The NH acid properties of nonplanar dodecasubstituted porphyrins (H2P) were studied by the spectropotentiometric and spectrophotometric methods and by semiempirical quantum-chemical calculations. The reaction of H2P with a weak organic base DMSO proceeded with the formation of the H-associated form DMSO⋯H⋯PH or DMSO⋯H⋯P⋯H⋯DMSO. Strong bases KOH[222] and [NR4]OH reacted with the formation of mono-(HP−) or dianionic (P2−) forms. An increase in NH acidity along the series tetraphenylporphin < tetraphenyltetrabenzoporphin < β-octaethyltetraphenylporphin < dodecaphenylporphin < β-octabromotetraphenylporphin was to a great extent caused by the polarization of molecules, which accompanied saddle-nonplanar distortions of their structure, rather than β-substituent electronic effects. The quantitative characteristics obtained using the suggested system of criteria of the chemical activity of NH bonds (1H NMR spectral, kinetic, and quantum-chemical criteria) linearly correlated with H2P acid dissociation constants and could be used for alternative estimation of the acidity of tetrapyrrole compounds.