Modification of CaO-based materials using Al-type dopants has been considered a promising method to enhance energy storage performance. The synergistic multi-doping effects of different Al-type dopants (soluble, hydrolysable and insoluble) on the energy storage performances, thermophysical and mechanical properties of CaO-based materials have never been reported. The hydrolysable/soluble Al-type supports co-doped CaO-based pellets were prepared, which exhibited superior energy storage density, multi-cycle stability, reaction rate, thermal conductivity and crushing strength compared to undoped CaO pellets. The regulation mechanisms of hydrolysable/soluble Al-type dopants (AlN/Al(NO3)3) on the reaction kinetics, multi-cycle stability, thermophysical properties and mechanical properties of CaO-based pellets were revealed. The addition of different Al-type dopants results in different dispersions of the formed Ca12Al14O33, which leads to different micro-morphologies and pore structures of CaO-based pellets. Hydrolysable Al-type dopants exhibit a more concentrated distribution in CaO-based pellets and the pellets have smaller crystallite sizes of CaO and predominantly microporous pores, which results in the high CO2 reactivity. Soluble Al-type dopants exhibit a more uniform dispersion in CaO-based pellets and the pellets have larger crystallite sizes of CaO and obvious pore channels, which results in the improved cyclic stability and decomposition kinetics. The optimized CaO-based pellets combine the advantages of the two Al-type dopants and present an increasing trend of energy storage density during the cyclic process. Its energy storage density remains 1571 kJ/kg after 50 cycles, and the value for CaO is only 569 kJ/kg. In addition, the optimal synthesized material has excellent thermal conductivity and crushing strength, which are 1.36 and 9.75 times those of CaO, respectively.