Despite recent advancements in the cryopreservation of dromedary camel embryos, widespread application of the technique is still limited by the need for specialised vitrification equipment and supplies. Temporary, liquid-phase embryo storage methods provide a useful tool for short-term preservation of camel embryos.In the current study, we compared the use of in vitro embryo culture with cold liquid storage in order to maintain both high- (Grade 1- Excellent and 2-Good) and low- (Grade 3- Moderate and 4-Poor) morphological grade Day-7 dromedary camel embryos in vitro for up to 3 days. Embryos were either cooled and placed in Hams-F10 medium supplemented with HEPES and 10% FBS and then kept at 4 °C; or placed in Hams-F10 supplemented with sodium bicarbonate and 10% FBS and then cultured in a humidified atmosphere of 6% CO2 at 37 °C before being assessed for viability at 24 h. In high-morphological grade embryos, both cold storage and culture supported 100% viability (maintenance of normal morphology) over this period (Cooled n = 22, Cultured n = 20). In low-morphological grade embryos, culture supported higher viability (16/18, 88.9%) than did cooling (4/18, 22.2%). We then evaluated the effect of up to 3 days of cold storage or culture on embryo morphological grade, diameter, and developmental competence following embryo transfer. High-grade embryos were divided between culture and cold storage; low-grade embryos were evaluated only after culture. Over 3 days of culture, both high- and low-grade embryos tended to either maintain or improve upon their initial morphological score (P < 0.05) and increased in diameter (P < 0.001). Embryos subjected to cooling tended to have reduced morphological scores by 48 h of storage and decreased in diameter by 72 h (P < 0.05). No significant influence of storage method (cooling vs. culture), duration (24–72 h), or embryo grade (high vs low) was observed on pregnancy establishment at Day-60 (22.2%–57.2% pregnancy rates for all treatments). Overall, rates of pregnancy establishment were similar for transferred cultured (n = 45) and cooled (n = 45) embryos (pregnancy rates at Day 18, 48% vs 51.1%; at Day 60, 37.7% vs 37.7%). Rates of embryonic loss also were similar (22.7% vs 26%).In conclusion, whilst similar rates of pregnancy and pregnancy loss were observed following the transfer of both cooled and cultured embryos held in vitro for up to 3 days, amongst the two methods, only embryo culture appears to provide a means of effectively preserving Day- 7 dromedary camel embryos with reduced morphological values in vitro. Considering these embryos appear to show poor tolerance to the cooling procedure and are unlikely candidates for vitrification, embryo culture may provide an effective method for deriving pregnancies from low-morphological grade embryos when immediate transfer is not possible on the day of flushing.
Read full abstract