The cathodic decomposition of CdS, both poly crystalline and single crystal, has been studied by electrolyte electroreflectance, cyclic voltammetry and impedance measurements. With a defect-free single crystal, CdS electroreduction (surface deposition of Cd 0 from lattice Cd 2+ ions) has a very high overpotential (1.5–2.0 V). However, after photocorrosion or with polycrystalline electrodes the overpotential is reduced to 100–200 mV due to the accumulation of lattice defects at the electrode surface; reaction is thus possible even at potentials positive of the flatband. Simultaneous with Cd° deposition, the energy levels of the semiconductor are shifted with respect to the electrolyte by 400 mV, conduction band electrons gaining energy to reduce water. Implications for hydrogen evolution at CdS particles are discussed.