Directional Mutation Pressure Research Articles

Relationship between G + C in silent sites of codons and amino acid composition of human proteins.

We have investigated the relationship between the G + C content of silent (synonymous) sites in codons and the amino acid composition of encoded proteins for approximately 1,600 human genes. There are positive correlations between silent site G + C and the proportions of codons for Arg, Pro, Ala, Trp, His, Gln, and Leu and negative ones for Tyr, Phe, Asn, Ile, Lys, Asp, Thr, and Glu. The median proteins coded by groups of genes that differ in silent-site G + C content also differ in amino acid composition, as do some proteins coded by homologous genes. The pattern of compositional change can be largely explained by directional mutation pressure, the genetic code, and differences in the frequencies of accepted amino acid substitutions; the shifts in protein composition are likely to be selectively neutral.

Accumulation of adenine and thymine in a groE-homologous operon of an intracellular symbiont.

As a result of the nucleotide sequence analysis of an aphid endosymbiont's operon homologous to the Escherichia coli groE, we noted that directional base substitutions tending toward an increase of A + T content represent an obvious evolutionary trend in this prokaryotic operon, housed for a long period by an eukaryotic cell. This result, when taken together with previous reports, raised the possibility that genomic DNA of prokaryotes residing in an eukaryotic cell is subject to A/T-biased directional mutation pressure and/or both negative and positive selection operating under conditions specific to the intracellular environments.

Directional mutation pressure, selective constraints, and genetic equilibria.

Rates of substitution mutations in two directions, v [from an A-T or T-A nucleotide pair (AT-pair) to a G-C or C-G nucleotide pair (GC-pair)] and u [from a GC-pair to an AT-pair], are usually not the same. The net effect, v/(u + v), has previously been defined as directional mutation pressure (mu D), which explains the wide interspecific variation and narrow intragenomic heterogeneity of DNA G + C content in bacteria. In this article, first, a theory of the evolution of DNA G + C content is presented that is based on the equilibrium among three components: directional mutation pressure, DNA G + C content, and selective constraints. According to this theory, consideration of both u and v as well as selective constraints is essential to explain the molecular evolution of the DNA base composition and sequence. Second, the theory of directional mutation pressure is applied to the analysis of the wide intragenomic heterogeneity of DNA G + C content in multicellular eukaryotes. The theory explains the extensive intragenomic heterogeneity of G + C content of higher eukaryotes primarily as the result of the intragenomic differences of directional mutation pressure and selective constraints rather than the result of positive selections for functional advantages of the DNA G + C content itself.

Novel anticodon composition of transfer RNAs in Micrococcus luteus, a bacterium with a high genomic G+C content : Correlation with codon usage

The number and relative amount of isoacceptor tRNAs for each amino acid in Micrococcus luteus, a Gram-positive bacterium with high genomic G+C content, have been determined by sequencing their anticodon loop and its adjacent regions and by selective labelling of tRNAs. Thirty-one tRNA species with 29 different anticodon sequences have been detected. All the tRNAs have G or C at the anticodon first position except for tRNA ICG Arg and tRNA NGA Ser, in response to the abundant usage of NNC and NNG codons. No tRNA with the anticodon UNN capable of translating codon NNA has been detected, in accordance with a very low or zero usage of NNA codons. The relative amount of isoacceptor tRNAs for an amino acid determined by selective labelling strongly correlates with usage of the corresponding codons. On the basis of these and other observations in this and other eubacterial species, we conclude that the relative amount and anticodon composition of isoacceptor tRNA species are flexible, and their changes are mainly adaptive phenomena that have been primarily affected by codon usage, which in turn is affected by directional mutation pressure.

Prokaryotic genetic code

The prokaryotic genetic code has been influenced by directional mutation pressure (GC/AT pressure) that has been exerted on the entire genome. This pressure affects the synonymous codon choice, the amino acid composition of proteins and tRNA anticodons. Unassigned codons would have been produced in bacteria with extremely high GC or AT genomes by deleting certain codons and the corresponding tRNAs. A high AT pressure together with genomic economization led to a change in assignment of the UGA codon, from stop to tryptophan, in Mycoplasma.

The genetic code in mitochondria and chloroplasts

The universal genetic code is used without changes in chloroplasts and in mitochondria of green plants. Non-plant mitochondria use codes that include changes from the universal code. Chloroplasts use 31 anticodons in translating the code; a number smaller than that used by bacteria, because chloroplasts have eliminated 10 CNN anticodons that are found in bacteria. Green plant mitochondria (mt) obtain some tRNAs from the cytosol, and genes for some other tRNAs have been acquired from chloroplast DNA. The code in non-plant mt differs from the universal code in the following usages found in various organisms: UGA for Trp, AUA for Met, AGR for Ser and stop, AAA for Asn, CUN for Thr, and possibly UAA for Tyr. CGN codons are not used by Torulopsis yeast mt. Non-plant mt, e.g. in vertebrates, may use a minimum of 22 anticodons for complete translation of mRNA sequences. The following possible causes are regarded as contributing to changes in the non-plant mt: directional mutation pressure, genomic economization, changes in charging specificity of tRNAs, loss of release factor RF2, changes in RF1, changes in anticodons, loss of lysidine-forming enzyme system, and disappearance of codons from coding sequences.

Genetic code 1990. Outlook

The genetic code is evolving as shown by 9 departures from the universal code: 6 of them are in mitochondria and 3 are in nuclear codes. We propose that these changes are preceded by disappearance of a codon from coding sequences in mRNA of an organism or organelle. The function of the codon that disappears is taken by other, synonymous codons, so that there is no change in amino acid sequences of proteins. The deleted codon then reappears with a new function. Wobble pairing between anticodons and codons has evolved, starting with a single UNN anticodon pairing with 4 codons. Directional mutation pressure affects codon usage and may produce codon reassignments, especially of stop codons. Selenocysteine is coded by UGA, which is also a stop codon, and this anomaly is discussed. The outlook for discovery of more changes in the code is favorable, and open reading frames should be compared with actual sequential analyses of protein molecules in this search.

Evolutionary changes in the genetic code

The genetic code has been influenced by directional mutation pressure affecting the base composition of DNA, sometimes in the direction of increased GC content and at other times, in the direction of AT. Such pressure led to changes in species-specific usages of codons and tRNA anticodons, and also in amino acid assignments of codons in mitochondria and in several intact organisms. These code changes are probably recent evolutionary events. The genetic code is not 'frozen', but instead it is still evolving.

The biological equilibrium of base pairs

An inherent feature of double-stranded DNA is the possible replacement of any base pair by another one upon replication. A replication-dependent substitution mutation of a matched base pair requires the temporary formation of a mismatched base pair (mispair). A functionally complementary pair of mispairs is ascribed to each of the four types of substitution mutations. Provided that all types of mispairs can be formed, a dynamic biological equilibrium between the four matched base pairs must exist in all DNA, which is directly related to the formation and stability of the corresponding eight mispairs in vivo. Each nucleotide position in a genome can therefore be described as a system of six dynamic equilibria between the four matched base pairs. After a sufficient number of replications, these equilibrium states will express an overall mutation-selection balance for each individual base pair. In a thermodynamic context, the mispairs represent intermediate states on the transformation pathways between the matched base pairs. Catalysts change the stability and probability of formation of intermediate states. Mutagenic proteins are proposed as hypothetical substitution mutation catalysts in vivo. Functionally, they would be capable of recognizing a particular DNA sequence, tautomerizing a nucleotide base thereof, and hence efficiently inducing a specific misincorporation. Phenomenologically such catalysts would accelerate the rates of substitution mutations and provide pathways for directional mutation pressure.

Role of GC-biased mutation pressure on synonymous codon choice inMicrococcus luteusa bacterium with a high genomic GC-content

The GC (G + C, or G or C)-contents of codon silent positions in all two-codon sets and three codons AUY/A (IIe), and in most of the family boxes of Micrococcus luteus (genomic GC-content: 74%) are 95% to 100% in both the highly and weakly expressed genes. In some family boxes, there is a decrease in NNC codons and an increase in NNG codons from the highly expressed to weakly expressed genes without apparent involvement of NNU and NNA codons. From these observations, we conclude that the selective use of synonymous codons in M. luteus may be largely determined by GC-biased mutation pressure and that in the highly expressed genes tRNAs would act as a weak selection pressure in some family boxes. Available data suggest that the effect of selection pressure by tRNAs on the synonymous codon choice becomes more apparent in the highly expressed genes in eubacteria with intermediate GC-contents such as Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis, and that the U/C ratio of the codon third positions in NNU/C-type two-codon sets in the weakly expressed genes would represent the approximate magnitude of directional mutation pressure throughout eubacteria.

Codon reassignment (codon capture) in evolution

The genetic code, once thought to be "frozen," shows variations from the universal code. Variations are found in mitochondria, Mycoplasma, and ciliated protozoa. The variations result from reassignment of codons, especially stop codons. The reassignments take place by disappearance of a codon from coding sequences, followed by its reappearance in a new role. Simultaneously, a changed anticodon must appear. We discuss the role of directional mutation pressure in the events, and we also describe the possibility that such events have taken place during early evolution of the genetic code and can occur during its present evolution.

Heterogeneity of tempo and mode of mitochondrial DNA evolution among mammalian orders.

A statistical analysis of complete DNA sequence data of mitochondrial genomes from human, bovine, and mouse (and partial sequence of rat) indicates that the transversion rate is lower in bovine than in human and murids, and that it is probably lower in human than in murids. However, it is unknown whether the transition rate is also lower in bovine. It is shown that the L-strand of human mitochondrial DNA has significantly higher C content and lower T and A contents than those of bovine and murids. This suggests that a directional mutation pressure which tends to change base composition has been operating in the human lineage.

Directional mutation pressure and neutral molecular evolution.

A quantitative theory of directional mutation pressure proposed in 1962 explained the wide variation of DNA base composition observed among different bacteria and its small heterogeneity within individual bacterial species. The theory was based on the assumption that the effect of mutation on a genome is not random but has a directionality toward higher or lower guanine-plus-cytosine content of DNA, and this pressure generates directional changes more in neutral parts of the genome than in functionally significant parts. Now that DNA sequence data are available, the theory allows the estimation of the extent of neutrality of directional mutation pressure against selection. Newly defined parameters were used in the analysis, and two apparently universal constants were discovered. Analysis of DNA sequence has revealed that practically all organisms are subject to directional mutation pressure. The theory also offers plausible explanations for the large heterogeneity in guanine-plus-cytosine content among different parts of the vertebrate genome.

Directional mutation pressure and transfer RNA in choice of the third nucleotide of synonymous two-codon sets.

Bacterial species have diverged into a series of families, some with high G + C content in their DNA, and other with high A + T content, resulting, respectively, from G.C- and A.T-directional mutation pressures. Such mutation pressure (G.C/A.T pressure) may be an important determinant for codon usage. It has also been suggested that tRNA acts as a selective constraint for determining codon usage. We have studied the relation between G.C/A.T pressure and tRNA constraints in determining choice of the third nucleotide of eight two-codon sets, using codon usage data obtained from protein genes in four bacterial species, Mycoplasma capricolum, Bacillus subtilis, Escherichia coli, and Micrococcus luteus, and in liverwort (Marchantia polymorpha) chloroplasts. The genomic G + C contents of these range from 25% to 74%. The results demonstrate that tRNA levels act additively to A.T and G.C pressure in affecting contents of A (pairing with *UNN anticodons, in which *U indicates a 2-thiouridine derivative) and C (pairing with GNN anticodons) or G (pairing with CNN anticodons), respectively, in third nucleotide positions of codons.

Evolution of anticodons: variations in the genetic code.

Clues to evolution of the genetic code can be found by comparing usage of anticodons in various organisms and organelles. GC content of DNA varies, as a result of directional mutation pressure (AT/GC pressure), especially in bacteria. Low GC in Mycoplasma is accompanied by use of UGA for tryptophan and, in ciliated protozoa, by use of UAA and UAG for glutamine. These are examples of "stop codon capture," which has been preceded by duplication of tRNA genes followed by nucleotide substitutions in their sequences, including mutational changes in their anticodons. Evolutionary changes in the code may have resulted from disappearance of codons and anticodons resulting from GC pressure and from their reappearance when the direction of the pressure was reversed. In this manner, codon UGA and anticodon UCA for tryptophan could have disappeared under GC pressure and reappeared in Mycoplasma under AT pressure. Stop codon UGA may have been the third of the three stop codons to appear, originating from mutations in UAA. Changes in the code are adaptive and nondeleterious. We propose that the number of anticodons has increased and that evolution continued until three existing forms of the universal code were produced: eukaryotic, eubacterial, and the code for halobacteria and methanococci. These three codes are distinguished from each other by their anticodon pattern. The eukaryotic code contains eight INN (ANN) anticodons that have replaced GNN anticodons as a result of AT pressure. Mitochondrial and chloroplast codes have evolved from the eubacterial code through genomic economization and AT pressure, leading to losses of GNN and CNN anticodons.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Role of directional mutation pressure in the evolution of the eubacterial genetic code.

Among eubacteria, the mean guanine and cytosine (GC) contents of genomic DNA vary approximately from 25% to 75% (Sueoka 1962). The phylogenetic tree to eubacterial 5S rRNA has indicated that bacterial genome GC contents are to some extent related to phylogeny (Hori and Osawa 1986). According to this tree, the gram-negative and the gram-positive bacteria diverged first. Among the gram-positive bacteria, those with low genomic GC content such as Bacillus subtilis (genomic GC: 43%), Lactobacillus viridescens (40%), Staphylococcus aureus (33%), Clostridium perfringens (38%), and Mycoplasma capricolum (25%) are phylogenetically close, whereas those with high genomic GC, such as Micrococcus luteus (74%), Streptomyces griseus (73%), and Mycobacterium tuberculosis (67%) comprise another phylogenetic group. These two groups separated long ago. The gram-negative bacteria with intermediate GC, such as Escherichia coli (50%), Serratia marcescens (58%), Salmonella typhimurium (51%), and Pseudomonas fluorescens (60%) belong to the common gram-negative branch...