments of the internal carotid artery (ICA) remain confusing. A classification of segments of the ICA is proposed based on constant anatomical structures, such as the carotid foramen and canal, the petrous bone, the petrolingual ligament (PLL), and the proximal and distal dural rings. The bilateral ICAs were dissected in 15 cadaveric head specimens using different neurosurgical approaches. The bilateral lacerum foramina were studied in five dry skulls. The bilateral segments of the ICA were also examined on carotid angiograms of 10 normal patients and another with the ophthalmic artery originating from the intracavernous portion of the ICA. The present classification divides the ICA into five segments in the direction of the blood flow. The cervical segment is extradural and extracranial, the petrous segment is extradural and intraosseous, the cavernous segment is interdural and intracavernous, the clinoidal segment is interdural and paracavernous, and the cisternal segment is intradural and intracisternal. The ICA did not pass through the lacerum foramen in any specimen. In all specimens, 1/8 to 5/8 of the lacerum foramen was under the deep dural layer of the cavernous sinus. The term 'lacerum segment' as used previously and called the 'trigeminal segment' by us cannot be justified. The PLL is the posterolateral border of the cavernous sinus and the lacerum and trigeminal segments should be included in the cavernous and petrous segments. The ophthalmic artery may originate from the clinoidal ICA, from the cavernous ICA, or from the middle meningeal artery. Instead of using the term 'ophthalmic segment,' the term 'cisternal segment' should be used for the anatomically distinct ICA in the subarachnoid space. This classification should be minimally affected by anatomical variations.

Paraclinoid and cavernous sinus regions: Measurement of critical structures relevant for surgical procedure

Determination of the safest distance the falciform ligament can be incised from its origin to the orbital apex. Measurement of the distance between the oculomotor foramen and the IV nerve in the lateral wall of the cavernous sinus. Evaluation of the optic strut as an accurate landmark between the intradural (subarachnoid) and extradural segment of the internal carotid artery (ICA). Ten fixed human cadaver heads were examined for a total of 20 sides. A frontotemporal craniotomy, an orbito-optic osteotomy, and extradural anterior clinoidectomy were carried out followed by opening the falciform ligament, circumferentially releasing the distal dural ring and dissection of the lateral wall of the cavernous sinus under the operating microscope. We measured: 1) the distance between the entry of the III nerve and the point where the IV nerve crosses over it into the cavernous sinus; 2) the distance the falciform ligament can be incised along the optic nerve laterally until the IV nerve is encountered at the orbital apex; 3) the distance between the optic strut and the lateral part of the distal dural ring; and 4) the distance between the optic strut and the ophthalmic artery. All measurements were made in millimeters, using small calipers. The distance between the optic strut and the lateral part of the distal dural ring ranges from 3-7.5 mm (mean=5.47 mm). In all our specimens, the ophthalmic artery was found distally from the optic strut in the intradural space at a distance ranging from 0.5-7 mm (mean=3.35 mm). The distance between the entry of the third nerve and the IV nerve into the cavernous sinus ranged from 7-15 mm (mean=10.9 mm). The distance between the origin of the falciform ligament and the IV nerve at the level of the orbital apex ranged from 9-15 mm (mean=10.75 mm). The falciform ligament and the optic sheath should not be opened longer than 9 mm along the lateral optic nerve or injury to the IV nerve can occur. Starting at the oculomotor foramen, the opening of the cavernous sinus should be limited to 7 mm to avoid injuring the IV nerve. Finally, the optic strut can be a reliable bony landmark that separates the subarachnoid space and extradural compartments along the anterior and medial ICA.

Surgery for carotid dural ring aneurysms

Carotid aneurysms of the paraclinoid segment are usually located in the intradural space, but can infrequently straddle the intra- and extradural space. We present 2 cases of unruptured carotid dural ring aneurysms with an aneurysmal sac that straddled the distal dural ring. Each paraclinoid aneurysm projected superiorly from the anterior surface of the internal carotid artery with a relatively flattened dome and central indentation on angiography. The aneurysmal domes were circumscribed by the distal dural ring and straddled the intra- and extradural space. After broad opening of the distal dural ring, aneurysms were successfully obliterated by clip application in parallel with the internal carotid artery. These cases underscore the significance of an aneurysmal dome indentation on angiographic images as a reflection of aneurysmal circumscription by the distal dural ring. Aneurysms that straddle the intra- and extradural space may require broad opening of the distal dural ring for adequate control and clipping.

Surgery for carotid dural ring aneurysms

Background Carotid aneurysms of the paraclinoid segment are usually located in the intradural space, but can infrequently straddle the intra- and extradural space. Case description We present 2 cases of unruptured carotid dural ring aneurysms with an aneurysmal sac that straddled the distal dural ring. Each paraclinoid aneurysm projected superiorly from the anterior surface of the internal carotid artery with a relatively flattened dome and central indentation on angiography. The aneurysmal domes were circumscribed by the distal dural ring and straddled the intra- and extradural space. After broad opening of the distal dural ring, aneurysms were successfully obliterated by clip application in parallel with the internal carotid artery. Conclusion These cases underscore the significance of an aneurysmal dome indentation on angiographic images as a reflection of aneurysmal circumscription by the distal dural ring. Aneurysms that straddle the intra- and extradural space may require broad opening of the distal dural ring for adequate control and clipping.

Commentary

In this retrospective review of 61 patients, the authors propose a new classification scheme for aneurysms arising from the ophthalmic segment of the internal carotid artery. The aneurysms are classified into four variants. Type Ia is a classic ophthalmic artery aneurysm. Type Ib arises more distally on the supraclinoid ICA but not on the origin of the ophthalmic artery. Type II is an inferolateral ICA aneurysm. Type IIIa arises from the medial wall of the C5 segment and has been described as an anteromedial or cave aneurysm. Type IIIb would probably be classified as a cave or cavernous aneurysm. Type IV aneurysms are similar to type II but are much larger and enlarge the distal dural ring. They may be partially in and out of the subarachnoid space. The authors are an experienced team and have an excellent reputation for performing outstanding work and research in neurovascular surgery.

Paraclinoid Carotid Aneurysms: Surgical Management, Complications, and Outcome Based on a New Classification Scheme.

The site of origin, projection, and relationship of aneurysms arising from the ophthalmic segment of the internal carotid artery (ICA) to adjacent structures are heterogeneous. Based on a retrospective analysis of 61 patients with aneurysms in this location, we developed a simple numerical classification system to guide surgical planning. We used angiographic findings to categorize the aneurysms. We followed the nomenclature of the carotid segments by Bouthillier et al (Neurosurgery 1996;38:425-432), C4 being the intracavernous ICA, C5 the clinoidal segment, and C6 the ophthalmic segment of the ICA. The aneurysms were divided into four major types: Types Ia and Ib projected superiorly and arose from the dorsal surface of C6. Type Ia was related to the ophthalmic artery. Type Ib aneurysms were sessile and had no branch relations. Type II aneurysms were related to the ventral wall of the C6 segment without any branch relation. Type IIIa variant arose from medial wall of the C6 segment and was related to the superior hypophyseal artery. Type IIIb arose from the medial wall of the C5 segment below the dural reflection without any branch relation. Large type IV aneurysms arose from the C5 and C6 segments, widening the distal dural ring. Patients' postoperative status and visual and overall outcomes were analyzed. Ultimately, this classification helped us to plan operative approaches and clip selection.