Development Of Design Guidelines Research Articles

Co-creating multimodal transportation hubs in Switzerland: How to close the gap between actors across different scales, levels, and sectors

Transforming railway stations and their surroundings into multimodal transportation hubs (MMTHs) involves numerous actors at different scales and from different economic sectors and levels of government. Successful transformations offer a wide range of benefits to sustainable development, including increased public transportation use and mixed-use, high-density station districts. Intensive collaboration and, ideally, co-creation are critical to achieving these outcomes through MMTHs; however, orchestrating all involved actors is challenging and requires supporting methods, and the knowledge required to develop and refine methods is scarce and rarely subjected to systematic analysis. Based on 15 semistructured interviews and two design thinking workshops attended by 13 and 20 MMTH experts, our study shows that the challenges of co-creating MMTHs relate not only to professional matters but also to managing collaboration and implementation among a large number of actors with various roles and interests. In this paper, we develop design guidelines for reviewing and evaluating two current methods and a prototypical method (the functional model) with the goal of identifying potential improvements and supporting MMTH co-creation in Switzerland. These guidelines cover the broad spectrum of co-creation activities, from organization and design collaboration with relevant actors to the development of a shared vision to support financing and the planning process. The functional model encompasses many aspects of the design guidelines and closes gaps between actors across different scales, economic sectors, and governmental levels. Due to the relatively low effort involved, the method can be repeated as needed throughout MMTH development, which often takes several years. Our study demonstrates that existing MMTH co-creation methods require improvement, and the design guidelines developed here suit this purpose. Our work thus contributes to the further development of MMTH co-creation methods, ultimately supporting sustainable development such as CO2 emission reduction and responsible land use.

Unveiling the Influence of Linkers on Conformations of Oligomeric Acceptors for High-Performance Polymer Solar Cells.

Conformational isomerism of organic photovoltaic materials has a profound impact on their molecular packing and therefore performance of polymer solar cells (PSCs). However, the conformations of oligomeric acceptors (OAs) are mostly predicted by simulations rather than experimental determinations. Herein, the stereochemical S-shaped structure of two dimeric-type acceptor molecules, V-DYIC and V-DYIC-4F, is first confirmed with different end groups (IC for V-DYIC and IC-2F for V-DYIC-4F), incorporating vinylene linkage for connecting the distinct state-of-the-art small molecule acceptor Y-segments. Through the synthetic control of fluorination sites adjacent to the vinyl-linker, S-shaped the conformation by NMR experiments is validated. Compared to the O-shaped dimer, S-shaped conformation results in enhanced lamellar order and reduced nonradiative recombination losses. The optimal acceptor, V-DYIC-4F, achieved a champion efficiency of 18.10% with the lowest energy loss of 0.556eV in its devices paired with PM6 due to their efficient carrier transport, and suppressed recombination compared to other devices, being attributed to the synergistic effect of conformation and end group fluorination. The insights gained in this work contribute valuable knowledge of both synthetic control and structural determination of OAs, providing strategic design guidelines for the future development of dimeric acceptors toward high-efficiency PSCs.

Eco Airport Design: Rancangan Gedung Terminal Ramah Lingkungan pada Bandar Udara

Increasing awareness of the importance of environmental conservation has encouraged the development of eco-design concepts in various fields, including air transportation infrastructure. The main focus of this research is to propose an eco-friendly terminal building design for airports using the Eco Airport Design approach. The research will involve case studies of specific airports to investigate the potential and challenges of applying eco-design principles in airport terminals. The research methods used will include observation, environmental data analysis, and the study of related literature. This research aims to develop design guidelines and recommendations that promote energy efficiency, waste reduction, use of eco-friendly materials, layouts that utilize natural air and light, and improve the environmental quality around the airport. The results of this research are expected to significantly contribute to environmental protection efforts in the context of air transportation infrastructure, particularly airport design for tertiary categories or those serving up to one million passengers per year.

Exploring the impact of green wall and its size on restoration effect and stress recovery using immersive virtual environments

The study investigated the influence of a green wall and its size on stress and restoration within the biophilic design integrating natural objects into environments. Despite its benefits in enhancing access to nature and stress reduction, visual stimuli properties may affect design outcomes. This research employed Immersive Virtual Environments (IVEs) combined with a climate chamber for thermally controlled conditions, where sixty participants experienced different virtual settings with and without green walls after performing a stressor task. The evaluation of stress involved recording physiological responses, including heart rate (HR), heart rate variability (HRV), and electrodermal activity (EDA) along with eye movements. Participants also completed a restoration state survey. Comparing physiological responses found no significant stress recovery in settings with green walls compared to baseline. Stress recovery was similar regardless of green wall size, indicating size may not affect stress. Restoration votes did not vary significantly across settings. These results were discussed focusing on the perceived lack of “naturalness” and “engagement” in virtual environments, as fixation time analysis indicated limited engagement: participants spent 18.63 % and 19.65 % of their time fixated on the green wall in small and large settings, respectively. The authors suggest design solutions to enhance the realism and engagement of virtual natural objects. Although this study did not find the impact of size, the minimum size of natural objects required for restoration is still unknown, suggesting a need for future research on different natural coverages to develop design guidelines for the successful integration of biophilic design into the built environments.

Experiencing the body as play: Cultivating older adults’ exergame experiences using embodied metaphors and multimodal feedback

Physical activity (PA) is promising in increasing active life for older adults, but its repetitive and fatigue-inducing nature greatly harms older adults’ motivation to participate. Recently, there has been a growing interest in applying exergames to improve older adults’ PA adherence and engagement. To better support body-based interactions, embodied metaphors and multimodal feedback are suggested to ensure effective and meaningful mapping between elderly players’ input actions and exergame responses, but their effectiveness have not been fully investigated. After developing a list of embodied and ontological metaphors based a series of user-centered approaches, two experiments were conducted to investigate how embodied metaphors and multimodal feedback impact older adults'’ playing experience of PA exergames, among fifty-nine and twenty-five older adults, respectively. Regarding the embodied metaphor design, the results indicated that a higher embodiment level significantly and positively influenced the participants’ acceptance behavior in terms of their attitudes toward the exergame, and a higher information richness level demonstrated significantly positive effects on familiarity perception and all aspects of acceptance behavior. For the multimodal feedback design, the results indicated that 3D visual feedback better facilitated the participants’ sense of embodiment and immersion, as well as their acceptance behavior, compared to 2D visual feedback. Furthermore, constant tactile feedback in a continuous-only or continuous-and-augmented way significantly improved the participants’ PA movement performance and sense of embodiment, rather than instant feedback. Accordingly, a list of design guidelines for PA exergame development is proposed, with the possible contributions and limitations of this research addressed.

Data-Driven Global Sensitivity Analysis of Variable Groups for Understanding Complex Physical Interactions in Engineering Design

Abstract In engineering design, global sensitivity analysis (GSA) is used for analyzing the effects of inputs on the system response and is commonly studied with analytical or surrogate models. However, such models fail to capture nonlinear behaviors in complex systems and involve several modeling assumptions. Besides model-focused methods, a data-driven GSA approach, rooted in interpretable machine learning, would also identify the relationships between system components. Moreover, a special need in engineering design extends beyond performing GSA for input variables individually, but instead evaluating the contributions of variable groups on the system response. In this article, we introduce a flexible, interpretable artificial neural network model to uncover individual as well as grouped global sensitivity indices for understanding complex physical interactions in engineering design problems. The proposed model allows the investigation of the main effects and second-order effects in GSA according to functional analysis of variance (FANOVA) decomposition. To draw a higher-level understanding, we further use the subset decomposition method to analyze the significance of the groups of input variables. Using the design of a programmable material system (PMS) as an example, we demonstrate the use of our approach for examining the impact of material, architecture, and stimulus variables as well as their interactions. This information lays the foundation for managing design space complexity, summarizing the relationships between system components, and deriving design guidelines for PMS development.

Kano Model for Apartment-Unit Specialized Planning Guidelines to Prevent Infectious Diseases

Owing to the continued occurrence of infectious diseases, proactive prevention and management plans are required. This study aimed to develop design guidelines to effectively respond to infectious diseases based on the needs of apartment residents, which focused on a South Korean setting. The research method included a literature review to identify apartment planning concepts for preventing and managing infectious diseases, a survey of 300 participants using the Kano model, and an analysis of the quality attributes (QAs) of the survey results to prioritize design guidelines. After reviewing 20 studies, 65 items related to apartment-unit planning for infectious disease prevention, including 108 keywords, were identified. Using thematic analysis, the keywords converged into three planning concepts: hygiene, convenience, and comfort. Based on the literature review, 27 survey questions were derived, and a Kano model QA analysis was performed. As a result, 17 attractive QAs, two one-dimensional QAs, seven indifferent QAs, and one reverse QA were identified. Among these, 13 items that had a significant impact on residents’ satisfaction were classified as essential requirements, and the remaining 14 items were classified as recommended design guidelines. The results of this study provide insights into an evidence-based framework for complex building design guidelines to prevent the spread of infectious diseases.

DESIGN GUIDELINE: EDUCATION BUILDING FOR HANDICAPPED PEOPLE TOWARDS HEALTHY ENVIRONMENT

Malaysia needs to revamp its education system to better support handicapped individuals, allowing them to lead fulfilling lives. Currently, there is a lack of educational institutions catering to their specific needs, inclusive and unconducive learning environments. Many educational buildings in Malaysia fall short in providing essential accessibility features and overlook critical factors like lighting, air quality, acoustics, and ergonomics. This research aims to address this issue by developing design guidelines that focus on creating educational facilities that are accessible and promote a healthy environment, thereby enhancing their educational opportunities and overall quality of life. This study uses a mixed-method approach, including questionnaire surveys, expert interviews, and data synthesis to assess the current state of educational building design. Findings emphasize few factors like accessibility, spatial planning, acoustics, ergonomics, and inclusive design in creating education buildings that are accessible, healthy, well-designed, and conducive to social integration for handicapped individuals.

Key parameters that affect the fatigue life of metal bellows-type expansion joint: Another look

Identifying and understanding the key parameters that influence the fatigue life of metal bellows-type expansion joints (metal bellows) enable designers and manufacturers to optimize performance, durability, and reliability and to develop design guidelines and manufacturing processes that could enhance fatigue resistance and ensure their reliable operation in real-world applications. The parameters that influence the fatigue life of metal bellows include the type of material and its properties, operating environment, type of expansion joint, temperature, stress/pressure, manufacturing/forming processes, geometry/construction, proper design, loading history, movement/deflection, vibration, and seismic activity. This comprehensive review covers the fatigue life literature, including concepts, guidelines, standards, assumptions, and the evolution of each parameter. Uniquely classifying parameters through thematic analysis, it guides manufacturers and users in optimizing metal bellows design, assessment, and risk mitigation. The review highlights overlooked insights in a user-friendly manner, prioritizing practical, easily fixable aspects for immediate application in the industrial setting.

The Effects of Depth of Knowledge of a Virtual Agent.

We explored the impact of depth of knowledge on conversational agents and human perceptions in a virtual reality (VR) environment. We designed experimental conditions with low, medium, and high depths of knowledge in the domain of game development and tested them among 27 game development students. We aimed to understand how the agent's predefined knowledge levels affected the participants' perceptions of the agent and its knowledge. Our findings showed that participants could distinguish between different knowledge levels of the virtual agent. Moreover, the agent's depth of knowledge significantly impacted participants' perceptions of intelligence, rapport, factuality, the uncanny valley effect, anthropomorphism, and willingness for future interaction. We also found strong correlations between perceived knowledge, perceived intelligence, factuality, and willingness for future interactions. We developed design guidelines for creating conversational agents from our data and observations. This study contributes to the human-agent interaction field in VR settings by providing empirical evidence on the importance of tailoring virtual agents' depth of knowledge to improve user experience, offering insights into designing more engaging and effective conversational agents.

Subsoil stiffness effects on the bridge-abutment dynamic behaviour

Integral abutment bridges (IABs) are robust structures that avoid the use of bearings and expansion joints and are relatively maintenance-free compared to conventional bridges. The seismic design code of IABs is not fully developed, and the complex soil-abutment interaction is not well understood. Therefore, research was carried out at the Schofield centre, the University of Cambridge, to understand the backfill-abutment interaction under earthquake loading, aimed at developing design guidelines for the industry. Understanding the mechanics by which the foundation soil stiffness and strength govern the abutment deformation and, thus, the earth pressures generated behind the abutment is essential. Two centrifuge tests have been conducted simulating an abutment with the conventional abutment-deck connection (or semi-integral abutment bridge), where moment restraint is released. In this paper, the dynamic response of the abutment founded on dry and liquefiable sandy soil is compared. Different deformation modes have been observed depending on the relative abutmentsoil stiffness. The abutment experienced minimal base displacement in dry sands. Conversely, the abutment witnessed cyclic rotational ratcheting about the deck level in liquefiable soil. The dry soil test helped identify the zones where soil stiffness and strength loss can be critical. In the case of the saturated test, the water table level was up to one-third of the abutment height, fully saturating the foundation soil while the backfill height was dry. The comparative results highlight the vulnerability of semi-integral abutment walls to liquefaction-induced failure, as witnessed in the 2011 Christchurch earthquakes.

The wondrous world of ABX3 molecular perovskites.

The substitution of atoms with molecular building blocks to form hybrid organic-inorganic networks has been an important research theme for several decades. ABX3 molecular perovskites (MolPs) are a subclass of hybrid networks, adopting the perovskite structure with cationic and anionic molecules on the A-site and X-site. MolPs such as ((CH3)2NH2)Zn(HCOO)3 or ((n-C3H7)4N)Mn(C2N3)3 show a range of fascinating structure-chemical properties, including temperature-driven phase transitions that include a change of polarity as interesting for ferroelectrics, pressure-driven order-disorder phase transitions as interesting for barocaloric solid-state refrigeration, and most recently, melting-behaviour before decomposition with subsequent glass formation after cooling. In this feature article, we take a more personal perspective, overviewing the field's current state and outlining future directions. We start by comparing the MolPs' structural chemistry with their inorganic parents, a comparison that helps us identify opportunities for material design. After discussing the MolPs' potential as barocalorics, ferroelectrics, and in the area of glasses, we outline some challenges that lie ahead. Beyond their relevance as a hybrid analogue of inorganic perovskites, we find that MolPs' chemical parameter space provides exciting opportunities for systematically developing design guidelines for functional materials.

A Monocular Projector-Camera System Using Modular Architecture.

This paper presents a monocular projector-camera (procam) system using modular architecture based on relay optics. Conventional coaxial procam systems cannot support (1) online changes to lens settings (zoom and focus) and (2) wide-angle projection mapping. We develop design guidelines for a proposed procam system that would solve these restrictions and address the proposed system's unique technical issue of crosstalk between the camera and projector pixels. We conducted experiments using prototypes to validate the feasibility of the proposed framework. First, we confirmed that the proposed crosstalk reduction technique worked well. Second, we found our technique could achieve correct alignment of a projected image onto a moving surface while changing the zoom and focus of the objective lens. The monocular procam system also achieved radiometric compensation where a surface texture was visually concealed by pixel-wise control of a projection color based on the captured results of offline color pattern projections. Finally, we demonstrated the high expandability of our modular architecture, through the creation of a high dynamic range projection.

Visual Indicators Representing Avatars' Authenticity in Social Virtual Reality and Their Impacts on Perceived Trustworthiness.

Photorealistic avatars show great potential in social VR and VR collaboration. However, identity and privacy issues are threatening avatars' authenticity in social VR. In addition to the necessary authentication and protection, effective solutions are needed to convey avatars' authenticity status to users and thereby enhance the overall trustworthiness. We designed several visual indicators (VIs) using static or dynamic visual effects on photorealistic avatars and evaluated their effectiveness in visualizing avatars' authenticity status. In this study we explored suitable attributes and designs for conveying the authenticity of photorealistic avatars and influencing their perceived trustworthiness. Furthermore, we investigated how different interactivity levels influence their effectiveness (the avatar was either presented in a static image, an animated video clip, or an immersive virtual environment). Our findings showed that using a full name can increase trust, while most other VIs could decrease users' trust. We also found that interactivity levels significantly impacted users' trust and the effectiveness of VIs. Based on our results, we developed design guidelines for visual indicators as effective tools to convey authenticity, as a first step towards the improvement of trustworthiness in social VR with identity management.

Using Online Videos as the Basis for Developing Design Guidelines: A Case Study of AR-Based Assembly Instructions

Design guidelines serve as an important conceptual tool to guide designers of interactive applications with well-established principles and heuristics. Consulting domain experts is a common way to develop guidelines. However, experts are often not easily accessible, and their time can be expensive. This problem poses challenges in developing comprehensive and practical guidelines. We propose a new guideline development method that uses online public videos as the basis for capturing diverse patterns of design goals and interaction primitives. In a case study focusing on AR-based assembly instructions, we apply our novel Identify-Rationalize pipeline, which distills design patterns from videos featuring AR-based assembly instructions (N=146) into a set of guidelines that cover a wide range of design considerations. The evaluation conducted with 16 AR designers indicated that the pipeline is useful for generating comprehensive guidelines. We conclude by discussing the transferability and practicality of our method.

Development types and design guidelines for the conservation and utilization of spatial environment in traditional villages in Southern China

ABSTRACT In China, despite the continuous efforts to preserve traditional villages in recent years, a significant amount of cultural heritages continue to vanish. Commonly observed issues such as the lack of coordination between preservation and development, the imbalance in spatial environment conservation and utilization, are pervasive. Regrettably, there is a conspicuous absence of theoretical underpinning in addressing these challenges. In this study, The evaluation factor of spatial environmental protection was selected, and these factors were weighted through expert surveys and the Analytic Hierarchy Process, and applied the multi-objective linear weighting function method to obtain a comprehensive evaluation calculation formula. Subsequently, we conducted an assessment of 28 representative traditional villages in the southern Chinese regions of Guangdong, Fujian, and Jiangxi. Their current issues were systematically analyzed and cluster analysis was applied to discern 11 distinct typologies of traditional village development. Besides, the temporal evolution patterns of these villages were delved into, and their development were categorized into five stages: initiation, enhancement, prosperity, over-development, and decline. Ultimately, based on the spatial environment characteristics of each development type and evolution stage, corresponding guidelines for spatial environment conservation and utilization are proposed, which provides necessary theoretical frameworks for future work this region.

Cohousing design guidelines for better social integration in the United Arab Emirates

Considering cohousing as a new typology in the United Arab Emirates’ (UAE) housing market is a challenge due to the cultural and societal dimensions. However, the variety of societies in the Emirates reflecting various habits, experiences, and traditions can allow testing such new types of housing which can be adapted to the local context, considering the needs of the society. This study aims at developing design guidelines for future cohousing in the UAE, considering the pillars of the Estidama program, i.e., social, cultural, economic, and environmental aspects, in addition to the role of architecture design. The present study is based on an empirical investigation from the viewpoint of future cohousing residents in the UAE. Semi-structured interviews considering 87 individuals were conducted. Moreover, a focus group discussion targeting eight professionals was performed. Furthermore, the Quality Function Deployment (QFD) method was applied to include the people’s voices directly when developing the design guidelines for cohousing in the UAE. The study showed that the aspects of culture and privacy are crucial in the future of cohousing in the UAE. In addition, providing local facilities such as majlis and praying rooms is vital to consider. Moreover, other aspects such as sustainable design, universal design, and safety are also valuable. For the outdoor environment, the study highlighted the importance of urban design quality, landscape solutions, shading, and natural ventilation strategies in outdoor spaces. Future cohousing in the UAE is expected to enhance social interaction and contribute to sustainability in the long-term perspective.

Exergy-based methodology to develop design guidelines for performance optimization of a coupled co-axial thermoacoustic refrigerator

Performance of thermoacoustic (TA) systems are very complex, and their performance optimization is a difficult task, and most TA systems have relatively very low efficiencies. The main objective of this study was to develop an exergy analysis to introduce a guide for a designer, how to optimize the performance of a TA system. We have applied this methodology to a coupled thermoacoustic engine and refrigerator with a standing wave in the engine and a traveling wave in the refrigerator. In an optimization procedure, a lumped systems numerical analysis was performed to predict the main parameters of the thermoacoustic system. The numerical method was validated by comparison with numerical and experimental results in the literature. The cost function was the total system coefficient of performance, and design parameters include the refrigerator regenerator length, location, and hydraulic radius. The performance index was decomposed into three main subsystem indices, i.e., the efficiency of the engine, the efficiency of the resonator, and the coefficient of performance of the refrigerator. The optimum point for each component was found, and the total system optimal point which is a result of thermoacoustic interaction of all segments were analyzed. It was illustrated how a change in design parameters could affect the pressure and velocity amplitude and phase distribution in different subsystems, which help the designer deal with the challenge of the optimal parameter selection to enhance the system performance. Finally, an exergy analysis was introduced to assess loss mechanism's contribution to each refrigerator's component. This result in a roadmap for optimization of the system. A new parameter called non-dimensional exergy loss portion (NELP) was introduced, which may significantly show the improvement potential in each system component.

Behaviour of Innovative Concrete Sandwich Panels with Pervious Concrete Core under Flexural Bending

Research studies investigating the possibility of using new core material (other than polystyrene) in concrete sandwich panels are being reported in the literature. In this paper, lightweight pervious concrete core is proposed as a new alternative. In this paper, the flexural behaviour of concrete sandwich panels with pervious concrete core is investigated under three-point and four-point bending conditions. The geometrical variables considered are core thickness and number of shear connector lines. Test results showed that, sandwich panels without shear connector trusses failed due to separation of wythes, and the panels with shear connector trusses achieved composite action. The variables considered were found to influence the initial stiffness, cracking moment, ultimate moment, load-deflection behaviour and load-strain behaviour of the panels. Analytical study indicated that the equation given in ACI 318 underestimated the strength of the tested panels. The equation have to be modified by explicitly including the shear connector details in the equation for predicting the flexural strength with reasonable accuracy. Further experimental and analytical studies on prototype concrete sandwich panels with pervious concrete core produced using lightweight aggregates are required in view of developing design guidelines for practical applications.

A state-of-the-art review of progressive collapse research and guidelines for single-layer lattice shell structures

The importance of progressive collapse analysis of structures has increased significantly due to various structural collapses. Single-layer lattice shell structures are susceptible to progressive collapse, as the failure or instability of a localised region can result in a global collapse due to their lightness and wide span. The geometry of these structures plays a crucial role in the load resistance, and any damage that alters the overall geometry can initiate different instabilities, which may also result in progressive collapse. Therefore, the possibility of progressive collapse is high among these lighter structural forms. However, research on the progressive collapse of single-layer lattice shell structures is limited compared to framed structures, highlighting the need for further investigation. Therefore, this manuscript aims to provide a comprehensive review of research conducted on the progressive collapse of single-layer lattice shell structures, focusing on experimental, numerical, and theoretical investigations. Earlier studies have explored the propagation of local instabilities leading to overall failure. More recent research has primarily focused on two approaches: (1) alternate path analysis, which examines the structure’s response after removing a member, and (2) substructure analysis, which aims to identify collapse-preventive mechanisms. Based on these analyses, various methods to enhance progressive collapse resistance have been discussed, including specific local resistance, alternate load paths, compartmentalisation, and tie forces. This review also highlights the limitations present in the current literature and suggests future research directions, which helps to develop design guidelines that can effectively increase the progressive collapse resistance of single-layer lattice shell structures, making them more reliable for various structural applications.