The hypothesis of this study was that grass silage digestibility would influence the response of dairy cows offered diets differing in crude protein (CP) content. Thirty-two mid-lactation Holstein dairy cows were used in a 2 period (21-d adaption phase, 7-d measurement phase), partially balanced change-over experiment. Four treatments were organized in a 2 × 2 factorial arrangement, comprising 2 grass silages differing in digestible organic matter in the dry matter (D-value; 748 and 668 g/kg DM, High-D and Low-D, respectively) and 2 total diet CP levels (target 145 g/kg DM and 175 g/kg DM, High CP and Low CP, respectively). The latter were achieved using 2 iso-energetic concentrates which differed in CP level (173 and 228 g/kg DM). Silages and concentrates were mixed and offered as a total mixed ration in a 50:50 DM ratio. At the end of the feeding study, nutrient utilization was measured using 4 cows per treatment. Except for milk urea nitrogen there were no interactions between silage digestibility and total diet CP for cow performance and nutrient utilization. The High-D silage improved cow performance and increased nitrogen-use-efficiency (NUE). Reducing total diet CP also increased NUE, but there were negative impacts on cow performance. While there were benefits of offering grass silage with a high digestibility, responses to total diet CP were similar at both levels of silage digestibility.