Unnatural amino acids (UAAs) are highly valuable molecules in organic synthesis, pharmaceutical sciences, and material science. Herein, we present a photocatalytic radical approach for desulfurative alkylation of cysteine derivatives with arenethiol as the hydrogen atom transfer catalyst for making UAAs and peptides. The formate salt, acting as the hydrogen atom donor, in situ generates the highly reductive CO2 radical anion species, which is the key to unlocking the C-S bond cleavage process with a simple benzoyl protecting group. No photocatalyst is required for the radical initiation and propagation, which makes such a visible-light-induced process mild, efficient, and sustainable.