Disulfide Scrambling Research Articles

A GdIII-Based Spin Label at the Limits for Linewidth Reduction through Zero-Field Splitting Optimization.

The remarkably narrow central line in the electron paramagnetic resonance spectrum and the very weak zero-field splitting (ZFS) make [GdIII(NO3Pic)] ([GdIII(TPATCN)]) an attractive starting point for the development of spin labels. For retaining the narrow line of this parent complex when modifying it with a substituent enabling bioconjugation, alkyl with a somehow remote functional group as a substituent at the picolinate moiety was found to be highly suitable because ZFS stayed weak, even if the threefold axial symmetry was broken. The ZFS is so weak that hyperfine coupling and/or g-value variations noticeably determine the linewidth in Q band and higher fields when the biomolecule is protonated, which is the standard situation, and in W band and higher fields for the protonated complex in a fully deuterated surrounding. Clearly, [NDSE-{GdIII(NO3Pic)}], a spin label targeting the cysteines in a peptide, is at a limit of linewidth narrowing through ZFS minimization. The labeling reaction is highly chemoselective and, applied to a polyproline with two cysteine units, it took no more than a minute at 7 °C and pH 7.8. Subsequent disulfide scrambling is very slow and can therefore be prevented. Double electron-electron resonance and relaxation-induced dipolar modulation enhancement applied to the spin-labeled polyproline proved the spin label useful for distance determination in peptides.

Ultrasensitive disulfide scrambling analysis of mAbs by LC-MS with post-column reduction and glycine signal enhancement

Explicitly confirming the complete disulfide bond linkage pattern of a monoclonal antibody (mAb) presents a challenge in the biopharmaceutical industry. Although proper native disulfide connections are in high abundance for analytical purposes within a peptide mapping digest under non-reducing conditions, disulfide scrambling can also exist but be difficult to detect, let alone characterize, particularly at low levels. Here, we developed an ultrasensitive high-confidence method for identifying explicit disulfide connectivity in mAbs. By applying a post-column addition of tris (2-carboxyethyl)phosphine hydrochloride (TCEP) to the liquid chromatography (LC) eluent of a non-reduced mAb digest, partial reduction of disulfide peptides is achieved after the initial peptide separation, allowing both the parent disulfide and its reduced daughter peptides to co-elute for simultaneous mass spectrometry (MS) detection. Combining this concept with the recently discovered ability of glycine to enhance MS signal when added to the LC eluent, we demonstrate a method for detecting, characterizing and quantifying low-abundance disulfide scrambling in mAbs.

Development of a simple non-reduced peptide mapping method that prevents disulfide scrambling of mAbs without affecting tryptic enzyme activity

Non-reduced peptide mapping by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) analysis is a commonly used method for disulfide linkage characterization to assess structural integrity and quality of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). However, disulfide scrambling artifacts induced during sample preparation are often observed when basic pH and high temperatures are used during denaturation and digestion. To minimize disulfide scrambling artifacts, methods using various acidic pH conditions have been developed by multiple groups. However, lower pH conditions increase missed and non-specific cleavages, which complicates disulfide bond analysis because the majority of enzymes used in protein characterization are most efficient at alkaline pH. Here, we developed a non-reduced peptide mapping method for mAb characterization that minimizes disulfide scrambling at basic pH by adding an oxidizing agent, cystamine, and a low concentration of iodoacetamide (IAA) alkylating agent. Two human IgG1 mAbs, one with kappa light chain and another one with lambda light chain, were used as model proteins to develop and optimize the method. Using this novel method, disulfide scrambled peptides related to light chain-heavy chain (LC-HC) inter-disulfide disruption were significantly reduced with high reproducibility compared to conventional methods. Results demonstrated that the cystamine-added method is robust and minimizes disulfide scrambling artifacts produced during sample preparation.

Discovery of a dual pathway aggregation mechanism for a therapeutic constrained peptide.

Constrained peptides (CPs) have emerged as attractive candidates for drug discovery and development. To fully unlock the therapeutic potential of CPs, it is crucial to understand their physical stability and minimize the formation of aggregates that could induce immune responses. Although amyloid like aggregates have been researched extensively, few studies have focused on aggregates from other peptide scaffolds (e.g., CPs). In this work, a streamlined approach to effectively profile the nature and formation pathway of CP aggregates was demonstrated. Aggregates of various sizes were detected and shown to be amorphous. Though no major changes were found in peptide structure upon aggregation, these aggregates appeared to have mixed natures, consisting of primarily non-covalent aggregates with a low level of covalent species. This co-existence phenomenon was also supported by two kinetic pathways observed in time- and temperature-dependent aggregation studies. Furthermore, a stability study with 8 additional peptide variants exhibited good correlation between aggregation propensity and peptide hydrophobicity. Therefore, a dual aggregation pathway was proposed, with the non-covalent aggregates driven by hydrophobic interactions, whereas the covalent ones formed through disulfide scrambling. Overall, the workflow presented here provides a powerful strategy for comprehensive characterization of peptide aggregates and understanding their mechanisms of formation.

Development of Conformationally Constrained α-RgIA Analogues as Stable Peptide Antagonists of Human α9α10 Nicotinic Acetylcholine Receptors.

Non-opioid therapeutics for the treatment of neuropathic pain are urgently needed to address the ongoing opioid crisis. Peptides from cone snail venoms have served as invaluable molecules to target key pain-related receptors but can suffer from unfavorable physicochemical properties, which limit their therapeutic potential. In this work, we developed conformationally constrained α-RgIA analogues with high potency, receptor selectivity, and enhanced human serum stability to target the human α9α10 nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. The key lactam linkage introduced in α-RgIA fixed the favored globular conformation and suppressed disulfide scrambling. The NMR structure of the macrocyclic peptide overlays well with that of α-RgIA4, demonstrating that the cyclization does not perturb the overall conformation of backbone and key side-chain residues. Finally, a molecular docking model was used to rationalize the selective binding between a macrocyclic analogue and the α9α10 nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. These conformationally constrained antagonists are therefore promising candidates for antinociceptive therapeutic intervention.

Bis(vinylsulfonyl)piperazines as efficient linkers for highly homogeneous antibody-drug conjugates

Disulfide re-bridging strategy has demonstrated significant advantages in the construction of homogeneous antibody drug conjugates (ADCs). However, a major issue that disulfide scrambling at the hinge region of antibody leads to the formation of “half-antibody” has appeared for many re-bridging linkers. We present bis(vinylsulfonyl)piperazines (BVP) as efficient linkers to selectively re-bridge disulfides at the antigen-binding fragment (Fab) regions and produce highly homogeneous conjugates with a loading of two drugs without disulfide scrambling. We also found that optically active (S)-configuration linkers led to more sufficient conjugation compared with (R)-configuration. The BVP-linked ADCs demonstrated superior efficacy and antigen-selectivity in vitro cytotoxicity.

Review on the Application of Mixed-mode Chromatography for Separation of Structure Isoforms.

Proteins often generate structure isoforms naturally or artificially due to, for example, different glycosylation, disulfide scrambling, partial structure rearrangement, oligomer formation or chemical modification. The isoform formations are normally accompanied by alterations in charged state or hydrophobicity. Thus, isoforms can be fractionated by reverse-phase, hydrophobic interaction or ion exchange chromatography. We have applied mixed-mode chromatography for fractionation of isoforms for several model proteins and observed that cation exchange Capto MMC and anion exchange Capto adhere columns are effective in separating conformational isoforms and self-associated oligomers.

Characterization of Disulfide Linkages in Proteins by 193 nm Ultraviolet Photodissociation (UVPD) Mass Spectrometry.

Deciphering disulfide bond patterns in proteins remains a significant challenge. In the present study, interlinked disulfide bonds connecting peptide chains are homolytically cleaved with 193 nm ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD). Analysis of insulin showcased the ability of UVPD to cleave multiple disulfide bonds and provide sequence coverage of the peptide chains in the same MS/MS event. For proteins containing more complex disulfide bonding patterns, an approach combining partial reduction and alkylation mitigated disulfide scrambling and allowed assignment of the array of disulfide bonds. The 4 disulfide bonds of lysozyme and the 19 disulfide bonds of serotransferrin were characterized through LC/UVPD-MS analysis of nonreduced and partially reduced protein digests.

Photodisruption of the Structurally Conserved Cys-Cys-Trp Triads Leads to Reduction-Resistant Scrambled Intrachain Disulfides in an IgG1 Monoclonal Antibody.

Photostability conditions as prescribed by ICH guidelines induced highly reduction-resistant scrambled disulfides that contribute to the population of apparent nonreducible aggregates in an IgG1 mAb. Photoinduced cross-linked species were isolated under reducing conditions using an organic phase size exclusion chromatography (OP-SEC) method, followed by O18-labeling tryptic mapping to identify cross-linked peptides. Disulfide scrambling was observed within the IgG1 structurally conserved-intrachain cysteine-cysteine-tryptophan triads (Cys-Cys-Trp), and correlated with Trp-to-kynurenine (Kyn) photodegradation within these triads. We hypothesize that intrachain disulfides protect the proximal Trp within the Cys-Cys-Trp triads from photodegradation by enabling dissipation of Trp-absorbed UV energy via electron transfer to the disulfide bond. Finally, we propose three distinct mechanisms of photochemical degradation of monoclonal antibodies mediated by Trp residues.

Photodegradation Pathways of Protein Disulfides: Human Growth Hormone.

Comprehensive product characterization was performed for the photodegradation of protein disulfides, representatively of human growth hormone (somatotropin; hGH), in order to provide a product database, which will be useful for the general analysis of protein stability. HGH was photo-irradiated at λ = 254 and λ > 295nm and tryptic digests were analyzed by HPLC-MS to investigate light-induced disulfide degradation pathways. A total of 60 products were detected, and structures/tentative structures were assigned to the products by MS2 and MS3 analysis. The main products were reduced Cys residues, dithiohemiacetal, thioether and disulfide scrambling products. In addition, we detected Cys degradation products such as Cys thioaldehyde, dehydroalanine (Dha), Ala, Ser semialdehyde, Ser, S-sulfocysteine, and Gly. Frequently, the tryptic fragments contained more than one modification, i.e. a Cys degradation product in close proximity to a dehydrated amino acid. Several novel cross-links were detected between Cys and Tyr, Cys, Ser and Phe, Cys and Trp, and Trp and Tyr. Photo-induced protein fragmentation was detected specifically at or in close proximity to the disulfide bond between T6 and T16. An in-house packed 75cm nano-column enabled us to resolve various isomers/diastereomers of the photo-degradation products. A comprehensive analysis of photodegradation products revealed a variety of novel photo-products, including cross-links, originating from disulfide degradation. The mechanisms of product formation are discussed.

Production of an anti-Aβ antibody fragment in Pichia pastoris and in vitro and in vivo validation of its therapeutic effect.

ScFv-h3D6 has been shown as an efficient therapy in the 3xTg-AD mouse model of Alzheimer’s Disease. Because one of the major bottlenecks for the therapeutic uses of proteins produced in Escherichia coli is their potential contamination with endotoxins, LPS were extensively removed by a rather low-efficient, expensive, and time-consuming purification step. In addition, disulfide scrambling is favored in the reducing bacterial cytoplasm albeit the use of reductase deficient strains. To overcome these hurdles, as well as to improve the yield, the yeast Pichia pastoris, an endotoxin-free host system for recombinant protein production, has been used to produce scFv-h3D6, both in flask and in a fed-batch bioreactor. Comparison of the thermal stability of the obtained protein with that from E. coli showed no differences. Opposite to the case of the protein obtained from E. coli, no disulfide scrambled conformations or LPS traces were detected in that produced in P. pastoris. Cytotoxicity assays in SH-SY5Y neuroblastoma cell-cultures demonstrated that proteins from both expression systems were similarly efficient in precluding Aβ-induced toxicity. Finally, the 3xTg-AD mouse model was used to test the therapeutic effect of both proteins. Quantification of Aβ levels from cortex and hippocampus protein extracts by ELISA, and Aβ-immunohistochemistry, showed that both proteins reduced Aβ burden. This work demonstrates that scFv-h3D6 obtained from P. pastoris shows the same benefits as those already known for that obtained from E. coli, with multiple advantages in terms of recombinant production and safety.

Assessment of disulfide and hinge modifications in monoclonal antibodies.

During the last years there was a substantial increase in the use of antibodies and related proteins as therapeutics. The emphasis of the pharmaceutical industry is on IgG1, IgG2, and IgG4 antibodies, which are therefore in the focus of this article. In order to ensure appropriate quality control of such biopharmaceuticals, deep understanding of their chemical degradation pathways and the resulting impact on potency, pharmacokinetics, and safety is required. Criticality of modifications may be specific for individual antibodies and has to be assessed for each molecule. However, some modifications of conserved structure elements occur in all or at least most IgGs. In these cases, criticality assessment may be applicable to related molecules or molecule formats. The relatively low dissociation energy of disulfide bonds and the high flexibility of the hinge region frequently lead to modifications and cleavages. Therefore, the hinge region and disulfide bonds require specific consideration during quality assessment of mAbs. In this review, available literature knowledge on underlying chemical reaction pathways of modifications, analytical methods for quantification and criticality are discussed. The hinge region is prone to cleavage and is involved in pathways that lead to thioether bond formation, cysteine racemization, and iso‐Asp (Asp, aspartic acid) formation. Disulfide or sulfhydryl groups were found to be prone to reductive cleavage, trisulfide formation, cysteinylation, glutathionylation, disulfide bridging to further light chains, and disulfide scrambling. With regard to potency, disulfide cleavage, hinge cleavage, disulfide bridging to further light chains, and cysteinylation were found to influence antigen binding and fragment crystallizable (Fc) effector functionalities. Renal clearance of small fragments may be faster, whereas clearance of larger fragments appears to depend on their neonatal Fc receptor (FcRn) functionality, which in turn may be impeded by disulfide bond cleavage. Certain modifications such as disulfide induced aggregation and heterodimers from different antibodies are generally regarded critical with respect to safety. However, the detection of some modifications in endogenous antibodies isolated from human blood and the possibility of in vivo repair mechanisms may reduce some safety concerns.

Assigning Peptide Disulfide Linkage Pattern Among Regio-Isomers via Methoxy Addition to Disulfide and Tandem Mass Spectrometry.

Pinpointing disulfide linkage pattern is critical in the characterization of proteins and peptides consisting of multiple disulfide bonds. Herein, we report a method based on coupling online disulfide modification and tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) to distinguish peptide disulfide regio-isomers. Such a method relies on a new disulfide bond cleavage reaction in solution, involving methanol as a reactant and 254nm ultraviolet (UV) irradiation. This reaction leads to selective cleavage of a disulfide bond and formation of sulfenic methyl ester (-SOCH3) at one cysteine residue and a thiol (-SH) at the other. Under low energy collision-induced dissociation (CID), cysteine sulfenic methyl ester motif produces a signature methanol loss (-32Da), allowing its identification from other possible isomeric structures such as S-hydroxylmethyl (-SCH2OH) and methyl sulfoxide (-S(O)-CH3). Since disulfide bond can be selectively cleaved and modified upon methoxy addition, subsequent MS2 CID of the methoxy addition product provides enhanced sequence coverage as demonstrated by the analysis of bovine insulin. More importantly, this reaction does not induce disulfide scrambling, likely due to the fact that radical intermediates are not involved in the process. An approach based on methoxy addition followed by MS3 CID has been developed for assigning disulfide linkage patterns in peptide disulfide regio-isomers. This methodology was successfully applied to characterizing peptide systems having two disulfide bonds and three disulfide linkage isomers: side-by-side, overlapped, and looped-within-a-loop configurations. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Fast and Efficient non-reduced Lys-C digest using pressure cycling technology for antibody disulfide mapping by LC–MS

Conventional sample preparation for antibody disulfide mapping often requires relatively long digestion time (from several hours to overnight) and relatively high endoproteinase concentration. These conditions are typically necessitated by the fact that antibody molecules are not sufficiently denatured under non-reduced conditions and chaotropic agents are used during digestion to achieve optimal denaturation. Disulfide scrambling can occur as artifacts of digestion as proteins are incubated for extended periods, often at neutral to slightly alkaline pH conditions. Shortening digestion time and lowering the pH during digestion frequently result in incomplete peptide cleavages or variable recoveries. Here, we report the development of a fast and efficient non-reduced Lys-C digestion method based on pressure cycling technology (PCT) and its application in determining disulfide-linkages in monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). Conditions were optimized to ensure complete digestion of the mAb with minimal sample preparation-related disulfide scrambling. The PCT-based method was able to generate up to 10-fold signal increase for some disulfide peptides in a 1h Lys-C digestion compared to the conventional bench-top digestion method. As a result of the shorter digestion time, disulfide scrambling that is seen as a major assay artifact of the conventional method was reduced to less than 0.05% in tested molecules. The results show that the PCT-based method offers fast digestion in a shorter time for all the mAbs tested.

Evaluation of disulfide scrambling during the enzymatic digestion of bevacizumab at various pH values using mass spectrometry

Disulfide linkages play an important role in protein stability and activity. Thus, it is critical to characterize disulfide bonds to ensure the quality and function of protein pharmaceuticals. There are, however, problems associated with maintaining disulfide linkages in the conventional procedures that are used to digest a protein. In order to preserve enzyme activity during the digestion of a protein, it is commonly carried out at neutral to basic environment which increases the possibilities of disulfide bond scrambling. However, it is not easy to differentiate whether the scrambled disulfide linkages are initiated by the sample itself or whether they are induced during the protease digestion process. In this study, the optimum pH for minimizing disulfide bond rearrangements during the digestion process was determined. Three sets of proteases, trypsin plus Glu-C, Lys-C and thermolysin were used, followed by dimethyl labeling and mass spectrometry for a bevacizumab (Avastin) disulfide linkage analysis. No disulfide linkage scrambling was detected at pH6 when Lys-C or trypsin plus Glu-C were used as enzymes. When thermolysin was applied, some scrambled disulfide bonds were identified at pH5, 6 and 7. Nevertheless, there was less disulfide bond scrambling at a lower pH. All correct disulfide bonds on bevacizumab could be identified using this approach. The results demonstrated that by choosing the proper enzymes, using a lower pH environment for the digestion could reduce the degree of artifact disulfide scrambling.

Next-generation disulfide stapling: reduction and functional re-bridging all in one

Herein we present a significant step towards next-generation disulfide stapling reagents. A novel class of reagent has been designed to effect both disulfide reduction and functional re-bridging. The strategy has been applied to great success across various peptides and proteins. Moreover, application to a multi-disulfide system resulted in functional re-bridging without disulfide scrambling.

Development of a sample preparation method for monitoring correct disulfide linkages of monoclonal antibodies by liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry

The number and positions of disulfide linkages in a therapeutic monoclonal antibody (mAb) play a crucial role in forming and stabilizing a correct mAb structure that is critical to its function. Peptide mapping by liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry (LC–MS) analysis of enzymatically digested mAb under nonreducing condition is a powerful method for disulfide linkage characterization to ensure mAb drug function and quality. However, the development of a robust sample preparation method with improved digestion efficiency and minimized disulfide scrambling for disulfide linkage analysis is essential but challenging. In this study, a sample preparation method for analysis of correct disulfide linkages in therapeutic mAbs was developed. Instead of common trypsin digestion, Lys-C plus trypsin was used in this approach to improve digestion efficiency. In addition, lower digestion temperature (25 °C) and lower digestion pH (pH 6.8) were also examined to minimize disulfide scrambling. Our results showed that Lys-C plus trypsin digestion at pH 6.8 and 25 °C is a better sample preparation condition for all therapeutic mAbs tested in this study because of a better digestion efficiency (all expected disulfide linkages can be confidently observed) and minimal disulfide scrambling.

Alleviating nonlinear behavior of disulfide isoforms in the reversed-phase liquid chromatography of IgG2

Reversed-phase chromatography is an established method for characterizing the disulfide isoforms of IgG2. This work explores the effect of mobile phase gradient profile and sample concentration on the separation of disulfide isoforms. The acidic mobile phase can alter the relative proportions of disulfide isoforms, but only when the level of the reactive A1 isoform is much higher than for typical conditions of separation and typical IgG2 samples. Otherwise, there is minimal disulfide scrambling. A slower gradient and flow rate modestly improve resolution, but the peaks remain heavily overlapped. Resolution is further improved and nonlinear chromatography lessened when injection is performed under non-stacking conditions. Non-stacking conditions also keep the concentration from spiking at the head of the column, reducing noncovalent associations that can promote disulfide scrambling. The higher resolution from non-stacking injection reveals the presence of at least seven species.

Thiol–Disulfide Exchange in Peptides Derived from Human Growth Hormone During Lyophilization and Storage in the Solid State

Lyophilization (freeze-drying) is frequently used to stabilize protein therapeutics. However, covalent modifications such as thiol-disulfide exchange and disulfide scrambling can occur even in the solid state. The effects of lyophilization and storage of lyophilized powders on the mechanism and kinetics of thiol-disulfide exchange have not been elucidated and are explored here. Reaction kinetics was monitored in peptides corresponding to tryptic fragments of human growth hormone (T20 + T20-T21 or T20 + cT20-T21) during different stages of lyophilization and during storage of the lyophilized powders at 22°C and ambient RH. The concentrations of reactants and products were determined using RP-HPLC and product identity confirmed using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. Loss of native disulfide was observed for the reaction of T20 with both linear (T20-T21) and cyclic (cT20-T21) peptides during the primary drying step; however, the native disulfides were regenerated during secondary drying with no further change till the end of lyophilization. Deviations from Arrhenius parameters predicted from solution studies and the absence of buffer effects during lyophilization suggest that factors such as temperature, initial peptide concentration, buffer type, and concentration do not influence thiol-disulfide exchange during lyophilization. Results from a "cold finger" method used to study peptide adsorption to ice indicate that there is no preferential adsorption to the ice surface and that its presence may not influence disulfide reactivity during primary drying. Overall, reaction rates and product distribution differ for the reaction of T20 with T20-T21 or cT20-T21 in the solid state and aqueous solution, whereas the mechanism of thiol-disulfide remains unchanged. Increased reactivity of the cyclic peptide in the solid state suggests that peptide cyclization does not offer protection against lyophilization and that damage induced by a process stress further affects storage stability at 22°C and ambient RH.

Disulfide Scrambling in Superoxide Dismutase 1 Reduces Its Cytotoxic Effect in Cultured Cells and Promotes Protein Aggregation

Mutations in the gene coding for superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) are associated with familiar forms of the neurodegenerative disease amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). These mutations are believed to result in a “gain of toxic function”, leading to neuronal degeneration. The exact mechanism is still unknown, but misfolding/aggregation events are generally acknowledged as important pathological events in this process. Recently, we observed that demetallated apoSOD1, with cysteine 6 and 111 substituted for alanine, is toxic to cultured neuroblastoma cells. This toxicity depended on an intact, high affinity Zn2+ site. It was therefor contradictory to discover that wild-type apoSOD1 was not toxic, despite of its high affinity for Zn2+. This inconsistency was hypothesized to originate from erroneous disulfide formation involving C6 and C111. Using high resolution non-reducing SDS-PAGE, we have in this study demonstrated that the inability of wild-type apoSOD1 to cause cell death stems from formation of non-native intra-molecular disulfides. Moreover, monomeric apoSOD1 variants capable of such disulfide scrambling aggregated into ThT positive oligomers under physiological conditions without agitation. The oligomers were stabilized by inter-molecular disulfides and morphologically resembled what has in other neurodegenerative diseases been termed protofibrils. Disulfide scrambling thus appears to be an important event for misfolding and aggregation of SOD1, but may also be significant for protein function involving cysteines, e.g. mitochondrial import and copper loading.