With the wide application of Sip/Al composites in key fields, it is critical to understand the material removal behavior and surface integrity evolution mechanism of Sip/Al composites. In this paper, based on the nanoindentation and scratching experiments, the coordination deformation behavior of Si particles and the Al matrix were investigated at the micro-scale, and the mechanism and conditions of surface integrity transition (SIT) of Sip/Al composites were elucidated. Then, taking into account the feature of particle fragmentation and detachment caused by interfacial failure, an analytical model of specific cutting energy for Sip/Al composites cutting under different material removal modes was established. The competitive relationship between ductile deformation and surface defect formation was investigated, and a quantitative prediction model for the critical depth of SIT was proposed. The results show that the evolution of the material removal behavior of Sip/Al composites is a consequence of the coordination deformation the Al matrix and Si particles. The material removal mode of Sip/Al composites transitions from ductile removal to quasi-brittle removal with particle fragmentation and detachment, and there is an obvious SIT characteristic. The prediction results of critical depth are in agreement with the experimental results, with an average error of less than 9.8 %. Moreover, an appropriate increase in cutting speed can effectively enhance the surface integrity of Sip/Al composites. This research contributes to a deeper understanding of the low-damage machining mechanism of Sip/Al composites.