Reviewed by: The Virgin Vote: How Young Americans Made Democracy Social, Politics Personal, and Voting Popular in the Nineteenth Century by Jon Grinspan Mark Wahlgren Summers (bio) The Virgin Vote: How Young Americans Made Democracy Social, Politics Personal, and Voting Popular in the Nineteenth Century. By Jon Grinspan. (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2016. Pp. 256. Cloth, $28.00.) Bad readers of detective stories turn to the last chapter first, to see who did it; good readers of history books turn to the endnotes first, to see how the author knows it. Those starting backward for Jon Grinspan’s The Virgin Vote not only will spend a long and rewarding time there; they will then rush eagerly to the front, wondering if the whole work can be as shrewd, as thorough, and as insightful as the citations. They will be agreeably disappointed: the body of the book is better yet. As a study of the excitement and larger significance of political engagement in the party period, this is the most thoughtful and indeed the best book written in at least a generation. It is also quite a lot of fun. Drawing on diaries, memoirs, and newspapers, weighting the argument with statistics about voter turnout, The Virgin Vote shows how young Americans in the nineteenth century engaged in politics and became not simply voters, but participants in every aspect of keeping a robust two-party system running. Politics was no mere election-day phenomenon, but a way of meeting people, of mingling with elders, of entering the world of adulthood, of newcomers finding new friends quickly, and even of finding a potential spouse or helpmeet. Schoolchildren yelled, “Democrats eat dead rats,” and boys took out their rowdiness in the one arson that communities smiled on, the election-night bonfire. For poor boys, the chance [End Page 133] to join a club and earn the praise of a rich sponsor seemed like the first step in a struggle upward. The benefits for the young were nothing compared with the advantages for party organizers. Every “virgin vote” they won, they knew, would be theirs for life: politically, Americans were not only monogamous, but divorce-resistant. Old fogies could recruit young fogies, the hustlers and canvassers among them fit to graduate to work backstairs and in the smoke-filled rooms fitter for middle age, but they never forgot to cultivate those for whom public expression and display mattered most. Youth meant enthusiasm, idealism, and the energy needed to keep an aging political system always refreshed and hearty. If politics meant anything besides winning office and getting spoils, the youngest generation played a key part in making that happen; if midcentury campaigns relied on hoopla and parade, clubs and societies like the Wide Awakes in 1860, the need to draw in the virgin voter and those meaning to vote in the future deserved much of the credit. Only as the parties shifted to campaigns of education, separating the decision to vote from a wider participation, and as American culture began to draw sharper lines between “grown-ups” and those not yet arrived, with activities specific to each category, did the flood of young people into political involvement falter. That turning away from politics, Grinspan would suggest, explains much about the tumbling in turnout as the twentieth century began (and no doubt it did, though the decline in the national figures also could be explained by the broad disfranchisement of African Americans in the South). It is a fascinating story, made more so by Grinspan’s ready use of anecdote and individual example; figures as famous as William Dean Howells or as obscure as Sunday school teacher Mattie Thomas illustrate the intensity and the pervasiveness of political involvement. We find Lester Ward using a Republican rally to hold trysts with the girl of his dreams and an eight-year-old so imbued with Whiggery that the news of President William Henry Harrison’s death threw him into a panic. This is a tale made of a thousand stories and no end of visual images, from the flapping tail of a yellow coat to a cigar-puffing future mayor, “his eyes shielded beneath a derby...
Read full abstract