Purpose: Children and adolescents and young adults (AYA) with pectus excavatum (PE) and adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) experience similar journeys regarding pain, body image, and self- and peer acceptance. Peer mentoring may address some of the challenges faced regarding diagnosis and treatment of PE and AIS. Before implementing a mentor program, our hospital noted an increased length of stay (LOS) and difficulty coping in those undergoing surgery for PE and AIS, emphasizing the need for additional support. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the impact of a peer mentor program for children/AYAs with PE or AIS and their parents on coping, pain, and LOS. Design and Methods: This non-randomized controlled trial included a prospective intervention group that received peer mentorship and a retrospective control group that received standard care. Self-reported surveys assessed the effect of the mentor program on coping. Qualitative data on coping were analyzed descriptively. Postoperative pain and LOS were obtained from the health record. Bivariate inferential statistics were used to compare the distribution of pain scores and LOS between intervention and control groups. Results: Children/AYAs, parents, and mentors reported enhanced coping and found peer mentorship beneficial, though it did not have a statistically significant impact on pain or LOS. Conclusions: Peer mentorship facilitates coping in children/AYAs with PE or AIS undergoing corrective surgery. Parents and mentors also perceived benefits. Practice Implications: Pediatric nurses and child life specialists can help children/AYAs, and their families prepare for surgery by connecting them with peer mentors and social support.