Douglas-fir Plantations Research Articles

Selective Postplanting Forb Control Increased Growth of Douglas-Fir but Not Western Larch Seedlings in Idaho

Abstract Weeding (commonly referred to as release) is a common practice in major timber-producing regions of the United States, yet the effects have not been well examined in recently established plantations in northern Idaho. This study tested the effects of selective postplanting forb control with clopyralid herbicide applied 1 year after planting on the growth and survival of Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii var. glauca) and western larch (Larix occidentalis) for 5 years across a site productivity gradient in northern Idaho. Forb cover was reduced in Douglas-fir plots but not western larch plots. The result was an increase in diameter, height, and stem volume of Douglas-fir seedlings 5 years after treatment at low and high productivity sites, but no effect on western larch. Survival of both species was unaffected by the treatment and remained high, likely because of the generally high productivity of all sites. Results suggest that postplanting forb control with clopyralid may be best suited to Douglas-fir plantations in the region. The early gains in size are likely to persist into the future given the divergent growth trajectories observed, potentially shortening rotations and increasing final stand volume production. Study Implications: Clopyralid is an effective tool for selectively controlling forbs after planting in recently established plantations in northern Idaho. The response was species-specific. Results showed Douglas-fir had positive gains in size 5 years after treatment, whereas western larch growth was unaffected. Results can help guide operational decisions regarding whether and in which situations clopyralid may be applied to accelerate stand growth by reducing postplanting competition.

Effects of Swiss Needle Cast on the Profitability and Optimal Management of Douglas-fir Plantations in Western Oregon

Abstract This study conducts an economic analysis to evaluate the impact of Swiss needle cast (SNC) caused by Nothophaeocryptopus gaeumannii on Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) plantations at the stand level in western Oregon. We examine timber and nontimber benefits across varying degrees of SNC severity considering timber benefits and carbon sequestration benefits. By comparing these values with unaffected Douglas-fir stands, our aim is to quantify the economic losses associated with SNC in terms of the land expectation values. The total land expectation value for a stand affected by SNC ranges from $556 to $2,179/ac, representing an average decrease of 50% ($1,066/ac) in economic revenues compared with a Douglas-fir stand without SNC infestation. Engaging in cost-effective annual management activities, with maximum costs of $43–$56/ac, could offset the profitability decline. On average, the total losses in profits for the current plantations affected by SNC are estimated to be around $206.5–430 million. Study Implications: In this study, we examine the economic impacts of Swiss needle cast (SNC) on the profitability of western Douglas-fir in Oregon. Our results reveal that profits for landowners can be, on average, reduced by $1,066/ac when their stand is infested by SNC, representing a 50% loss in profitability. Landowners could potentially mitigate these losses by engaging in annual management activities aimed at preventing Douglas-fir infestation, incurring a cost ranging between $43–56/ac, which could offset the reduction in profitability.

First report of Phytophthora pluvialis in Douglas fir plantations in Belgium

First report of <i>Phytophthora pluvialis</i> in Douglas fir plantations in Belgium

Douglas-fir plantations impact stream and groundwater chemistry in western Europe: Insights from three case studies in France and Luxembourg

In rural areas, nitrate concentrations in surface waters most often originate from the leaching of excess N fertilizer in agricultural lands, whereas forested catchments often have good water quality. However, Douglas-fir plantations may induce nitrogen cycle unbalances which may lead to an excess of nitrate production in the soil. We hypothesize that the excess of production of nitrate in the soil and nitrate leaching to streamwater is greater in catchments planted with Douglas fir. We used paired catchments in both France and Luxembourg with different land covers (Douglas-fir, Spruce, Deciduous, Grassland and clearcut) which were monitored over a 3–5 year period in order to assess the effect of Douglas-fir plantations on the chemical composition of surface water. Nitrate concentration in the soil and groundwater were also monitored. The results show that nitrate concentrations in streams draining Douglas-fir catchments were two to ten times higher than in streams draining other land covers, but were similar to the clearcut catchment. Nitrate concentrations under Douglas-fir in groundwater (up to 50 mg L−1) and in the soil were also higher than under all other land covers. Soil nitrate concentration was related to stream nitrate concentration. This suggests that soil processes, through excessive nitrate production under Douglas-fir, are driving the nitrate concentration in the stream water and our hypothesis of a transfer of a fairly large proportion of this excessive production from the soil to the stream is supported. This study also shows that nitrate concentrations in surface and ground waters in rural areas could also originate from Douglas fir forested catchments. The impact of Douglas-fir is nevertheless reduced downstream through a dilution effect: mixing tree species at the catchment scale could thus be a solution to mitigate the effect of Douglas-fir on nitrate concentration in surface waters.

Bee diversity decreases rapidly with time since harvest in intensively managed conifer forests.

Despite widespread concerns about the anthropogenic drivers of global pollinator declines, little information is available about the impacts of land management practices on wild bees outside of agricultural systems, including in forests managed intensively for wood production. We assessed changes in wild bee communities with time since harvest in 60 intensively managed Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) stands across a gradient in stand ages spanning a typical harvest rotation. We measured bee abundance, species richness, and alpha and beta diversity, as well as habitat characteristics (i.e., floral resources, nesting substrates, understory vegetation, and early seral forest in the surrounding landscape) during the spring and summer of 2018 and 2019. We found that bee abundance and species richness declined rapidly with stand age, decreasing by 61% and 48%, respectively, for every 5 years since timber harvest. Asymptotic estimates of Shannon and Simpson diversity were highest in stands 6-10 years post-harvest and lowest after the forest canopy had closed, ~11 years post-harvest. Bee communities in older stands were nested subsets of bee communities found in younger stands, indicating that changes were due to species loss rather than turnover as the stands aged. Bee abundance-but not species richness-was positively associated with floral resource density, and neither metric was associated with floral richness. The amount of early seral forest in the surrounding landscape seemed to enhance bee species richness in older, closed-canopy stands, but otherwise had little effect. Changes in the relative abundance of bee species did not relate to bee functional characteristics such as sociality, diet breadth, or nesting substrate. Our study demonstrates that Douglas-fir plantations develop diverse communities of wild bees shortly after harvest, but those communities erode rapidly over time as forest canopies close. Therefore, stand-scale management activities that prolong the precanopy closure period and enhance floral resources during the initial stage of stand regeneration will provide the greatest opportunity to enhance bee diversity in landscapes dominated by intensively managed conifer forests.

Estimating Stand-Level Carbon Supply Curves for Loblolly Pine and Douglas-Fir Plantations

AbstractWe estimate the carbon sequestration supply curve at the stand level based on the optimal rotation decision and conduct a marginal analysis for payments necessary for postponing harvest for additional 1-year increments of two commercially important species in the United States, loblolly pine and Douglas-fir. Under certain costs, production and timber prices assumptions, payments ranged from $62.23 ($26.97–$105.87) ac/yr. for loblolly pine plantations and $399.17 ($189.80–$628.72) ac/yr. for Douglas-fir plantations. Our results indicate that higher carbon sequestration occurs with higher site index, higher trees per acre, and in unthinned stands. Significant variability within and between species was heavily dependent on the number of years that final harvest was postponed. In addition, we show the effect of prices on the quantity supplied under multiple silvicultural treatments. The study should assist willing forest landowners and potential partners to determine initial reservation prices for carbon sequestration and temporary provision for a 1-year period in line with programs offering this contracting mechanism.

Douglas Fir Growth Is Constrained by Drought: Delineating the Climatic Limits of Timber Species under Seasonally Dry Conditions

There is debate on which tree species can sustain forest ecosystem services in a drier and warmer future. In Europe, the use of non-native timber species, such as Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii [Mirb.] Franco), is suggested as a solution to mitigate climate change impacts because of their high growth resilience to drought. However, the biogeographical, climatic and ecological limits for widely planted timber species still need to be defined. Here, we study the growth response to climate variables and drought of four Douglas fir plantations in northern Spain subjected to contrasting climate conditions. Further, we measure wood density in one of the sites to obtain a better understanding of growth responses to climate. Correlative analyses and simulations based on the Vaganov–Shaskin process-based model confirm that growth of Douglas fir is constrained by warm and dry conditions during summer and early autumn, particularly in the driest study site. Minimum wood density increased in response to dry spring conditions. Therefore, planting Douglas fir in sites with a marked summer drought will result in reduced growth but a dense earlywood. Stands inhabiting dry sites are vulnerable to late-summer drought stress and can act as “sentinel plantations”, delineating the tolerance climate limits of timber species.

Soil solution chemistry in 11 monitoring plots of Douglas-fir plantations in France: implications for soil fertility

Soil solution chemistry in 11 monitoring plots of Douglas-fir plantations in France: implications for soil fertility

A Place for Inquiry, A Place for Wonder: The Andrews Forest. By William G. Robbins

William Robbins’s latest study makes an important contribution to the environmental history of the Pacific Northwest through its thorough, careful scholarship that documents a significant, as-yet little recognized site in our nation’s forest science history. In A Place for Inquiry, A Place for Wonder: The Andrews Forest, Robbins argues that the 15,800-acre experimental forest—“a cloistered place, unknown to the vast majority of Oregon citizens” (p. 192)—is the site of significant contributions to ecosystem science, as well as the environmental humanities, at regional, national, and international scales. The H.J. Andrews (named posthumously for Horace J. Andrews, Regional Forester of the U.S. Forest Service’s Pacific Northwest Region (1943–1951)), located west of the Cascade Mountains within the Willamette National Forest, was established in 1948. Over its seven-decade history, this Experimental Forest of the U.S. Forest Service has generated insights about old-growth Douglas fir forests and plantations and the drainage basin’s watershed processes....

Ten-year Douglas-fir regeneration and stand productivity differ among contrasting silvicultural regimes in western Washington, USA

In the Pacific Northwestern USA, concerns regarding impacts of forest harvesting on visual quality, wildlife habitat, and carbon management have prompted evaluations of alternative silvicultural regimes for coast Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii var. menziesii). Research was initiated in 1998 near Olympia WA USA to conduct long-term comparisons among six silvicultural regimes: clearcut (harvest all trees), two age (harvest all except 38 mature trees ha−1), patches (harvest 20% of the area in 0.6–2.0 ha tracts), groups (harvest 20% of the area in 0.1–0.5 ha tracts), thinning (reduce stand density to 45% of the biological maximum for Douglas-fir), and a non-treated control. Harvested areas in the first four regimes were planted with Douglas-fir seedlings. This report focuses on tree regeneration and stand productivity during the first decade of the study. Fifth year height of planted Douglas-fir was greater in the clearcut regime (1.8 m) than in the patches and groups regimes (1.1–1.2 m). Fifth year tree regeneration in the clearcut and two-age regimes was dominated by Douglas-fir (80–86% of seedlings), but regeneration in the patches and groups regimes was composed of a mixture of conifer and hardwood species. Ten-year periodic annual increment (PAI) in Douglas-fir ingrowth volume was greater in the clearcut regime (1.4 m3 ha−1 yr−1) than in the control (0.1 m3 ha−1 yr−1), whereas ingrowth volume PAI of other conifer species was greater in the two-age regime (0.4 m3 ha−1 yr−1) than in the control (0.0 m3 ha−1 yr−1). Tree regeneration responses indicated increasing abundance of shade tolerant species in the non-clearcut regimes, especially western hemlock (Tsuga heterophylla). Fifth year cover of the vine, California blackberry (Rubus ursinus), in the clearcut regime (21%) was over four times that in the control (5%). Ground disturbance in the clearcut regime reduced 5th-year height of the shrubs, salal (Gaultheria shallon) and red huckleberry (Vaccinium parvifolium), by 40–50% compared to the control. Ten-year volume PAI of Douglas-fir was linearly related to post-harvest stand basal area (r2 = 0.94), and the relationship did not vary significantly among the three replicate sites. During the first decade of the study, Douglas-fir regeneration and stand productivity differed among silvicultural regimes because of post-harvest variation in stand edge competition, species composition of tree seedlings and ingrowth, and residual stand density.

Distribution of a Foliage Disease Fungus Within Canopies of Mature Douglas-Fir in Western Oregon.

Nothophaeocryptopus gaeumannii is a common native, endophytic fungus of Douglas-fir foliage, which causes Swiss needle cast, an important foliage disease that is considered a threat to Douglas-fir plantations in Oregon. Disease expression is influenced by fungal fruiting bodies (pseudothecia), which plug the stomata and inhibit gas exchange. Trees are impacted when pseudothecia plug stomates on 1-year-old and older needles resulting in early needle abscission. Mature (100 years+) trees appear to be less impacted from disease, and we hypothesize this is due to the greater emergence of pseudothecia on older than younger needles, which allows for more needle retention. We measured the density of pseudothecia occluding stomates across 2- to 5-year-old needles from upper, middle, and lower canopy positions of mature trees at three sites in the Oregon Coast Range and two sites in the western Oregon Cascade Mountains. Binomial generalized linear mixed model (GLMM) was used to test for the effects of canopy position (upper, middle, and lower), sites, needle age (2-5 years old), and years (2016 and 2017), and their interactions on the pseudothecia density. Pseudothecia density varied annually depending on sites, needle age and canopy positions. Pseudothecia density peaked on 3-, and 4-year-old needles, however, needles emerging from the same year, like 2-year-old needles in 2016 and 3-year-old needles in 2017 both emerged in 2014, had consistently similar patterns of pseudothecia density for both years, across site and canopy positions. Canopy position was important for 3-, and 4-year-old needles, showing less pseudothecia in the lower canopy. This research confirms that N. gaeumannii pseudothecia density is greatest in 3- and 4-year old needles in mature trees in contrast to plantations where pseudothecia density usually peaks on 2-year-old needles, and that pseudothecia density (disease severity) is generally lower in mature trees. Something about mature forest canopies and foliage appears to increase the time it takes for pseudothecia to emerge from the needles, in contrast to younger plantations, thus allowing the mature trees to have greater needle retention.

Spatial Genetic Structure of the Insect-Vectored Conifer Pathogen Leptographium wageneri Suggests Long Distance Gene Flow Among Douglas-fir Plantations in Western Oregon

Many fungi in the Ophiostomatales are vectored by bark beetles that introduce these fungi directly into their tree hosts. Most of these fungal associates have little effect on their hosts, but some can cause serious diseases. One such fungus, Leptographium wageneri, causes an economically and ecologically important tree disease known as black stain root disease (BSRD). For this study, 159 full genome sequences of L. wageneri were analyzed using a population genomics approach to investigate the epidemiology, dispersal capabilities, and reproductive biology of this fungus. Analyses were performed with SNP haplotypes from 155 isolates of L. wageneri var. pseudotsugae collected in 16 Douglas-fir stands in Oregon and 4 isolates of L. wageneri var. wageneri collected in pinyon pine stands in southern California. These two host-specific varieties appear to be evolutionarily divergent, likely due a combination of factors such as host differentiation and geographic isolation. We analyzed gene flow and population structure within and among Douglas-fir plantations in western Oregon to infer the relative importance of local vs. long distance dispersal in structuring populations of L. wageneri var. pseudotsugae. Long-distance gene flow has occurred between Douglas-fir plantations, contributing to diversity and population structure within stands, and likely reflecting the behavior of an important insect vector. Genetic clustering analyses revealed the presence of unique local clusters within stands and plantations in addition to those common among multiple stands or plantations. Although populations of L. wageneri var. pseudotsugae are primarily asexual, two mating types were present in many stands, suggesting that recombination is at least possible and may contribute to genetic diversity.

Carbon balance for biosolids use in commercial Douglas Fir plantations in the Pacific Northwest

Municipal biosolids are commonly used to fertilize Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) plantations in the Pacific Northwest. An intensive soil sampling was conducted to quantify the effects of long-term biosolids application on soil carbon, nitrogen and bulk density for forest soils. This information was used to calculate a carbon balance for biosolids use in commercial tree plantations. Paired control and treated sites on two soil series (Klaus and Tokul) were included with samples collected to a 30 cm depth. A significant decrease in bulk density for two depths, but no changes in total C or N were observed in the Klaus soil. In the Tokul soil, biosolids fertilization increased C storage (total C * bulk density) for three of the four measured depths, resulting in an increase in total C from 112.8 Mg C ha−1 to 172 Mg C ha−1 for the 0–30 cm depth. A comparable increase in N was observed, with significant increases in N storage for all measured depths. The C balance considered fuel use associated with transport and application as costs. The fertilizer (N and P) content of the biosolids and changes in soil C were considered as credits. The balance showed net sequestration for both soil series. Carbon benefits for the Klaus soil totaled −0.2 Mg CO2 per Mg biosolids. Benefits in the Tokul soil totaled −5.15 Mg CO2 per Mg biosolids. Based on diameter at breast height (DBH) biosolids use also resulted in increased tree growth for both soil series. However, differences in stand age and stocking rate complicated interpretation of these results.

Persistence of the Swiss Needle Cast Outbreak in Oregon Coastal Douglas-Fir and New Insights from Research and Monitoring.

Swiss needle cast (SNC), caused by Nothophaeocryptopus gaeumannii, is a foliage disease of Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii), that reduces growth in native stands and exotic plantations worldwide. An outbreak of SNC began in coastal Oregon in the mid-1990s and has persisted since that time. Here we review the current state of knowledge after 24 years of research and monitoring, with a focus on Oregon, although the disease is significant in coastal Washington and has recently emerged in southwestern British Columbia. We present new insights into SNC distribution, landscape patterns, disease epidemiology and ecology, host-pathogen interactions, trophic and hydrologic influences, and the challenges of Douglas-fir plantation management in the presence of the disease. In Oregon, the SNC outbreak has remained geographically contained but has intensified. Finally, we consider the implications of climate change and other recently emerged foliage diseases on the future of Douglas-fir plantation management.

Differences in Growth and Log Quality of Douglas-Fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii (Mirb.) Franco) Provenances

Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii (Mirb.) Franco) is a non-native conifer from western North America that was introduced into European forests at the end of the 19th century. Plantations of Douglas-fir in Europe have shown good performance, quality, and resilience to exacerbating climatic conditions. However, all these qualities strongly depend on provenance. A total of 1061 surviving trees of fifteen different Douglas-fir provenances were measured in a Slovenian provenance trial that was established within the framework of the 1966/1967 IUFRO seed collection program. We found significant differences among provenances with respect to survival rate, growth performance, and log quality. The total recorded yield of the 46-year-old stand was 602.9 m3/ha, and the average survival rate was 43%. The correlation of juvenile tree heights in 1985 and their average breast height diameters in 2017 is positive and significant. Based on vitality and diameter, the best performing provenances were Yelm and Cathlamet. The provenance with the best log quality assessed through branchiness is Jefferson (Olympic Peninsula, western Washington). All the most promising provenances for western Slovenia (Central Europe) originate from the low-altitude western coast of Washington (WACO), with the Cathlamet provenance showing the best combination of good growth, survival rate, and log quality.

Invertebrate communities in adjacent Douglas fir and native beech forests in New Zealand

Non-native trees profoundly alter the structure and resilience of native forest ecosystems through direct or indirect effects on ecosystem processes, e.g. by altering invertebrate communities, but such effects are poorly understood in New Zealand. We sampled adjacent stands of the non-native tree Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) and native beech (Nothofagaceae) forests and tested whether the overall invertebrate communities varied across forest types. We then assessed whether natural enemies, both trophic-generalist predators and more trophic-specialist parasitoids, differed across forest types. We found a trend for lower overall invertebrate family diversity in Douglas fir plantations compared to native beech forests. Parasitoid abundance was lower in Douglas fir forests compared to native beech forests, although we could not tease apart whether these effects were due to differences in forest age, forest type, or a combination of these factors. Our findings suggest that there are subtle shifts in invertebrate community composition from native forests to non-native forests, and that trophic specialisation might play a key role in determining which natural enemies can inhabit non-native forests in New Zealand. Nevertheless, our small sample size calls for further exploration of these patterns.

Effects of small aggregates of mature tree retention on adjacent planted coastal Douglas-fir growth and survival

Long-term retention of mature trees at the time of harvesting, called variable retention, has increased significantly since the 1990s as a silvicultural practice for maintaining stand-level biodiversity. A common approach is aggregated retention where groups of trees are left to increase structural diversity and provide forest influence over the adjacent harvested area. Despite the increased global application of aggregated retention, the growth and survival of adjacent trees has received less research effort than biodiversity studies. This knowledge gap was addressed with a study of small (0.01 to 0.58 ha, mean 0.3 ha) retained mature tree aggregates in harvested areas on southeast Vancouver Island, British Columbia, Canada. Coastal Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii var. menziesii (Mirb.) Franco.) seedlings were planted in ~10-m-wide belt transects (three planting rows), extending up to 10 m into and 50 m away from aggregate edges in four cardinal directions. Nitrogen fertilizer was applied at planting to some transects. Basal diameter, height and survival of the planted Douglas-fir were measured for an average of 11 years. We used nonlinear mixed-effects models to assess the relationships of planted-tree basal diameter and height growth to distance from aggregate edge, edge orientation, planted-tree age, fertilization and aggregate characteristics (basal area and height). We extended planting into the aggregates to model tree response on both sides of edges. Modeled growth rates were slower for 10-year-old planted trees under the aggregate canopy and along the edges of the harvested area compared to growth at about 10 m and greater distance from aggregate edges; i.e. trees achieved 90% of their potential height and diameter by about 10 m from the aggregate canopy. Impacts were greatest on north-facing edges and least on south-facing edges, although differences were very small. We examined planted-tree survival by proximity to aggregate edges using a Cox proportional hazards model. Survival was lower directly beneath the aggregate canopy and up to approximately 5 m into the harvested area and was also slightly lower adjacent to south-facing edges. Fertilized trees showed a minor increase in survival versus unfertilized trees. Structural characteristics of aggregates had only a minimal impact on planted-tree growth and survival. This study helps provide a better understanding of the relationships among planted-tree growth and survival and edge effects for implementation of aggregated retention.

Physiology and Growth of Douglas-Fir and Redwood Seedlings Planted After Partial Harvesting

Reforestation following timber harvests and natural disturbances is an essential component of sustainable forest management. As disturbances such as drought-induced mortality and wildland fires spread across many forests of the western U.S., a better understanding of the influences of stand structure on seedling physiology can foster more effective reforestation efforts. Moreover, as climate throughout the West is projected to become hotter and drier, it is important to investigate regeneration under xeric conditions, particularly for species restricted to mesic habitats. To study the influences of stand structure and climate on regeneration success, we monitored physiology (water potential [Ψ] and stomatal conductance [gs]), growth (change in basal diameter and biomass accumulation), and mortality rate of planted Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) and coast redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) seedlings for two growing seasons after partial harvesting in inland northern California. Compared to seedlings in the no-cut and moderate-retention treatments, seedlings in the gap (100% cut) treatment had the highest Ψ and gs, greatest growth, and lowest mortality. We also found that compared to Douglas-fir, redwood had higher Ψ and gs, greater growth, and lower mortality. Overall, our study indicates that low-retention silvicultural treatments can minimize water stress and maximize gas exchange, growth, and survival in regenerating seedlings. Our results also demonstrate that redwood, a species generally restricted to mesic coastal habitats, can successfully establish in xeric inland sites when planted after partial harvesting, even during drought conditions.

Long-term effects of forest harvesting on summer low flow deficits in the Coast Range of Oregon

We examined long-term changes in daily streamflow associated with forestry practices over a 60-year period (1959–2017) in the Alsea Watershed Study, Oregon Coast Range, Pacific Northwest, USA. We quantified the response of daily streamflow to (1) harvest of mature/old forest in 1966, (2) 43- to 53-yr and 48- to 58-yr-old industrial plantation forests in 2006–2009, and (3) logging of the plantations using contemporary forest practices, including retention of a riparian buffer, in 2010 and 2014. Daily streamflow from a 40- to 53-yr-old Douglas-fir plantation was 25% lower on average, and 50% lower during the summer (June 15 to Sept 15 of 2006 to 2009), relative to the reference watershed containing mature/old forest. Low flow deficits persisted over six or more months of each year. Surprisingly, contemporary forest practices (i.e., clearcutting of the plantation with riparian buffers in 2009 and 2014) had only a minor effect on streamflow deficits. Two years after logging in 2014, summer streamflow deficits were similar to those observed prior to harvest (under 40- to 53-yr-old plantations). High evapotranspiration from rapidly regenerating vegetation, including planted Douglas-fir, and from the residual plantation forest in the riparian buffer appeared to explain the persistence of streamflow deficits after logging of nearly 100% of the forest plantation. Results of this study indicated that 40- to 50-yr rotations of Douglas-fir plantations can produce persistent, large summer low flow deficits. While the clearcutting of these plantations, with retention of riparian buffers, increased daily streamflow slightly, flows did not return to pre-first entry conditions. Further work is needed to examine how intensively managed plantation forests along with expected warmer, drier conditions in the future may influence summer low streamflow and aquatic ecosystems.

Synergistic effects of wild ungulates and management intensification suppress native plants and promote exotics

In managed forest landscapes, conflicts among wood production, ungulates, native biodiversity, and exotic species are common. As humanity allocates more land as intensively managed plantations, these conflicts may become more severe. For instance, native ungulates have been implicated in the loss of native plant diversity, declines in timber revenues and the spread of exotic species in many forest systems, yet the synergistic effects of management and ungulate herbivory are not well understood.We hypothesized that herbicide and herbivore-induced suppression of native forage species promotes the release of exotic species in young forest plantations. Further, we expected herbivory and the retention of native forage via less intensive management would have negative consequences for reforestation objectives. To test this hypothesis, we conducted an experiment that manipulated management intensity (via herbicides) and access of two deer species to vegetation (via exclosures) on 28 operational Douglas-fir plantations of the Pacific Northwest, USA. We recorded yearly plant species cover estimates and tested the effects of herbivory and herbicides on native and exotic plants during the first six years of plantation establishment.Heavier herbicide treatments reduced the cover and diversity of native plants, and increased the cover of exotics over time, particularly that of exotic herbaceous species. Regardless of herbicide intensity, herbivores reduced the cover of native forage species. In a treatment that represents operational standards applied to over 2.5 million ha in the region, the suppression of native species by deer corresponded with an increase in exotic species cover by 23 percent, resulting in equitable abundance of native and exotic plants. As expected, Douglas-fir growth was suppressed when herbivores were present and vegetation was left untreated by herbicides, although the presence of deer promoted both crop-tree growth and the relative abundance of exotics in our most intensive treatment, presumably due to the added suppression of native competitors.Our findings suggest that wild ungulates amplify management-driven shifts toward exotic species in intensively managed forest plantations. Exotic plant forage status and adaptations to frequent disturbance seem to be key mechanisms for the synergistic effects we observed. Without herbicides, diverse assemblages of native species are buffered from herbivory and exotic species proliferation, with potential tradeoffs for timber production. Our results highlight the role of management intensity in modifying the interactions among exotic plants and native herbivores, contributing to a mechanistic understanding of the role of native biodiversity in regulating exotic species spread. Our data provide further support for growing evidence that synergistic effects of multiple drivers can facilitate exotic plant proliferation.