Background: It is sometimes difficult to clinically delineate genitofemoral and ilioinguinal neuralgias because of the overlap in the clinical symptomatology. Case description: A young male with a past history of transurethral removal of ureteral calculi presented with severe, debilitating neuropathic pain in the groin. He had hyperpathia and allodynia in the distribution of genitofemoral nerve, and hence a clinical diagnosis of genitofemoral neuralgia was made. An ultrasound guided diagnostic block of the genitofemoral nerve with local anesthetic produced only a mild reduction in pain (VAS 2 reduction). A repeat diagnostic block of the ilioinguinal nerve produced complete resolution of pain. Literature search showed a limited number of case reports of ultrasound guided blocks for genitofemoral neuralgia; and overlap syndromes have been addressed with differential nerve blocks. Clinical relevance: Our hypothesis is that an aberrant reinnervation from the ilioinguinal to genitofemoral nerve may present with features favoring a genitofemoral neuralgia. In situations where radiofrequency treatment is being considered, such cases may pose a failed intervention if both nerves are not separately targeted.