Introduction: UK DCD rates have increased six-fold in the last 7 years, but it is not clear who benefits from DCD kidney transplants, particularly as the mean age of DCD donors is increasing and DCD kidney allocation is exempt from the national scheme. This study examines donor profile and outcomes according to age at listing for renal transplantation in our centre, where twice as many DCD as DBD kidney transplants are currently performed. Methods: Outcomes of adult patients listed for renal transplantation between 2002 and 2012 were analysed. Patients were divided into three groups according to age at time of listing: <45, 45-65 and >65 (elderly). Times of listing, delisting, death and transplant details were recorded; DCD organs were allocated using a modification of the national algorithm, which favoured age-matching donor and recipient. Results: Of those listed for renal transplantation (1386), 559 were aged under 45, 691 were 45-65 and 136 were over 65, with 74%, 70% and 53%, respectively, receiving a transplant. The proportion of elderly patients listed increased from 6% in 2002 to 13% in 2012. Elderly patients had the highest rate of delisting (p<0.001): only 7% of untransplanted patients who had been listed in the first 6 years were active on the list at time of follow-up (cf 15% 45-65, 24% <45). Despite the preferential national allocation of DBD organs to younger, HLA-matched, recipients, there was no significant difference in time to transplantation between the three groups, likely because whereas younger patients received an equal proportion of organs from DBD, DCD and live donors, older patients received a much higher proportion of DCD kidneys (64% in the >65 group, p<0.001). This reflects local bias of allocating elderly DCD kidneys to elderly patients; 30% of kidneys from DCD donors over 65 were allocated to recipients over 65 (cf 20% of kidneys from comparable DBD donors). This bias has, however, a limited impact on overall DCD usage, because only 12% of all DCD kidneys were allocated to the over 65 group (of which half were from donors over 70). There was no significant difference in graft survival between the three groups when censored for death as a cause of graft loss. Conclusions: The time-frame for transplantation of elderly patients is limited. As numbers listed increase, preferential allocation of older DCD kidneys to this population may alleviate demand with minimal effect on the overall donor pool.
Read full abstract