Deep Vadose Zone Research Articles

Variation of nitrate sources affected by precipitation with different intensities in groundwater in the piedmont plain area of alluvial-pluvial fan

A substantial reservoir of nitrogen (N) in soil poses a threat to the quality and safety of shallow groundwater, especially under extreme precipitation that hastens nitrogen leaching into groundwater. However, the specific impact of varying precipitation intensities on the concentration and sources of nitrate (NO3−) in groundwater across diverse hydrogeological zones and land uses remains unclear. This study aims to elucidate the fluctuations in NO3− concentration, sources, and controlling factors in shallow groundwater under different intensities of precipitation (extreme heavy precipitation and continuous heavy precipitation) in a typical alluvial-pluvial fan of the North China Plain by using stable isotopes (δ2H–H2O, δ18O–H2O, δ15N–NO3-, δ18O–NO3-), hydrochemical analyses and the SIAR model. Affected by extreme heavy precipitation the depleted isotopes of δ2H–H2O and δ18O–H2O in groundwater of the entire area suggested the rapid recharge of fast flow by precipitation. The enriched isotopes of δ2H–H2O and δ18O–H2O of north part in alluvial fan after continuous heavy precipitation showed the recharge of translatory flow of soil water. NO3−concentrations increased to 78.9 mg/L after extreme heavy precipitation and increased to 105.3 mg/L after continuous heavy precipitation when compared to those in normal year (56.8 mg/L) of north part of the alluvial fan. However, NO3− concentrations had slight variation after continuous heavy precipitation of south part of the fan due to the deep vadose zone. The contribution ratio of sources of NO3− in groundwater by using SIAR analysis revealed manure & sewage (MS) as the primary NO3− source (accounting for 59.7–78.1%) before extreme heavy precipitation, chemical fertilizer (CF) making a minor contribution (6.9–17.3%). Different precipitation events and land use types lead to changes in NO3− sources. Affected by extreme heavy precipitation, the contribution of MS decreased while CF increased, particularly in vegetables (26.2–28.1%) and farmland (29.2–34.7%). After continuous heavy precipitation, MS increased again, particularly in vegetables (50.0%) and farmlands (20.4–66.4%), with CF either increasing or remaining steady. This indicated that continuous heavy precipitation accelerated the leaching of nitrogen (organic manure application) stored in deep soil to groundwater and it has a larger influence on the increasing of NO3− concentrations of groundwater than extreme heavy precipitation which carried nitrogen (chemical fertilizer application) in shallow soil to groundwater by fast flow. These findings underscore the importance of considering soil chemical N stores and their implications for groundwater contamination mitigation under future extreme climate scenarios, particularly in agricultural management practices.

Newly plant-derived carbon in the deeper vadose zone of a sandy agricultural soil does not stimulate denitrification

Analysis of stable carbon (C) isotopic signatures (δ13C) in various soil C pools provides useful information on soil C sources, transport, and availability. Understanding the extent of deeper soil (below 40 cm) sequestration and transport of plant derived C is of particular interest as this provides a source for microorganisms to drive biological denitrification (as indicated by denitrification enzyme activity, DEA) and hence mitigate the nitrate leaching to groundwater. Meanwhile, studies on deeper soil C sequestration are rare due to methodological constraints. This study was done in deeper vadose zone (0–160 cm) of a sandy agricultural soil in a humid and temperature zone after a C3-C4 vegetation change taking advantage of the marked isotopic differences between C3 and C4 plants. It took place in a site previously grown with C3 crops (beet, barley, grass), but where C4 crops (maize) were grown continuously for the last 20 years. The other site where C3 crops were continuously grown was used for comparison. Specifically, the δ13C signature in top and deeper soil layers was used to distinguish between old C3– and newly C4-plant derived C in four C pools, i.e., bulk soil C, hot- and cold-water extractable C, and respired CO2-C. The δ13C signature between C3 soils and C3-C4 shifted soils was similar for bulk soil C but significantly different for water extractable and respired C pools. Hence, we estimated that the contribution of newly derived C to bulk soil C was negligible, whereas the contributions to the other C pools amounted up to 28.4 % along the soil profile. This emphasizes the importance of simultaneously analysing δ13C signature in various soil C pools to accurately assess C vertical transport and distribution. The concentrations of cold-DOC and values of specific ultraviolet visible absorbance of the wavelengths 254 and 280 nm decreased from 50 to 130 cm soil depths, while they increased below these depths. However, this suggested rise in C chemical quality at the deepest soil depths did not cause an increase in soil respiration activity or DEA, which was attributed to the protective effects of iron and aluminium oxides on C decomposition. Upon the application of labile C and N substrates, the deepest soil layers displayed a significantly increased DEA, suggesting the presence of a relatively abundant population of active denitrifying organisms. Overall, this study documents the presence of plant-derived C in the deeper vadose zone. Meanwhile, this particular C pool might not be an important substrate to drive deep-soil denitrification due to constraints imposed by the protection by metal oxides.

High spatiotemporal asynchrony between water deficit and nitrate accumulation under apple orchards in deep loess deposits

Understanding the relationship between water and nitrate in soils is critical to agricultural production and aquifer vulnerability assessments, especially in regions with intensive agricultural activities and thick unsaturated zones. Deep soils usually record long-term variations in coupling water and nitrate processes, influenced by multiple environmental factors. As such, this study aims to investigate water and nitrate-nitrogen (NO3–−N) contents and their relationships in soil profiles of 13–23 m deep under farmland and neighboring apple orchards with different ages. Soil properties were considered to explore the individual effect of a single factor or combined effects of multiple factors by wavelet analysis and partial least squares path models. Compared with farmland, apple orchards had large water deficit and NO3–−N accumulation due to root water uptake and synthetic fertilizer inputs, with high spatiotemporal asynchrony in deep unsaturated zones. Specifically, water deficit and NO3–−N accumulation were respectively observed in relatively stable (5–15 m) and active layers (0–5 m, spatial asynchrony), with higher water deficit rates under young apple trees (e.g., 12 and 22 years old) but larger NO3–−N accumulation rates under old apple trees (e.g., 23–32 years old, temporal asynchrony), respectively. Under farmland and orchard, soil texture-organic carbon regulated soil water movement, while soil water-organic carbon affected nitrate transport and transformation processes, which further altered soil pH and electric conductivity conditions in deep vadose zones. The growth of apple trees leads to asynchronous water depletion and fertilizer accumulation in soils, and the > 20 years apple trees are limited by insufficient water despite the excessive fertilizer. The dried soil layers not only reduce potential groundwater recharge, but also prolong the residence time of nitrate bombs in thick unsaturated zones. This study provides essential information for sustainable management of vegetation and water resources, and benefits the complicated hydrological and biogeochemical cycles in thick vadose zones.

Genome-Resolved Metagenomics and Denitrifying Strain Isolation Reveal New Insights into Microbial Denitrification in the Deep Vadose Zone.

The heavy use of nitrogen fertilizer in intensive agricultural areas often leads to nitrate accumulation in subsurface soil and nitrate contamination in groundwater, which poses a serious risk to public health. Denitrifying microorganisms in the subsoil convert nitrate to gaseous forms of nitrogen, thereby mitigating the leaching of nitrate into groundwater. Here, we investigated denitrifying microorganisms in the deep vadose zone of a typical intensive agricultural area in China through microcosm enrichment, genome-resolved metagenomic analysis, and denitrifying bacteria isolation. A total of 1000 metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs) were reconstructed, resulting in 98 high-quality, dereplicated MAGs that contained denitrification genes. Among them, 32 MAGs could not be taxonomically classified at the genus or species level, indicating that a broader spectrum of taxonomic groups is involved in subsoil denitrification than previously recognized. A denitrifier isolate library was constructed by using a strategy combining high-throughput and conventional cultivation techniques. Assessment of the denitrification characteristics of both the MAGs and isolates demonstrated the dominance of truncated denitrification. Functional screening revealed the highest denitrification activity in two complete denitrifiers belonging to the genus Pseudomonas. These findings greatly expand the current knowledge of the composition and function of denitrifying microorganisms in subsoils. The constructed isolate library provided the first pool of subsoil-denitrifying microorganisms that could facilitate the development of microbe-based technologies for nitrate attenuation in groundwater.

The nature and extent of bomb tritium remaining in deep vadose zone: A synthesis and prognosis

AbstractTritium present in deep vadose zones is a useful tracer for estimating groundwater recharge, but its full utility is constrained by not knowing where and for how long the tritium tracing method remains applicable. We obtained 44 tritium profiles from 17 globally distributed sites with vadose zone thicknesses of 12–624 m and used transport models to estimate the number of years that tritium may still be useful. Results show that the method may still be usable for 26 of 44 soil profiles surveyed, mainly in China, Australia, the United States, South Africa, and Senegal, with a remaining useful period of between 6 and 83 years. We also developed a statistical model that uses outputs from a hydrological model to predict the applicability of the tritium tracing method. Global implementation of the statistical model showed that the method remains usable at 20% of Earth's land mass (excluding Antarctica and Greenland) over the next few decades.

Simulation of spatial and temporal variation of nitrate leaching in the vadose zone of alluvial regions on a large regional scale

Excessive use of fertilizers presents a significant threat to groundwater safety. To mitigate nitrate leaching and ensure the sustainable utilization of groundwater resources, it is crucial to quantify the spatial heterogeneity of nitrogen leaching and its drivers. Therefore, accurate modeling of deep nitrate leaching at large regional scales is necessary. In this study, we have created a computational framework to analyze the transport of unsaturated zone water and nitrate at a regional scale. The framework is based on a process-oriented, watershed-scale computational model that segments the study area into a grid system, with each grid modeled using Richards-based advection-diffusion equations for water and solutes. The research model estimated nitrate nitrogen leaching, accumulation, and denitrification in the vadose zone of agricultural fields in the Baiyangdian watershed, which is a typical agricultural region with complex land use and soil deposition conditions in the North China Plain. The results showed that there were significant spatial differences in nitrate N leaching, denitrification and accumulation with values of 0–388 kg/ha/year, 30–177 kg/ha/year and 75–4778 kg/ha. Groundwater recharge in the wheat/maize, vegetable, and cotton area exhibited a negative correlation with nitrate N accumulation while showing a positive correlation with nitrate N leaching. Nitrate nitrogen distribution indicated spatial heterogeneity, attributable mainly to the heterogeneity in soil texture, structure, and land use. With nitrate nitrogen leaching and denitrification levels reaching 327–388 kg/ha/year and 133–175 kg/ha/year, respectively, vegetable fields pose a direct threat to groundwater. Meanwhile, wheat/maize fields showed the greatest nitrate nitrogen accumulation, ranging from 624 to 4778 kg/ha. This excessive buildup of nitrate in these fields presents a potential hazard to groundwater quality. Soil texture in the root zone had a greater influence on the amount of nitrate leaching and denitrification than soil texture below the root zone. Deeper soil texture (>2 m) was found to mainly control total nitrate accumulation in the vadose zone. To assess nitrate leaching, denitrification, and accumulation at a regional scale within the deep vadose zone, a process-oriented model was developed, considering the intricate associations among land usage, soil texture, and biochemical reactions.

Dynamics of soil water and nitrate within the vadose zone simulated by the WHCNS model calibrated based on deep learning

Excessive application of water and nitrogen fertilizer during farmland management practices leads to serious groundwater nitrate pollution. A field experiment was conducted during the spring maize growth period in Alxa, Inner Mongolia, China. The soil Water Heat Carbon Nitrogen Simulator (WHCNS) model was calibrated by the ensemble smoother method (ES(DL)) based on the field experiment. Then dynamics of soil water content, soil water percolation flux, soil nitrate concentration and soil nitrate leaching flux were simulated with the calibrated WHCNS model under different water and nitrogen fertilization treatments within the vadose zone. The main conclusions are as follows: ES(DL) is feasible for the calibration of the WHCNS model. RMSE_Maximum a posteriori (RMSE_MAP) of soil water content are 0.0301 cm3 cm−3 and 0.0302 cm3 cm−3 for model calibration and model validation, respectively. RMSE_MAP of soil nitrate concentration are 5.49 mg N kg−1 and 3.86 mg N kg−1 for model calibration and model validation, respectively. Both average soil nitrate concentration and average nitrate leaching flux increase with increasing irrigation amount under the same nitrogen fertilization level for the depths of 1.2 m and 1.8 m. However, average soil nitrate concentration decreased and leaching flux increased with increasing irrigation amount under the same nitrogen fertilization level for the depths of 10 m and 20 m. The study of nitrate dynamics in the deep vadose zone contributes to better understand the procedure of nitrate pollution in groundwater caused by excessive water and nitrogen application.

Microbial nitrogen mineralization is slightly affected by conversion from farmland to apple orchards in thick loess deposits

Organic nitrogen mineralization, indispensable to soil carbon and nitrogen cycles, is the largest contributor to nitrate reservoirs in deep vadose zones. The microbial nitrogen mineralization (MNM) within deep soils, particularly in regions with intensive agricultural activities and thick soil horizons, has been largely disregarded. As such, this study aims to address this knowledge gap by investigating the chiA-harboring microbial structure and network within nine 10-m profiles beneath cultivated farmland and two apple orchards. The results showed that apple orchards, compared to farmland, had considerable water deficit and nitrogen accumulation within deeper soil layers due to well-developed root systems and the overuse of chemical fertilizers. However, the chiA-harboring microbial diversity, composition, and abundance all exhibited significant variations with soil depths rather than being influenced by different land use types. Moreover, the diversity indices and gene abundances decreased with soil depths, and the related soil microbes included 19 phyla, 29 classes, 72 orders, 114 families, and 197 genera, with Actinobacteria and Proteobacteria being the two major bacterial phyla. The microbial co-occurrence network was simper beneath apple orchards. The chiA-harboring microorganisms within deep unsaturated zones were greatly influenced by the depth-dependent soil nutrients, such as total nitrogen, organic carbon, and available potassium. The limited plant root biomass and the inhibitory effects of dried soil layers both restricted the availability of carbon sources, which further interfered with the MNM processes within deep soils insignificantly. Therefore, despite the considerable plant-induced ecohydrological consequences, the depth-dependent MNM processes were slightly affected after the transformation from farmland to apple orchards within thick loess deposits. This study offers crucial insights into microbial dynamics of the deep biosphere, thereby contributing to our understanding of depth-dependent biogeochemical cycles within global deep unsaturated zones.

Exploring recharge mechanisms of soil water in the thick unsaturated zone using water isotopes in the North China Plain

Exploring the groundwater recharge mechanisms in regions with thick unsaturated zones can enhance our understanding of intricate groundwater processes, especially in intensive agricultural regions such as the North China Plain (NCP). For example, to better answer the question of how deep soil water can be recharged, it is of utmost importance to illustrate the recharge mechanisms of groundwater under different land use types in the NCP. This study collected soil samples from four boreholes up to 18 m deep covering farmland and orchards with different stand ages and measured soil water content (SWC), stable and radioactive isotopes (δ18O, δ2H and 3H) of both soil water and groundwater. Results indicated that the movement of water through the deep vadose zone of soils was primarily piston flow based on a soil tritium profile. The infiltration rate was estimated to be 32.2 mm yr−1 based on the tritium peak method. The variations of soil water δ18O and line control excess (lc-excess) indicated that the orchards had lower evaporation effects and a higher precipitation offset than those in farmland soils. Furthermore, the deep soil water was replenished by intensive precipitation events (from July to September). The great soil water deficit and decreased deep drainage under pear orchards is usually closely related to huge water consumption by evapotranspiration (ET) via root uptake, which explains the increase of ET in pear orchards with increasing stand age. These findings have provided substantial insights into groundwater resource management in similar regions with limited water resources and recharge modeling for regions covered with thick unsaturated zones.

Interplay of legacy irrigation and nitrogen fertilizer inputs to spatial variability of arsenic and uranium within the deep vadose zone

The vadose zone is a reservoir for geogenic and anthropogenic contaminants. Nitrogen and water infiltration can affect biogeochemical processes in this zone, ultimately affecting groundwater quality. In this large-scale field study, we evaluated the input and occurrence of water and nitrogen species in the vadose zone of a public water supply wellhead protection (WHP) area (defined by a 50-year travel time to groundwater for public supply wells) and potential transport of nitrate, ammonium, arsenic, and uranium. Thirty-two deep cores were collected and grouped by irrigation practices: pivot (n = 20), gravity (n = 4) irrigated using groundwater, and non-irrigated (n = 8) sites. Beneath pivot-irrigated sites, sediment nitrate concentrations were significantly (p < 0.05) lower, while ammonium concentrations were significantly (p < 0.05) higher than under gravity sites. The spatial distribution of sediment arsenic and uranium was evaluated against estimated nitrogen and water loading beneath cropland. Irrigation practices were randomly distributed throughout the WHP area and presented a contrasting pattern of sediment arsenic and uranium occurrence. Sediment arsenic correlated with iron (r = 0.32, p < 0.05), uranium negatively correlated to sediment nitrate (r = −0.23, p < 0.05), and ammonium (r = −0.19 p < 0.05). This study reveals that irrigation water and nitrogen influx influence vadose zone geochemistry and mobilization of geogenic contaminants affecting groundwater quality beneath intensive agricultural systems.

Spatio-temporal variations of nitrate pollution of groundwater in the intensive agricultural region: Hotspots and driving forces

Nitrate (NO3−) pollution of groundwater is a persistent and widespread problem worldwide, particularly in intensive agricultural regions with high nitrogen (N) surplus. Identifying spatio-seasonal variations, drivers and sources of NO3− in groundwater is key to controlling this pollution. In this study, we monitored 175 wells in areas with different irrigation practices (dryland, well irrigation and canal irrigation) in an intensive apple-planting region over a year (September 2020–October 2021) in the southern Loess Plateau, China. The integration of hydrochemical analysis, deep soil profiles, NO3− isotopic composition and a Bayesian isotope mixing model (SIAR) was used to identify the hotspots and hot moments of groundwater NO3− pollution, and main NO3− sources. The results showed that average NO3− concentrations of three regions gradually decreased from north to south, following the order of dryland region (9 mg NO3 L−1) < well irrigation region (23 mg NO3 L−1) < canal irrigation region (94 mg NO3 L−1), and orchard > residential area ≈ cereal land. In the study region, 44% of groundwater exceeded the drinking standard of the World Health Organization (50 mg NO3 L−1). The intensive apple planting in the canal irrigation regions has caused groundwater NO3− pollution, and changed hydrochemical types from HCO3−Ca‧Mg to SO4‧Cl‧NO3-Ca‧Mg. In the canal irrigation region, NO3− in the vadose zone has migrated to groundwater. The hotspots of groundwater NO3− pollution (NO3− vulnerable zones) were identified at low-altitude loess tableland and alluvial plains with canal irrigation. Irrigation and precipitation accelerated soil NO3− deep migration. The hot moments of NO3− pollution in the irrigated region was the period from the wet season to the dry season; and the “hidden reactive N pool” in the deep vadose zone (>2 m) caused a time lag of NO3− reaching into groundwater. Chemical N fertilizer and manure N applied in apple orchards were the main contributing sources of groundwater NO3− pollution in the apple-planting region. Our study highlights the significant effect of apple-planting industry development on groundwater quality.

Radionuclide Transport Simulations Supporting Proposed Borehole Waste Disposal in Israel

A scientific collaboration between the U.S. and Israel is underway to assess the suitability of a potential site for subsurface radioactive waste disposal in the Negev Desert, Israel. The Negev Desert has several favorable attributes for geologic disposal, including an arid climate, a deep vadose zone, interlayered low-permeability lithologies, and carbonate rocks with high uranium-sorption potential. These features may provide a robust natural barrier to radionuclide migration. Geologic and laboratory characterization data from the Negev Desert are incorporated into multiphase flow and transport models, solved using PFLOTRAN, to aid in site characterization and risk analysis that will support decision-making for waste disposal in an intermediate-depth borehole design. The lithology with the greatest uranium sorption potential at the site is phosphorite. We use modeling to evaluate the ability of this layer to impact uranium transport around a proposed disposal borehole. The current objective of the simulations is focused on characterizing hypothetical leakage from waste canisters and subsequent uranium migration under three infiltration scenarios. Here, we describe a hydrogeologic model based on data from a local exploratory borehole and present results for uranium flow and transport simulations under varying infiltration scenarios. We find that under the current climate conditions, it is likely that uranium will remain in the near-field of the borehole for thousands of years. However, under a hypothesized extreme climate scenario representing an increase in infiltration by a factor of 300x above present-day values, uranium may break through the phosphorite layer and exit the base of the model domain (~200 m above the water table) within 1000 years. Simulation results have direct implications for the planning of nuclear waste disposal in the Negev Desert, and specifically in intermediate-depth boreholes.

Ecohydrologic Dynamics of Rock Moisture in a Montane Catchment of the Colorado Front Range

AbstractWarming across the western United States continues to reduce snowpack, lengthen growing seasons, and increase atmospheric demand, leading to uncertainty about moisture availability in montane forests. As many upland forests have thin soils and extensive rooting into weathered bedrock, deep vadose‐zone water may be a critical late‐season water source for vegetation and mitigate forest water stress. A key impediment to understanding the role of the deep vadose zone as a reservoir is quantifying the plant‐available water held there. We quantify the spatiotemporal dynamics of rock moisture held in the deep vadose zone in a montane catchment of the Rocky Mountains. Direct measurements of rock moisture were accompanied by monitoring of precipitation, transpiration, soil moisture, leaf‐water potentials, and groundwater. Using repeat nuclear magnetic resonance and neutron‐probe measurements, we found depletion of rock moisture among all our monitored plots. The magnitude of growing season depletion in rock moisture mirrored above‐ground vegetation density and transpiration, and depleted rock moisture was from ∼0.3 to 5 m below ground surface. Estimates of storage indicated weathered rock stored at least 4%–12% of mean annual precipitation. Persistent transpiration and discrepancies between estimated soil matric potentials and leaf‐water potentials suggest rock moisture may mitigate drought stress. These findings provide some of the first measurements of rock moisture use in the Rocky Mountains and indicated rock moisture use is not just confined to periods of drought or Mediterranean climates.

Monitoring of Thick Vadose Zone Water Dynamics Under Irrigation Using a 48 m Deep Caisson at the Luancheng Critical Zone Observatory

AbstractUnderstanding soil water dynamics in the deep vadose zone (DVZ, below the root zone) of irrigated farmland is critical for estimating groundwater recharge and assessing the impacts of agricultural activities on groundwater quality. However, the state and movement of soil water in the DVZ remain poorly understood owing to the lack of in‐situ observations. Here, based on a 48‐m deep caisson (Critical Zone Observatory, CZO) established in a typical irrigated farmland in the piedmont region of the North China Plain, we extended the monitoring of soil water content and matric potential across the entire vadose zone profile. We found that a high soil water content and matric potential (close to or slightly higher than the field capacity) was maintained in the DVZ of typical irrigated cropland. The response of soil water in the DVZ to the water inputs at the ground surface was predominantly sequentially delayed with an increase in depth in the DVZ. As a result, the wetting front propagated into the soil layer to a depth of 38 m within 228 days. Moreover, high soil moisture contents and matric potentials in the DVZ resulted in a dramatic but explicable difference between the estimated average pore water velocity (0.73 m year−1) and the wetting front propagation rate (0.16 m day−1). This study demonstrates the unreported rapid response of soil water in the DVZ to water input at the ground surface under intensively irrigated cropland and could promote a better understanding of groundwater recharge processes with a thick unsaturated zone.

Labile carbon and soil texture control nitrogen transformation in deep vadose zone

Understanding transient nitrogen (N) storage and transformation in the deep vadose zone is critical for controlling groundwater contamination by nitrate. The occurrence of organic and inorganic forms of carbon (C) and nitrogen and their importance in the deep vadose zone is not well characterized due to difficulty in sampling and the limited number of studies. We sampled and characterized these pools beneath 27 croplands with different vadose zone thicknesses (6–45 m). We measured nitrate and ammonium in different depths for the 27 sites to evaluate inorganic N storage. We measured total Kjeldahl nitrogen (TKN), hot-water extractable organic carbon (EOC), soil organic carbon (SOC), and δ13C for two sites to understand the potential role of organic N and C pools in N transformations. Inorganic N stocks in the vadose zone were 21.7–1043.6 g m−2 across 27 sites; the thicker vadose zone significantly stored more inorganic N (p < 0.05). We observed significant reservoirs of TKN and SOC at depths, likely representing paleosols that may provide organic C and N to subsurface microbes. The occurrence of deep C and N needs to be addressed in future research on terrestrial C and N storage potential. The increase of ammonium and EOC and δ13C value in the proximity of these horizons is consistent with N mineralization. An increase of nitrate, concurrent with the sandy soil texture and the water-filled pore space (WFPS) of 78 %, suggests that deep vadose zone nitrification may be supported in vadose zones with organic-rich layers such as paleosol. A profile showing the decrease of nitrate concentrations, concurrent with the clay soil texture and the WFPS of 91 %, also suggests denitrification may be an important process. Our study shows that microbial N transformation may be possible even in deep vadose zone with co-occurrence of C and N sources and controlled by labile C availability and soil texture.

High nutrients surplus led to deep soil nitrate accumulation and acidification after cropland conversion to apple orchards on the Loess Plateau, China

Nitrate accumulation in the deep vadose zone poses direct or potential threat of environment and agriculture due to the long hydraulic retention time, especially in areas with limited rainfall. This study explored the primary causes and associated environmental problems of deep soil nitrate accumulation in apple orchards on the Loess Plateau by investigating nutrient (N, P, and K) surplus, deep soil nitrate accumulation and acidification, fertilization habits, and farmer awareness, through a combination of questionnaire and experiment. The results revealed much larger nutrient inputs than outputs, with N, P, and K surpluses 1.8–4.0-fold higher than required for apple tree growth. The huge N surplus caused nitrate accumulation and acidification in deep soil under apple orchards (up to 6 m). Soil nitrate storage in 25-year-old apple orchards within 6 m depth ranged from 5039–14,693 kg ha–1, 4.7–11.7-fold higher than under cropland. In addition, soil pH in 25-year-old apple orchards was 0.31–0.40 lower at 2–4 m depth than that of cropland. Overfertilization was the main contributor to the high cost of apple production, with most farmers unaware that they had overfertilized; the farmers also lacked an environmental conscious. We recommend multiple fertilizations, reasonable ratios of chemical and organic fertilizer, and scientific fertilization guidance to balance the economic benefits and environmental protection of apple orchards. In addition, farmers should be educated on environmental protection to sustainably develop the apple industry on the Loess Plateau.

Field variation of groundwater recharge and its uncertainty via multiple tracers' method in deep loess vadose zone

Accurate estimation of groundwater recharge is a precondition for assessing its spatial variation at different scales, especially field scale. In the field, the limitations and uncertainties of different methods are first evaluated based on site-specific conditions. In this study, we evaluated field variation in groundwater recharge via multiple tracers in the deep vadose zone on the Chinese Loess Plateau. Five deep soil profiles (approximately 20 m deep) were collected in the field. Soil water content and particle compositions were measured to analyse soil variation, and soil water isotope (3H, 18O, and 2H) and anion (NO3− and Cl−) profiles were used to estimate recharge rates. Distinct peaks in soil water isotope and nitrate profiles indicated a vertical one-dimensional water flow in the vadose zone. Although the soil water content and particle composition were moderately variable, no significant differences were observed in recharge rates among the five sites (p > 0.05) owing to the identical climate and land use. The recharge rates did not show a significant difference (p > 0.05) between different tracers' methods. However, recharge estimates by the chloride mass balance method indicated higher variations (23.5 %) than those by the peak depth method (11.2 % to 18.7 %) among five sites. Moreover, if considering the contribution of immobile water in vadose zone, groundwater recharge would be overestimated (25.4 % to 37.8 %) using the peak depth method. This study provides a favourable reference for accurate groundwater recharge and its variation evaluated using different tracers' methods in deep vadose zone.

The natural abundance of stable water isotopes method may overestimate deep-layer soil water use by trees

Abstract. Stable water isotopes have been used extensively to study the water use strategy of plants in various ecosystems. In deep vadose zone (DVZ) regions, the rooting depth of trees can reach several meters to tens of meters. However, the existence of roots in deep soils does not necessarily mean the occurrence of root water uptake, which usually occurs at a particular time during the growing season. Therefore, quantifying the contribution of deep-layer soil water (DLSW) in DVZ regions using the natural abundance of stable water isotopes may not be accurate because this method assumes that trees always extract shallow- and deep-layer soil water. We propose a multi-step method for addressing this issue. First, isotopic labeling in deep layers identifies whether trees absorb DLSW and determines the soil layer depths from which trees derive their water source. Next, we calculate water sources based on the natural abundance of stable isotopes in the soil layer determined above to quantify the water use strategy of trees. We also compared the results with the natural abundance of stable water isotopes method. The 11- and 17-year-old apple trees were taken as examples for analyses on China's Loess Plateau. Isotopic labeling showed that the water uptake depth of 11-year-old apple trees reached 300 cm in the blossom and young fruit (BYF) stage and only 100 cm in the fruit swelling (FSW) stage, whereas 17-year-old trees always consumed water from the 0–320 cm soil layer. Overall, apple trees absorbed the most water from deep soils (&gt;140 cm) during the BYF stage, and 17-year-old trees consumed more water in these layers than 11-year-old trees throughout the growing season. In addition, the natural abundance of stable water isotopes method overestimated the contribution of DLSW, especially in the 320–500 cm soil layer. Our findings highlight that determining the occurrence of root water uptake in deep soils helps to quantify the water use strategy of trees in DVZ regions.

Kinetic and molecular evidence for DON transformation in the deep vadose zone: Important implications for soil nitrogen budgeting and groundwater nitrate management

The neglect of dissolved organic nitrogen (DON), especially with regard to its transformation in the deep vadose zone, can result in high uncertainty surrounding estimated nitrogen (N) leaching losses to groundwater. This study provided kinetic and molecular evidence for DON transformation in the deep vadose zone by focusing on a typical agricultural area in Eastern China. DON was as important as inorganic N for N stocks, and 28.04% ∼ 71.94% of DON was sealed in the deep vadose zones (i.e., > 1 m depth). Soil N mineralization rates gradually decreased as incubation proceeded, and aerobic condition was more favorable for soil N mineralization. Both shallow and deep vadose zones could be potential hotspots for N mineralization, and the trend of N mineralization rate varying with soil depth was site-specific. Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry data revealed that DON was dominated by lipids before incubation, whereas lignins were dominant after incubation was complete. Lignin-like compounds were not intrinsically recalcitrant, instead persisting in soil due to concurrent removal, transformation, and formation. DON transformation occurred along the entire soil profile regardless of redox conditions, potentially having different microbe-mediated pathways. These findings emphasize the implications of considering DON transformation in the deep vadose zone for soil N budgeting and groundwater nitrate management.

Tracing the Sources and Fate of NO3- in the Vadose Zone-Groundwater System of a Thousand-Year-Cultivated Region.

Excess nitrate (NO3-) loading in terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems can result in critical environmental and health issues. NO3--rich groundwater has been recorded in the Guanzhong Plain in the Yellow River Basin of China for over 1000 years. To assess the sources and fate of NO3- in the vadose zone and groundwater, numerous samples were collected via borehole drilling and field surveys, followed by analysis and stable NO3- isotope quantification. The results demonstrated that the NO3- concentration in 38% of the groundwater samples exceeded the limit set by the World Health Organization. The total NO3- stock in the 0-10 m soil profile of the orchards was 3.7 times higher than that of the croplands, suggesting that the cropland-to-orchard transition aggravated NO3- accumulation in the deep vadose zone. Based on a Bayesian mixing model applied to stable NO3- isotopes (δ15N and δ18O), NO3- accumulation in the vadose zone was predominantly from manure and sewage N (MN, 27-54%), soil N (SN, 0-64%), and chemical N fertilizer (FN, 4-46%). MN was, by far, the greatest contributor to groundwater NO3- (58-82%). The results also indicated that groundwater NO3- was mainly associated with the soil and hydrogeochemical characteristics, whereas no relationship with modern agricultural activities was observed, likely due to the time delay in the thick vadose zone. The estimated residence time of NO3- in the vadose zone varied from decades to centuries; however, NO3- might reach the aquifer in the near future in areas with recent FN loading, especially those under cropland-to-orchard transition or where the vadose zone is relatively thin. This study suggests that future agricultural land-use transitions from croplands to orchards should be promoted with caution in areas with shallow vadose zones and coarse soil texture.