a chromatid break is obviously not a simple matter, since the latter can involve the loss of up to 20 Mbp, and evidence from some radiosensitive sublines suggests that secondary chromatin configuration influences conversion of DNA damage to chromosome breaks. These and other questions were addressed at a meeting held in Montreal in June 1997 which brought together experts in DNA damage and repair, chromatin structure and cytogenetics to delineate the route from a DNA lesion to a dead cell. The topics discussed moved through increasing levels of complexity from damage distribution at the molecular level to nucleoprotein structure to the organization of nuclear domains. Several presentations described investigation of the genomic distribution of DNA lesions. In one of these (M-E. Mirault, Universiti Laval), a single-strand break (SSB)-specific S1 nuclease was used as a probe. Similar cleavage patterns were found with a variety of chemical agents and with ionizing radiation with preferential localization of S1 cleavage in matrix-associated DNA. In another study (A. I. Kassis, Harvard Medical School), 1251 was used to assess the effects of OH radicals produced in proximity to DNA. Results were consistent with DSBs being produced by a single-event mechanism when a high radical density was generated close to naked DNA, while for higher-order chromatin both production of DSBs and toxicity appeared to be largely indirect in nature. The genomic distribution of naturally occurring DNA DSBs was examined using a technique in which illegitimate integration of a transgene in murine fibroblast DNA was localized by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis (G. Dellaire and P. Chartrand, Institut du Cancer de Montrial). Results indicated that illegitimate integration occurs randomly at megabase resolution in murine fibroblasts and, since the initiation of illegitimate integration would require a DNA DSB, the corollary is that DSBs occur randomly within the murine genome at megabase resolution. An important aspect of the organization of the eukaryotic chromosome which was addressed by several speakers at this meeting is the arrangement of DNA supercoils into looped domains anchored at intervals of 30-60 kbp to the nuclear matrix through matrix attachment region (MAR)-specific sequences (J. L. Roti Roti, Washington University, St. Louis; J. L. Schwartz, University of Washington, Seattle). These structures create independent domains of torsional stress in chromatin which are important for spatial control of DNA replication, gene transcription and DNA repair. Based on data obtained with assays that use high-salt extraction of nuclei (nucleoids), it is hypothesized that there are two categories of looped domains: those with loose (protease-sensitive) attachments to the nuclear matrix and those which are tightly attached to the nuclear matrix and are resistant to disruption. In the first case breaks can affect rewinding both in the loop where they occur and in adjacent loops, while in the second case breaks affect rewinding only in the loop where they occur and the adjacent loops are insulated from damage. In one subgroup of cell lines, differences in radiosensitivity could be explained in terms of the ability of anchoring regions to isolate DNA domains from changes in DNA supercoiling, whereas in other cell lines rewinding and radiation resistance are associated with a subset of specific proteins located at the anchoring regions. In another study (P. J. Johnston, British Columbia Cancer Research Centre), selective examination of DSBs occurring as multiples within looped DNA structures revealed identical subsets of DSBs repairing with slow kinetics through the DNA-dependent protein kinase (PK)/Ku pathway. Correction of the results to account for differences in the rate of elution of cells actively replicating DNA gave a looped domain size of 3.0 Mbp for all cells examined. It was suggested that this is a fundamental unit of chromatin structure which may play an important part in the processing of DNA DSBs. 1Selected papers from this meeting will appear in this and future issues of Radiation Research.
Read full abstract