ABSTRACT Phaeodactylum tricornutum Bohlin, the one diatom known to lack a silicon requirement for growth, and the prasinophyte Platymonas sp. are two representatives of a taxonomically diverse group of planktonic algae that have been reported to take up Si without a demonstrable requirement for the element. For both species, removal of Si from solution during growth in batch culture has at least two components; true biological uptake throughout the growth of the culture, and spontaneous inorganic precipitation of a solid silicate phase–probably Mg2Si3O8 (sepiolite)–under the elevated pH conditions that prevail late in batch growth. It is not clear to what extent previous observations of Si uptake by algae without siliceous frustules may be influenced by inorganic, non‐cellular precipitation. The kinetics of true cellular uptake of Si are similar in Phaeodalylum and Platymonas, and different from those reported for the Si‐requiring diatoms. Uptake follows hyperbolic saturation kinetics in both species, with half‐saturation concentrations of 97.4 μM in Phaeodactylum and 80.9 μM in Platymonas, as compared to ca. 1–6 μM in diatoms that form siliceous frustules. Uptake by Phaeodactylum and Platymonas is not substrate‐saturated until the dissolved Si concentration of the medium exceeds 200 μM. Concentrations this high do not occur in the surface layer of the ocean, and the kinetics suggest that both species deposit much less silica in nature than they can be induced to deposit in culture.