We examine in detail the techniques of supersymmetric dimensional regularization. A peculiar complementarity is found to be inherent in the regularization: its manifestly supersymmetric version is contradictory, while the removal of inconsistencies costs a lossof supersymmetry in higher orders. We analyse this phenomenon at the level of Feynman diagrams and discover an explicit example of supersymmetry breakdown in the three-loop approximation. In the light of this result, we reconsider the status of dimensional regularization in globally supersymmetric gauge theories.