Flavodiiron NO reductases (FNORs) are important enzymes in microbial pathogenesis, as they equip microbes with resistance to the human immune defense agent nitric oxide (NO). Despite much efforts, intermediates that would provide insight into how the non-heme diiron active sites of FNORs reduce NO to N2O could not be identified. Computations predict that iron-hyponitrite complexes are the key species, leading from NO to N2O. However, the coordination chemistry of non-heme iron centers with hyponitrite is largely unknown. In this study, we report the reactivity of two non-heme iron complexes with preformed hyponitrite. In the case of [Fe(TPA)(CH3CN)2](OTf)2, cleavage of hyponitrite and formation of an Fe2(NO)2 diamond core is observed. With less Lewis-acidic [Fe2(BMPA-PhO)2(OTf)2] (2), reaction with Na2N2O2 in polar aprotic solvent leads to the formation of a red complex, 3. X-ray crystallography shows that 3 is a tetranuclear iron-hyponitrite complex, [{Fe2(BMPA-PhO)2}2(μ-N2O2)](OTf)2, with a unique hyponitrite binding mode. This species provided the unique opportunity to us to study the interaction of hyponitrite with non-heme iron centers and the reactivity of the bound hyponitrite ligand. Here, either protonation or oxidation of 3 is found to induce N2O formation, supporting the hypothesis that hyponitrite is a viable intermediate in NO reduction.