Suppose that Y is an n x 1 observable random vector, normally distributed, with mean XfB and dispersion D(F1, ..., Fk), where X is an n x q matrix of known constants, ,B is a q x 1 vector of unknown parameters, Fj = ((ojtu)), say, is an unknown p x p symmetric positive-definite matrix for j = 1, ..., k, and D(F1, ..., Fk) is an n x n symmetric positivedefinite matrix which is a known linear function of the vector of -kp(p + 1) parameters ojtu (j = 1, ..., k; t ) u). In addition, suppose that there are observable p x p random matrices Si (j = 1, ..., k), with Y, S1, ..., Sk mutually independent, such that nj Sj Wp(nj, F), where Wp(n, F) denotes the Wishart distribution of size p with n degrees of freedom and associated dispersion F. Suppose that we are interested in testing the hypothesis Ho: H,B = h versus H1: H/I * h where H is an r x q matrix of known constants with rank r such that H/I is estimable and h is an r x 1 vector of known constants in the column space of H. The problem is to test Ho, the probability of type I error to be approximately oc for all values of the unknown parameters. In the literature, two methods of obtaining a test in particular examples and in general have been tractable. One is an expansion method following Welch (1947) for the Behrens-Fisher problem, James (1951) for the one-way classification, James (1956) for the common mean problem and James (1954) for the problem in general. The other is an approximate degrees of freedom method following Welch (1947) for the Behrens-Fisher problem, Welch (1951) for the one-way classification, Meier (1953) for the common mean problem and Johansen (1980) for the problem in general. Welch (1947) showed that the approximate degrees of freedom test and the expansion test in the Behrens-Fisher problem are equivalent to terms of order nj-'. Welch (1951) showed that the approximate degrees of freedom test of Welch (1951) and the expansion test of James (1951) for the one-way classification are equivalent to terms of order nj-l. Johansen (1980) stated that it is difficult to compare his approximate degrees of freedom test with the expansion test of James (1954). It is the purpose of this paper to show that equivalence to terms of order n-' holds between the general solutions of Johansen (1980) and James (1954) by deriving the approximate degrees of freedom test of Johansen using the methods of James and by deriving a simpler version of the expansion test.