Heart transplantation is limited by donor availability, immune mediated rejection, and unintended adverse effects from immunosuppression. Expanding donor availability and immunologic compatibility are priorities. Donor-organ directed therapies have the potential to improve allograft survival while minimizing patient harm. The heart contains 2 ontogenically distinct tissue resident macrophage populations (CCR2- and CCR2+ macrophages) with divergent inflammatory and reparative functions. The exact role of donor macrophages after cardiac transplant remains unexplored. A better understanding of how donor intrinsic immunity influences allograft acceptance and survival may provide new opportunities to improve the outcomes of transplant recipients. We utilized a fully HLA-mismatched mouse heart transplant model in combination with two differing immunosuppression regimens: CTLA4-Ig (acute rejection model) and CTLA4 Ig + anti-CD40L Ab (graft tolerance model). We assessed donor macrophage composition, location, and dynamics at various time points following transplantation using genetic lineage tracing and imaging. The functional requirements for CCR2- and CCR2+ donor macrophages was assessed using transgenic mice that facilitate selective depletion of CCR2- or CCR2+ macrophages. We show that donor CCR2- and CCR2+ macrophages persist in the heart following transplantation. We demonstrate that donor CCR2- and CCR2+ macrophages display dynamic responses following IRI and rejection. Co-labelling with CD68 highlights the later composition of donor-derived CCR2+ macrophages, donor-derived CCR2- macrophages, and resident monocyte derived macrophages in the transplanted heart. Depletion of CCR2+ macrophages prior to transplantation resulted in prolonged allograft survival and reduced cardiomyocyte cell death. In contrast, deletion of CCR2- macrophages led to accelerated rejection, increased cardiomyocyte cell death, and exaggerated leukocyte infiltration. Donor-derived CCR2+ macrophages and donor-derived CCR2- macrophages persist in the cardiac transplant. Depletion of donor-derived CCR2+ macrophages led to graft rejection whereas removal of donor-derived CCR2- macrophages promoted graft survival. These data indicate that donor macrophages play key roles in acute cellular rejection after cardiac transplantation.