Open fractures of the lower limb represent a common challenge for trauma centers. Even where national guidelines are available, these standards are frequently missing. Our study evaluates the influence of polytrauma on the adherence to the timing and management required in an orthoplastic approach. A retrospective review was performed on 36 patients affected by a Gustilo-Anderson grade IIIA, IIIB, or IIIC fracture of the lower limb between 2018 and 2022. Data related to patient management were analyzed: time to the first evaluation by a plastic surgeon, time to soft tissue coverage, time to definitive osteosynthesis, days in intensive care unit (ICU), days of hospitalization, and total cost of hospital stay. Patient satisfaction was evaluated through the administration of 2 questionnaires: the Enneking and the Foot Function Index (FFI). In 23 patients (63.9%), a soft tissue reconstruction was required. Of these, 13 were polytraumas (PT) (56.5%) and 10 were affected by an isolated lower limb fracture (ILLF) (43.5%). The median time to wound excision was 7.0 days (IQR, 0-16.0) in the PT group and 12.5 days (IQR, 1-41.0) in the ILLF group, whereas the mean time to soft tissue coverage was 15.0 days (IQR, 4.0-17.0) in the PT group and 38.0 days (IQR, 25.0-65.0) in the ILLF group. Mean time to definitive fixation was 33.0 days (IQR, 6.5-70.0) in the PT group and 16.5 days (IQR, 3.0-26.0) in the ILLF group. Statistically significant difference was reported on mean time to soft tissue coverage, whereas not relevant differences were reported on mean time to plastic surgeon involvement, first debridement, definitive fixation, days of hospitalization, costs, and Enneking and FFI score. This is the first study comparing the effectiveness of the orthoplastic approach between isolated lower limb fractures and polytraumas. According to our study, open lower limb fracture management is paradoxically more effective in polytraumas rather than in isolated injuries because a multidisciplinary approach is mandatory in severely injured and compromised patients.