Detection Of Coliphages Research Articles

Assessing the prevalence of FRNA bacteriophages and their correlation with SARS-CoV-2 RNA in the wastewater of Mumbai city

ABSTRACT Bacteriophages have been explored as indicators of the presence of human viruses in water. F+ coliphages are of particular interest due to their abundance in wastewater and some groups surviving the treatment process. This study assessed the prevalence of F+ coliphages and FRNA bacteriophage (FRNAPH) groups in the wastewaters of Mumbai city and explored its correlation with the presence of SARS-CoV-2. Wastewater samples (raw = 63, treated = 99) collected from three wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) were assessed for F+ coliphages, FRNAPH groups and SARS-CoV-2. Of the 63 raw wastewater samples, 92% were positive for F+ coliphages and FRNAPH, while SARS-CoV-2 was detected in 76% of samples; FRNAPH GI RNA was the most prevalent (96.82%) followed by FRNAPH GII (77.77%), FRNAPH GIII (36.50%), and FRNAPH GIV (4.76%). A significant correlation was observed between the occurrence of SARS-CoV-2 and F+ coliphages, FRNAPH GII and FRNAPH GIII RNA copies and also between F+ coliphages and FRNAPH GII and GIII. These observations suggest that F+ coliphages, FRNAPH GII and GIII can be explored further as indicators of SARS-CoV-2 in wastewaters. Also, F+ coliphage detection may be a cost-effective and practical approach for monitoring virus elimination during wastewater treatment.

Cross-method assessment of coliphage detection methods in the framework of EPA regulatory standards.

This study aimed to understand the performance and utility of US EPA-approved coliphage methods in comparison to fecal indicator bacteria (FIB) and molecular microbial source tracking (MST) methods in recreational waters. We used US EPA Method 1642 to quantify concentrations of coliphage along with culture- and molecular-based enumeration of E. coli and Enterococcus sp, and human fecal source marker HF183. We also conducted a feasibility assessment to determine the utility of US EPA Method 1642 for application to routine recreational water monitoring. Ten sampling events were conducted at three sampling sites over the duration of a year. Average concentrations of somatic (SC) (log10 1.48 PFU/100 mL) and male-specific (MSC) coliphages (log10 1.00 PFU/100 mL) at all sites were low with SC found across a broader range (0.3-3.1 log10 PFU/100 mL) of concentrations compared to MSC (non-detect-1.7 log10 PFU/100 mL). A feasibility assessment was conducted across US EPA Method 1642 for coliphage enumeration, culture-based FIB, defined substrate technology (DST) approaches Enterolert™ and Colilert®, and quantitative microbial source tracking (qMST) US EPA Method 1696. US EPA Method 1642 had the longest processing times, but also was moderate in cost, compared to the DST and qMST molecular methods. Given the poor correlations between MSC and SC with FIB and qMST markers in this study and the cumbersome nature of US EPA Method 1642, the method may not be the most applicable method for use in systems impacted predominantly by stormwater and other non-point source pollution. Findings from this study, however, provide guidance on the application of fecal indicator virus in ambient coastal surface waters.

F-specific coliphage detection by the Bluephage method

F-specific coliphages have been proposed as viral indicators of fecal pollution. These intestinal phages infect cells through the F-pili of the host strains used for their detection, Escherichia. coli HS/FAmp in the US-EPA standard method and Salmonella enterica WG49 in the ISO method.The recently designed Bluephage protocol allows the rapid detection of as low as one somatic coliphage in a working day. The current study describes a new Bluephage method designed to exclusively detect F-specific phages. It employs two new host strains, CB14 and CB16, which detect the same number of F-specific phages as their respective parental strains HS and WG49. In the Bluephage method, when the strain is lysed by bacteriophage infection, the yellow medium turns blue. As low as one F-specific phage was detected in 3 to 5 h by this approach and when the sample contained high phage concentrations, results were obtained in less than 3 h. The F-specific Bluephage method can be used with different sample volumes and allows phage quantification by the most probable number technique. Strain CB14 performed more consistently than CB16, with comparable detection efficiency after increasing the incubation time to 50 min without shaking.

Bluephage, a method for efficient detection of somatic coliphages in one hundred milliliter water samples

Emerging water quality guidelines and regulations require the absence of somatic coliphages in 100 mL of water, yet the efficiency of standardized methods to test this volume of sample is questionable. A recently described procedure, Bluephage, using a modified E. coli host strain, overcomes some of the methodological limitations of standardized methods. In a maximum of 6.5 hours (2.5 hours for pre-growing the host strain and 4 hours for the presence/absence test), Bluephage allows the direct detection of one plaque-forming unit (PFU) in a 100 mL water sample. The test shows high levels of specificity for somatic coliphages and comparable accuracy with standardized methods.

Evaluation of New Components in Modified Scholten's Medium for the Detection of Somatic Coliphages.

Enteric bacteriophages (somatic coliphages, F-specific coliphages or both together) are now recognized as useful viral indicators in water, shellfish, and biosolids and are being progressively included in national and international sanitary regulations. Among them, somatic coliphages have an advantage in that they usually outnumber F-RNA coliphages in water environments. Their enumeration using Modified Scholten's (MS) media, following the ISO 10705-2 standard for the growth of Escherichia coli host strain WG5, is highly efficient and a common practice worldwide. These media contain a high concentration of nutrients, which may be modified to save costs without loss of bacterial growth host efficiency. This study explored reducing the concentration of nutrients in the current formulation and/or incorporating new components to improve the host bacterial growth and/or the enumeration of somatic coliphages at an affordable analytical cost. A twofold dilution of the original MS media was found not to affect the bacterial growth rate. The addition of combinations of assayed compounds to twofold diluted MS media slightly enhanced its analytical performance without altering bacterial growth. By generating savings in both cost and time while maintaining optimal results, media dilution could be applied to design new simple applications for coliphage enumeration.

Virological Quality of Urban Rivers and Hospitals Wastewaters in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia

Background:Polluted rivers and hospital wastewater become a greater concern because of their public health and environmental hazards with high tendency to result in epidemics.Methods and Materials:The current study investigated 84 samples of Urban rivers and 30 samples of hospitals wastewaters in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia between February and April, 2017. The simultaneous detection of male-specific and somatic Coliphages from the samples was carried out usingEscherichia coliCB390 as the host according to the single agar layer plaque assay at public health microbiology laboratory of Ethiopian Public Health Institute.Results:Of the total 114 samples tested, coliphages were detected in 44 (52.4%) and 3 (10%) samples of urban rivers and hospital waste waters, respect ively. Total coliphages enumerations ranged from <1pfu/100ml to 5.2×103pfu/100ml for urban rivers and <1pfu/100ml to 4.92×103pfu/100ml for hospitals wastewaters.Conclusion:The detection of total coliphages in our study settings warrants the possibility that the pollution of urban rivers and hospital wastewaters may be a source for pathogenic viral infections. Unless coliphages, viral and fecal indicators are also examined in the waters by public health agencies, waterborne infections cause a major risk to public health.

Aptness of Escherichia coli host strain CB390 to detect total coliphages in Colombia

Fecal bacteria have been used for more than a century as indicators of fecal contamination in water. In recent years, the monitoring of somatic and F-specific coliphages has been gradually included in guidelines and regulations as an additional parameter to reinforce water safety. The Escherichia coli host strain CB390 was tailored to detect both somatic and F-specific coliphages in a single test. The efficacy of this strain for bacteriophage detection, previously evaluated in Western Europe and North America, was assessed here for the first time in South America. The detection of somatic and F-specific coliphages by the strain CB390, as well as by standardized methods, was performed in drinking and river water and municipal and abattoir wastewaters. No statistical difference was found in the numbers of total coliphages detected by strain CB390 and the sum of somatic and F-specific coliphages determined separately by the standardized ISO methods. The data presented here provide further validation of the effectiveness of the host strain E. coli CB390 for the detection of total coliphages in waters in a single test and demonstrate its suitability for application in upper-middle income countries of the Americas (World Bank category).

New approach for the simultaneous detection of somatic coliphages and F-specific RNA coliphages as indicators of fecal pollution

Two groups of coliphages have been recently included in different water management policies as indicators of viral fecal pollution in water and food: somatic coliphages, which infect E. coli through cell wall receptors, and F-specific RNA coliphages, which infect through the F-pili. Somatic coliphages are more abundant in fecally contaminated waters, except reclaimed waters, those disinfected by UV irradiation, and some groundwater samples that show a higher level of F-specific coliphages. Somatic coliphages are morphologically similar to DNA enteric viruses while F-specific coliphages are similar to RNA viruses such as norovirus and hepatitis A viruses, which are the viral pathogens of concern in sewage. The use of strains sensitive to both types of phages has been proposed for total coliphage enumeration, thereby avoiding double analysis. The standardized methods available for coliphage detection are robust and cost-effective, but the introduction of ready-to-use methods would facilitate routine implementation in laboratories. The fastest available tool for somatic coliphage enumeration is the recently developed Bluephage, which uses a modified β-glucuronide-overexpressing E. coli strain unable to take up the glucuronide substrate. The overexpressed enzyme accumulates inside the bacterial cells until released by phage-induced cell lysis, whereupon it encounters its substrate and the medium changes from yellow to blue. The present method uses E. coli strain CB12, sensitive to somatic coliphages and F-specific coliphages due to the expression of the F-pili. The Bluephage approach incorporating CB12 detects both types of coliphages in a time range of 1:30 to 4:00 h, as assayed with coliphages from raw sewage, river water, sludge and mussels. This strategy can be applied to obtain qualitative and quantitative results and is applicable to microplates as well as to large sample volumes (100 ml). Moreover it can provide monitoring of water bodies at real time, as for example for ambient recreational beach monitoring.

The QuantiPhage assay: A novel method for the rapid colorimetric detection of coliphages using cellulose pad materials

Assessment of viral contamination is essential for monitoring the microbial quality of water and protection of public health, as human virus presence is not accurately determined using bacterial indicators. Currently, the time required for conventional viral testing means that water contaminated with human pathogens may be used (e.g. for drinking, recreation or irrigation) days before results are available. Here we report a new rapid method for coliphage enumeration, the QuantiPhage (QP) assay. The novelty of the assay is the use of cellulose absorbent pad materials to support coliphage growth and colorimetric detection, in place of agar that is used in the plaque assay. In addition to saving time associated with agar preparation and tempering, the QP assay enabled enumeration of somatic coliphages in 1.5–2 h and F+ coliphages in 2.5–3 h. The assays were highly sensitive, with a lower detection limit of 1 plaque forming unit (PFU) per mL where 1 mL sample volumes were analysed, and 1 PFU per 10 mL where 10 mL sample volumes were analysed. This is the first rapid culture assay to enable low numbers of coliphages to be reliably detected and to produce directly equivalent results to agar-based plaque assays. A novel gelatin-immobilisation method is also reported, that reduces time to prepare bacterial cells from ∼20 h to 40–60 min (depending on the assay format), and provides a ready to use form of cells, that is compatible with rapid detection and kit formats. When applied to analysis of somatic coliphages in wastewater samples and surface water samples, mean differences in results of the QP assay and the conventional plaque assay were not statistically significant (mean difference ≤ 0.15 log10 PFU/L and 0.5 PFU/10 mL respectively, P > 0.05). The QP is a valuable tool for assessing microbial water quality, which may assist in improving the management of water resources.

Detection of coliphages and human adenoviruses in a subtropical estuarine lake

Fecal indicator bacteria (FIB) have been used to assess fecal contamination in recreational water. However, enteric viruses have been shown to be more persistent in the environment and resistant to wastewater treatment than bacteria. Recently, U.S Environmental Protection Agency has proposed the use of coliphages as viral indicators to better protect against viral waterborne outbreaks. This study aimed to detect and determine correlation between coliphages (F-specific and somatic), fecal indicator bacteria (enterococci and fecal coliforms), and human enteric viruses (human adenovirus) in a subtropical brackish estuarine lake. Water samples were collected from 9 estuarine recreation sites on Lake Pontchartrain in southeast Louisiana. Water samples (n = 222, collected weekly) were analyzed for coliphages and fecal indicator bacteria using culture-based methods and large volume water samples (n = 54, collected monthly) were analyzed for human adenovirus using quantitative PCR. Somatic coliphage and F-specific coliphage were found in 93.7 and 65.2% of samples with geometric mean concentrations of 30 and 3 plaque forming units (PFU) per 100 mL, respectively. Enterococci, fecal coliforms, and adenovirus were found in all samples with geometric mean concentrations of 27 most probable number (MPN), 77 MPN, and 3.0 × 104 gene copies per 100 mL, respectively. Watersheds in suburban areas exhibited significantly higher concentrations of coliphages and fecal indicator bacteria, indicating potential fecal contamination from septic systems. There was no significant correlation (p > 0.05) observed between the presence of adenoviruses and fecal indicator bacteria and coliphages. The presence of human adenovirus in Lake Pontchartrain poses a significant public health problem for both recreational use and seafood harvesting as it increases exposure risks. This study demonstrated the lack of relationship between fecal indicators and human viral pathogen in Lake Pontchartrain supporting an alternative microbial surveillance system such as direct pathogen detection.

Virological and bacteriological quality of drinking water in Ethiopia

Background: Since unsafe water is responsible for serious illness, deaths due to highest burdens of diseases and greatest economic failure, monitoring the quality of water is essential. Water Quality monitoring is assessed widely using different indicators. Bacterial and viral indicators provide more complete picture of water quality. Virological quality of water hasn’t been assessed in most countries including Ethiopia. The use of E. coli CB390 minimizes resource and time to perform the tests in simultaneous detection of somatic and male-specific coliphages. Methods & Materials: A cross sectional study was conducted on 218 drinking waters samples collected from various regions of Ethiopia from February to June 2016 to assess water quality using coliphages by the help of CB390 E. coli host, plaque assay; Multiple tube fermentation method for coliforms and pour plate technique for counting heterotrophic bacteria at Ethiopian Public Health Institute. The data were analyzed using SPSS 20. Results: Heterotrophic bacteria, total and thermotolerant coliforms, E. coli and phages were detected in 72.9%, 51.8%, 38.5%, 23.9% and 2.3% of the total samples respectively. Heterotrophic plate count greater than 100 CFU/ml were noted in 41 (18.8%) samples and detections of total and thermotolerant coliforms and E. coli in 38 (17.4%), 24 (11.0%) and 10 (4.6%) samples respectively and no detection of phages in chlorinated waters. While, Heterotrophic plate count greater than 100 CFU/mL were observed in 100 (45.9%) samples and detections of total and thermotolerant coliforms, E. coli and coliphages in 75 (34.4%), 60 (27.5%), 42 (19.3%) and 5 (2.3%) samples respectively for untreated waters. Conclusion: Majority of the waters contained indicators above standard limits. This indicates that the sources are contaminated with environmental and fecal contaminants signifying poor quality and it is a potential threat to human and animals health. Hence regular water monitoring using various indicators should be a priority agenda by all stake holders.

Whole-Genome Sequence of Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica Serovar Typhimurium Strain WG49 and Escherichia coli Strain WG5 Used in South Africa for Phage Detection in Water Samples.

Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica serovar Typhimurium WG49 is widely used for enumeration of F-specific RNA (F-RNA) coliphages in water. Escherichia coli WG5 is broadly used for the detection and enumeration of somatic coliphages in water samples. We report here the genome sequences of these bacterial strains used in South Africa under ISO methods 10705-1 and 10705-2.

Bluephage: A rapid method for the detection of somatic coliphages used as indicators of fecal pollution in water

The use of somatic coliphages as indicators of fecal and viral pollution in water and food has great potential due to the reliability, reproducibility, speed and cost effectiveness of methods for their detection. Indeed, several countries already use this approach in their water management policies. Although standardized protocols for somatic coliphage detection are available, user-friendly commercial kits would facilitate their routine implementation in laboratories. The new method presented here allows detection of up to 1 somatic coliphage in under 3.5 h, well within one working day. The method is based on a modified Escherichia coli strain with knocked-out uidB and uidC genes, which encode the transport of glucuronic acid inside cells, and overexpressing uidA, which encodes the enzyme β-glucuronidase. The enzyme accumulated in the bacterial cells only has contact with its substrate after cell lysis, such as that caused by phages, since the strain cannot internalize the substrate. When the enzyme is released into the medium, which contains a chromogen analogous to glucuronic acid, it produces a change of color from yellow to dark blue. This microbiological method for the determination of fecal pollution via the detection of culturable microorganisms can be applied to diverse sample types and volumes for qualitative (presence/absence) and quantitative analysis and is the fastest reported to date.

E. coli CB390: An alternative E. coli host for simultaneous detection of somatic and F+ coliphage viruses in reclaimed and other waters

Somatic and F+ coliphages have been identified and validated as virus indicators of fecal contamination in ground water by US EPA and more recently they are being considered for use in managing both marine and fresh recreational water and wastewater discharges. Studies documenting their usefulness as viral indicator in reclaimed water sources in the USA are limited. However, simultaneous detection of both somatic and F+ coliphages on a single E. coli host is preferred over their separate analysis because both are abundant in wastewater, they may respond differently to wastewater reclamation treatment processes, and separate analysis for each group in separate host bacteria adds complexity and cost. In this study, a new total coliphage host (E. coli CB390, CECT9198) was evaluated for its ability to detect somatic, F+ coliphages, and total coliphages by US EPA Methods 1601 and 1602. No statistical difference was found in the detection coliphages in spiked phosphate buffered saline samples or in natural waters; additionally, no statistical difference was found between the detection of total coliphages by Methods 1601 and 1602.

Waterborne Viruses and F-Specific Coliphages in Mixed-Use Watersheds: Microbial Associations, Host Specificities, and Affinities with Environmental/Land Use Factors.

This study is one of the first, to our knowledge, to evaluate relationships among F-specific coliphages and a large suite of enteric viruses in mixed-use but agriculturally dominated surface waters in Canada. This study suggested that relationships between viable F-specific coliphages and molecularly detected viruses do exist, but they are not always positive. Caution should be employed if viable F-specific coliphages are to be used as indicators of virus presence in surface waters. This study elucidates relative effects of agriculture, wildlife, and human activity on virus and F-specific coliphage detection. Seasonal and meteorological attributes play a strong role in the detection of most virus and F-specific coliphage targets.

Simultaneous detection of somatic and F-specific coliphages in different settings by Escherichia coli strain CB390.

Bacteriophages are increasingly being used as water quality indicators. Two groups of phages infecting Escherichia coli, somatic and F-specific coliphages, are being considered as indicators of fecal and viral contamination for several types of water around the world. However, some uncertainties remain regarding which coliphages to assess. Recently, E. coli strain CB390 has been reported to be suitable for simultaneous detection of both groups, which seems to be more informative than determining only one of the groups. Here, a significant number of samples from different settings, mostly those where F-specific phages have been reported to outnumber somatic coliphages, are analyzed for somatic coliphages, F-specific RNA phages by standardized methods and coliphages detected by host strain CB390. The results presented here confirm that the numbers of phages counted using CB390 are equivalent to the sum of the somatic and F-specific coliphages counted independently in all settings. Hence the usefulness of this strain for simultaneous detection of somatic and F-specific coliphages is confirmed. Also, sets of data on the presence of coliphages in reclaimed and groundwater are reported.

Specificity of coliphages in evaluating marker efficacy: A new insight for water quality indicators

Conventional procedures for qualitative assessment of coliphage are time consuming multiple step approach for achieving results. A modified and rapid technique has been introduced for determination of coliphage contamination among potable water sources during water borne outbreaks. During December 2013, 40 water samples from different potable water sources, were received for water quality analyses, from a jaundice affected Municipality of West Bengal, India. Altogether, 30% water samples were contaminated with coliform (1–20cfu/ml) and 5% with E. coli (2–5cfu/ml). Among post-outbreak samples, preponderance of coliform has decreased (1–4cfu/ml) with total absence of E. coli. While standard technique has detected 55% outbreak samples with coliphage contamination, modified technique revealed that 80%, double than that of bacteriological identification rate, were contaminated with coliphages (4–20pfu/10ml). However, post-outbreak samples were detected with 1–5pfu/10ml coliphages among 20% samples. Coliphage detection rate through modified technique was nearly double (50%) than that of standard technique (27.5%). In few samples (with coliform load of 10–100cfu/ml), while modified technique could detect coliphages among six samples (10–20pfu/10ml), standard protocol failed to detect coliphage in any of them. An easy, rapid and accurate modified technique has thereby been implemented for coliphage assessment from water samples. Coliform free water does not always signify pathogen free potable water and it is demonstrated that coliphage is a more reliable ‘biomarker’ to ascertain contamination level in potable water.

Comparison of ZetaPlus 60S and nitrocellulose membrane filters for the simultaneous concentration of F-RNA coliphages, porcine teschovirus and porcine adenovirus from river water

Increasing attention is being paid to the impact of agricultural activities on water quality to understand the impact on public health. F-RNA coliphages have been proposed as viral indicators of fecal contamination while porcine teschovirus (PTV) and porcine adenovirus (PAdV) are proposed indicators of fecal contamination of swine origin. Viruses and coliphages are present in water in very low concentrations and must be concentrated to permit their detection. There is little information comparing the effectiveness of the methods for concentrating F-RNA coliphages with concentration methods for other viruses and vice versa. The objective of this study was to compare 5 current published methods for recovering F-RNA coliphages, PTV and PAdV from river water samples concentrated by electronegative nitrocellulose membrane filters (methods A and B) or electropositive Zeta Plus 60S filters (methods C–E). Method A is used routinely for the detection of coliphages (Méndez et al., 2004) and method C (Brassard et al., 2005) is the official method in Health Canada's compendium for the detection of viruses in bottled mineral or spring water. When river water was inoculated with stocks of F-RNA MS2, PAdV, and PTV to final concentrations of 1×106PFU/100mL, 1×105gc/100mL and 3×105gc/100mL, respectively, a significantly higher recovery for each virus was consistently obtained for method A with recoveries of 52% for MS2, 95% for PAdV, and 1.5% for PTV. When method A was compared with method C for the detection of F-coliphages, PAdV and PTV in river water samples, viruses were detected with higher frequencies and at higher mean numbers with method A than with method C. With method A, F-coliphages were detected in 11/12 samples (5–154PFU/100mL), PTV in 12/12 samples (397–10,951gc/100mL), PAdV in 1/12 samples (15gc/100mL), and F-RNA GIII in 1/12 samples (750gc/100mL) while F-RNA genotypes I, II, and IV were not detected by qRT-PCR.

Modified USEPA method 1601 to indicate viral contamination of groundwater

The 2006 Ground Water Rule allows three indicators for detection of fecal contamination: Escherichia coli, enterococci, and coliphages. Although each indicator has its benefits and limitations, testing for all three ensures the safest potable water supply. Somatic and male‐specific coliphages are viral indicators. Current coliphage detection methods approved by the US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) require more preparation and expense compared with rapid bacterial indicator tests. This study describes a tier 2 validation of commercially prepared reagents used in a modified USEPA method 1601 format for the qualitative detection of coliphages. Four water laboratories participated in a USEPA alternative test procedure format using method 1601 performance‐based measurement system guidelines to test four geographically diverse groundwaters spiked with wastewater. Results indicated that the modifications to method 1601 have value in predicting the presence of coliphages in 8 h with subsequent overnight plaque confirmation; the total assay time of 16 to 24 h was equivalent to the 48 to 72 h of USEPA method 1601.

Comparison of methods for the detection of coliphages in recreational water at two California, United States beaches

Methods for detection of two fecal indicator viruses, F+ and somatic coliphages, were evaluated for application to recreational marine water. Marine water samples were collected during the summer of 2007 in Southern California, United States from transects along Avalon Beach (n=186 samples) and Doheny Beach (n=101 samples). Coliphage detection methods included EPA method 1601 - two-step enrichment (ENR), EPA method 1602 - single agar layer (SAL), and variations of ENR. Variations included comparison of two incubation times (overnight and 5-h incubation) and two final detection steps (lysis zone assay and a rapid latex agglutination assay). A greater number of samples were positive for somatic and F+ coliphages by ENR than by SAL (p<0.01). The standard ENR with overnight incubation and detection by lysis zone assay was the most sensitive method for the detection of F+ and somatic coliphages from marine water, although the method takes up to three days to obtain results. A rapid 5-h enrichment version of ENR also performed well, with more positive samples than SAL, and could be performed in roughly 24h. Latex agglutination-based detection methods require the least amount of time to perform, although the sensitivity was less than lysis zone-based detection methods. Rapid culture-based enrichment of coliphages in marine water may be possible by further optimizing culture-based methods for saline water conditions to generate higher viral titers than currently available, as well as increasing the sensitivity of latex agglutination detection methods.