In 1999, a tidal wetland located along the St. Lawrence River close to Ste. Croix de Lotbinière (Quebec, Eastern Canada) was the site of an experimental oil spill. Test plots were established and subjected to an experimental crude oil spill to evaluate natural attenuation, nutrient amendment and vegetation cropping as countermeasures. In 2020, this study re-visited the test plots to investigate residual oil and habitat recovery. Only concentrations of mid-chain length n-alkanes (C10–C36), but not of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), were significantly above detection limit, and were detected in both test plot and control sediments. Hydrocarbon, total organic carbon, nitrogen and phosphate contents did not differ significantly between test plot and control sediments. Microbial analyses did not detect significant differences in microbial load, microbial diversity or microbial community composition between test plot and control sediments. Key genes for the aerobic and anaerobic degradation of n-alkanes as well as for the aerobic degradation of PAHs were detected in all sediment samples. Associated gene abundances did not differ significantly between test plot and control sediments. This study shows that oil-exposed test plot sediments of the Ste. Croix wetland can be considered completely recovered after 21 years irrespective of the performed countermeasure.