Dark-stable State Research Articles

Does Serial Femtosecond Crystallography Depict State-Specific Catalytic Intermediates of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex?

Recent advances in serial femtosecond crystallography (SFX) of photosystem II (PSII), enabled by X-ray free electron lasers (XFEL), provided the first geometric models of distinct intermediates in the catalytic S-state cycle of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC). These models are obtained by flash-advancing the OEC from the dark-stable state (S1) to more oxidized intermediates (S2 and S3), eventually cycling back to the most reduced S0. However, the interpretation of these models is controversial because geometric parameters within the Mn4CaO5 cluster of the OEC do not exactly match those expected from coordination chemistry for the spectroscopically verified manganese oxidation states of the distinct S-state intermediates. Here we focus on the first catalytic transition, S1 → S2, which represents a one-electron oxidation of the OEC. Combining geometric and electronic structure criteria, including a novel effective oxidation state approach, we analyze existing 1-flash (1F) SFX-XFEL crystallographic models that should depict the S2 state of the OEC. We show that the 1F/S2 equivalence is not obvious, because the Mn oxidation states and total unpaired electron counts encoded in these models are not fully consistent with those of a pure S2 state and with the nature of the S1 → S2 transition. Furthermore, the oxidation state definition in two-flashed (2F) structural models is practically impossible to elucidate. Our results advise caution in the extraction of electronic structure information solely from the literal interpretation of crystallographic models and call for re-evaluation of structural and mechanistic interpretations that presume exact correspondence of such models to specific catalytic intermediates of the OEC.

Orientational Jahn-Teller Isomerism in the Dark-Stable State of Nature's Water Oxidase.

The tetramanganese–calcium cluster of the oxygen‐evolving complex of photosystem II adopts electronically and magnetically distinct but interconvertible valence isomeric forms in its first light‐driven oxidized catalytic state, S2. This bistability is implicated in gating the final catalytic states preceding O−O bond formation, but it is unknown how the biological system enables its emergence and controls its effect. Here we show that the Mn4CaO5 cluster in the resting (dark‐stable) S1 state adopts orientational Jahn–Teller isomeric forms arising from a directional change in electronic configuration of the “dangler” MnIII ion. The isomers are consistent with available structural data and explain previously unresolved electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopic observations on the S1 state. This unique isomerism in the resting state is shown to be the electronic origin of valence isomerism in the S2 state, establishing a functional role of orientational Jahn–Teller isomerism unprecedented in biological or artificial catalysis.

Kα X-ray Emission Spectroscopy on the Photosynthetic Oxygen-Evolving Complex Supports Manganese Oxidation and Water Binding in the S3 State.

The unique manganese-calcium catalyst in photosystem II (PSII) is the natural paragon for efficient light-driven water oxidation to yield O2. The oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) in the dark-stable state (S1) comprises a Mn4CaO4 core with five metal-bound water species. Binding and modification of the water molecules that are substrates of the water-oxidation reaction is mechanistically crucial but controversially debated. Two recent crystal structures of the OEC in its highest oxidation state (S3) show either a vacant Mn coordination site or a bound peroxide species. For purified PSII at room temperature, we collected Mn Kα X-ray emission spectra of the S0, S1, S2, and S3 intermediates in the OEC cycle, which were analyzed by comparison to synthetic Mn compounds, spectral simulations, and OEC models from density functional theory. Our results contrast both crystallographic structures. They indicate Mn oxidation in three S-transitions and suggest additional water binding at a previously open Mn coordination site. These findings exclude Mn reduction and render peroxide formation in S3 unlikely.

Understanding Two Different Structures in the Dark Stable State of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex of Photosystem II: Applicability of the Jahn-Teller Deformation Formula.

Tanaka et al. (J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2017, 139, 1718) recently reported the three‐dimensional (3D) structure of the oxygen evolving complex (OEC) of photosystem II (PSII) by X‐ray diffraction (XRD) using extremely low X‐ray doses of 0.03 and 0.12 MGy. They observed two different 3D structures of the CaMn4O5 cluster with different hydrogen‐bonding interactions in the S1 state of OEC keeping the surrounding polypeptide frameworks of PSII the same. Our Jahn–Teller (JT) deformation formula based on large‐scale quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) was applied for these low‐dose XRD structures, elucidating important roles of JT effects of the MnIII ion for subtle geometric distortions of the CaMn4O5 cluster in OEC of PSII. The JT deformation formula revealed the similarity between the low‐dose XRD and damage‐free serial femtosecond X‐ray diffraction (SFX) structures of the CaMn4O5 cluster in the dark stable state. The extremely low‐dose XRD structures were not damaged by X‐ray irradiation. Implications of the present results are discussed in relation to recent SFX results and a blue print for the design of artificial photocatalysts for water oxidation.

Structural heterogeneity in a parent ground-state structure of AnPixJg2 revealed by theory and spectroscopy.

We investigated the red absorbing, dark stable state (Pr state) of the second GAF domain of the cyanobacteriochrome AnPixJ (AnPixJg2) by a molecular dynamics simulation of 1 μs duration. Our results reveal two distinct conformational isoforms of the chromophore, from which only one was known from crystallographic experiments. The interconversion between both isoforms is accompanied by alterations in the hydrogen bond pattern between the chromophore and the protein and the solvation structure of the chromophore binding pocket. The existence of sub-states in the Pr form of AnPixJg2 is supported by the results from experimental 13C MAS NMR spectroscopy. Our finding is consistent with the observation of structural heterogeneity in other cyanobacteriochromes and phytochromes.

Structure of photosystem II and substrate binding at room temperature.

Light-induced oxidation of water by photosystem II (PS II) in plants, algae and cyanobacteria has generated most of the dioxygen in the atmosphere. PS II, a membrane-bound multi-subunit pigment protein complex, couples the one-electron photochemistry at the reaction centre with the four-electron redox chemistry of water oxidation at the Mn4CaO5 cluster in the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC). Under illumination, the OEC cycles through five intermediate S-states (S0 to S4), in which S1 is the dark-stable state and S3 is the last semi-stable state before O-O bond formation and O2 evolution. A detailed understanding of the O-O bond formation mechanism remains a challenge, and will require elucidation of both the structures of the OEC in the different S-states and the binding of the two substrate waters to the catalytic site. Here we report the use of femtosecond pulses from an X-ray free electron laser (XFEL) to obtain damage-free, room temperature structures of dark-adapted (S1), two-flash illuminated (2F; S3-enriched), and ammonia-bound two-flash illuminated (2F-NH3; S3-enriched) PS II. Although the recent 1.95 Å resolution structure of PS II at cryogenic temperature using an XFEL provided a damage-free view of the S1 state, measurements at room temperature are required to study the structural landscape of proteins under functional conditions, and also for in situ advancement of the S-states. To investigate the water-binding site(s), ammonia, a water analogue, has been used as a marker, as it binds to the Mn4CaO5 cluster in the S2 and S3 states. Since the ammonia-bound OEC is active, the ammonia-binding Mn site is not a substrate water site. This approach, together with a comparison of the native dark and 2F states, is used to discriminate between proposed O-O bond formation mechanisms.

Characterization of Red/Green Cyanobacteriochrome NpR6012g4 by Solution Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy: A Hydrophobic Pocket for the C15-E,anti Chromophore in the Photoproduct.

Cyanobacteriochromes (CBCRs) are cyanobacterial photosensory proteins distantly related to phytochromes. Like phytochromes, CBCRs reversibly photoconvert between a dark-stable state and a photoproduct via photoisomerization of the 15,16-double bond of their linear tetrapyrrole (bilin) chromophores. CBCRs provide cyanobacteria with complete coverage of the visible spectrum and near-ultraviolet region. One CBCR subfamily, the canonical red/green CBCRs typified by AnPixJg2 and NpR6012g4, can function as sensors of light color or intensity because of their great variation in photoproduct stability. The mechanistic basis for detection of green light by the photoproduct state in this subfamily has proven to be a challenging research topic, with competing hydration and trapped-twist models proposed. Here, we use ¹³C-edited and ¹⁵N-edited ¹H-¹H NOESY solution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy to probe changes in chromophore configuration and protein-chromophore interactions in the NpR6012g4 photocycle. Our results confirm a C15-Z,anti configuration for the red-absorbing dark state and reveal a C15-E,anti configuration for the green-absorbing photoproduct. The photoactive chromophore D-ring is located in a hydrophobic environment in the photoproduct, surrounded by both aliphatic and aromatic residues. Characterization of variant proteins demonstrates that no aliphatic residue is essential for photoproduct tuning. Taken together, our results support the trapped-twist model over the hydration model for the red/green photocycle of NpR6012g4.

Electroretinogram (ERG) Recordings from Drosophila.

Phototransduction is a process in which light is converted into electrical signals used by the central nervous system. Invertebrate phototransduction is a process mediated by the phosphoinositide signaling cascade, characterized by Phospholipase C (PLC) as the effector enzyme and the Transient Receptor Potential (TRP) channels as its target. The great advantage of using invertebrate photoreceptors is the simplicity of the preparation, the ease of light stimulation, the robust expression of key molecular components, and most importantly, the ability to apply the power of molecular genetics. This last feature is mainly attributed to Drosophila melanogaster as a preferred animal model. The Electroretinogram (ERG) is an extracellular voltage recording from the entire eye, which reflects the total electrical activity arising from the retina in response to a light stimulation. The Drosophila ERG light response is robust and easily obtained, thus making it a convenient method to identify defects in the light response as a result of mutations. The Prolonged Depolarizing Afterpotential (PDA) is a useful ERG phenomenon that can be recorded from white-eyed flies following intense blue light. It is induced by a massive photo-conversion of the photopigment rhodopsin to its dark stable state called metarhodopsin, due to failure of light response termination. Unlike the light coincident ERG recording, which declines quickly to the dark baseline after the cessation of the light stimulus, the PDA response continues long (hours) after light offset. However, this response can be suppressed to the dark baseline at any time by photo-conversion of metarhodopsin back to rhodopsin, by application of an intense orange light stimulus (see Figure 7; Minke, 2012). The PDA has been used as an important tool to screen for visual defective mutant (Minke, 2012).

Substrate-water exchange in photosystem II is arrested before dioxygen formation.

Light-driven oxidation of water into dioxygen, catalysed by the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) in photosystem II, is essential for life on Earth and provides the blueprint for devices for producing fuel from sunlight. Although the structure of the OEC is known at atomic level for its dark-stable state, the mechanism by which water is oxidized remains unsettled. Important mechanistic information was gained in the past two decades by mass spectrometric studies of the H218O/H216O substrate–water exchange in the four (semi) stable redox states of the OEC. However, until now such data were not attainable in the transient states formed immediately before the O–O bond formation. Using modified photosystem II complexes displaying up to 40-fold slower O2 production rates, we show here that in the transient state the substrate–water exchange is dramatically slowed as compared with the earlier S states. This further constrains the possible sites for substrate–water binding in photosystem II.

Calcium, Strontium, and Protein Dynamics during the S2 to S3 Transition in the Photosynthetic Oxygen-Evolving Cycle

Photosystem II (PSII) catalyzes the oxidation of water at a Mn4CaO5 cluster. The mechanism of water oxidation requires four sequential photooxidation events and cycles the OEC through the S0–4 states. Oxygen is released during a thermal transition from S4 to S0, and S1 is the dark stable state. Calcium is required for activity, and, of substituted cations, only strontium supports activity but at a lower steady-state rate. The S1 to S2 transition corresponds to a Mn oxidation reaction. Previously, we used divalent ion substitution to provide evidence that calcium activates water and that an internal water cluster (W5+) is protonated during the S1 to S2 transition. For the next transition, S2 to S3, either a Mn or a ligand oxidation event has been proposed. Here, we use strontium reconstitution and reaction-induced FT-IR spectroscopy to study this transition. We show that strontium substitution has a dramatic effect on the infrared spectrum of the S2 to S3 transition, reducing the intensity of all spectral ...

Detection of an intermediary, protonated water cluster in photosynthetic oxygen evolution

In photosynthesis, photosystem II evolves oxygen from water by the accumulation of photooxidizing equivalents at the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC). The OEC is a Mn4CaO5 cluster, and its sequentially oxidized states are termed the Sn states. The dark-stable state is S1, and oxygen is released during the transition from S3 to S0. In this study, a laser flash induces the S1 to S2 transition, which corresponds to the oxidation of Mn(III) to Mn(IV). A broad infrared band, at 2,880 cm(-1), is produced during this transition. Experiments using ammonia and (2)H2O assign this band to a cationic cluster of internal water molecules, termed "W5(+)." Observation of the W5(+) band is dependent on the presence of calcium, and flash dependence is observed. These data provide evidence that manganese oxidation during the S1 to S2 transition results in a coupled proton transfer to a substrate-containing, internal water cluster in the OEC hydrogen-bonded network.

A hydrogen-bonding network plays a catalytic role in photosynthetic oxygen evolution

In photosystem II, oxygen evolution occurs by the accumulation of photo-induced oxidizing equivalents at the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC). The sequentially oxidized states are called the S(0)-S(4) states, and the dark stable state is S(1). Hydrogen bonds to water form a network around the OEC; this network is predicted to involve multiple peptide carbonyl groups. In this work, we tested the idea that a network of hydrogen bonded water molecules plays a catalytic role in water oxidation. As probes, we used OEC peptide carbonyl frequencies, the substrate-based inhibitor, ammonia, and the sugar, trehalose. Reaction-induced FT-IR spectroscopy was used to describe the protein dynamics associated with the S(1) to S(2) transition. A shift in an amide CO vibrational frequency (1664 (S(1)) to 1653 (S(2)) cm(-1)) was observed, consistent with an increase in hydrogen bond strength when the OEC is oxidized. Treatment with ammonia/ammonium altered these CO vibrational frequencies. The ammonia-induced spectral changes are attributed to alterations in hydrogen bonding, when ammonia/ammonium is incorporated into the OEC hydrogen bond network. The ammonia-induced changes in CO frequency were reversed or blocked when trehalose was substituted for sucrose. This trehalose effect is attributed to a displacement of ammonia molecules from the hydrogen bond network. These results imply that ammonia, and by extension water, participate in a catalytically essential hydrogen bond network, which involves OEC peptide CO groups. Comparison to the ammonia transporter, AmtB, reveals structural similarities with the bound water network in the OEC.

Rapid Loss of Structural Motifs in the Manganese Complex of Oxygenic Photosynthesis by X-ray Irradiation at 10–300 K

Structural changes upon photoreduction caused by x-ray irradiation of the water-oxidizing tetramanganese complex of photosystem II were investigated by x-ray absorption spectroscopy at the manganese K-edge. Photoreduction was directly proportional to the x-ray dose. It was faster in the higher oxidized S2 state than in S1; seemingly the oxidizing potential of the metal site governs the rate. X-ray irradiation of the S1 state at 15 K initially caused single-electron reduction to S0* accompanied by the conversion of one di-mu-oxo bridge between manganese atoms, previously separated by approximately 2.7 A, to a mono-mu-oxo motif. Thereafter, manganese photoreduction was 100 times slower, and the biphasic increase in its rate between 10 and 300 K with a breakpoint at approximately 200 K suggests that protein dynamics is rate-limiting the radical chemistry. For photoreduction at similar x-ray doses as applied in protein crystallography, halfway to the final Mn(II)4 state the complete loss of inter-manganese distances <3 A was observed, even at 10 K, because of the destruction of mu-oxo bridges between manganese ions. These results put into question some structural attributions from recent protein crystallography data on photosystem II. It is proposed to employ controlled x-ray photoreduction in metalloprotein research for: (i) population of distinct reduced states, (ii) estimating the redox potential of buried metal centers, and (iii) research on protein dynamics.

The S0 State of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex in Photosystem II Is Paramagnetic: Detection of an EPR Multiline Signal.

The S0 State of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex in Photosystem II Is Paramagnetic: Detection of an EPR Multiline Signal.