Chlamydia trachomatis is an obligate intracellular bacterium, which undergoes a biphasic developmental cycle inside a vacuole termed the inclusion. Chlamydia-specific effector proteins embedded into the inclusion membrane, the Inc proteins, facilitate inclusion interaction with cellular organelles. A subset of Inc proteins engages with specific host factors at the endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-inclusion membrane contact site (MCS), which is a discrete point of contact between the inclusion membrane and the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Here, we report that the C. trachomatis Inc protein CTL0402/IncSCt is a novel component of the ER-inclusion MCS that specifically interacts with and recruits STIM1, a previously identified host component of the ER-inclusion MCS with an unassigned interacting partner at the inclusion membrane. In comparison, the Chlamydia muridarum IncS homologue (TC0424/IncSCm) does not interact with or recruit STIM1 to the inclusion, indicating species specificity. To further investigate IncS function and overcome the recently reported early developmental defect of the incS mutant, we achieved temporal complementation by expressing IncS exclusively during the early stages of the developmental cycle. Additionally, we used allelic exchange to replace the incSCt open reading frame with incSCm in the C. trachomatis chromosome. Inclusions harboring either of these strains progressed through the developmental cycle but were STIM1 negative and displayed increased inclusion lysis 48 h postinfection. Expression of incSCt in trans complemented these phenotypes. Altogether, our results indicate that IncS is necessary and sufficient to recruit STIM1 to C. trachomatis inclusion and that IncS plays an early developmental role conserved in C. trachomatis and C. muridarum and a late role in inclusion stability specific to C. trachomatis. IMPORTANCE Obligate intracellular pathogens strictly rely on the host for replication. Specialized pathogen-encoded effector proteins play a central role in sophisticated mechanisms of host cell manipulation. In Chlamydia, a subset of these effector proteins, the inclusion membrane proteins, are embedded in the membrane of the vacuole in which the bacteria replicate. Chlamydia encodes 50 to 100 putative Inc proteins. Many are conserved among species, including the human and mouse pathogens Chlamydia trachomatis and Chlamydia muridarum, respectively. However, whether the function(s) of Inc proteins is indeed conserved among species is poorly understood. Here, we characterized the function of the Inc protein IncS conserved in C. trachomatis and C. muridarum. Our work reveals that a single effector protein can play multiple functions at various stages of the developmental cycle. However, these functions are not necessarily conserved across species, suggesting a complex evolutionary path among Chlamydia species.