Cytochrome P450 monooxygenases of the CYP79 family catalyze conversion of specific amino acids into oximes feeding into a variety of metabolic plant pathways. Here we present an extensive phylogenetic tree of the CYP79 family built on carefully curated sequences collected across the entire plant kingdom. Based on a monophyletic origin of the P450s, a set of evolutionarily distinct branches was identified. Founded on the functionally characterized CYP79 sequences, sequence features of the individual substrate recognition sites (SRSs) were analyzed. Co-evolving amino acid residues were identified using co-evolutionary sequence analysis. SRS4 possesses a specific sequence pattern when tyrosine is a substrate. Except for the CYP79Cs and CYP79Fs, substrate preferences toward specific amino acids could not be assigned to specific subfamilies. The highly diversified CYP79 tree, reflecting recurrent independent evolution of CYP79s, may relate to the different roles of oximes in different plant species. The sequence differences across individual CYP79 subfamilies may facilitate the in vivo orchestration of channeled metabolic pathways based on altered surface charge domains of the CYP79 protein. Alternatively, they may serve to optimize dynamic interactions with oxime metabolizing enzymes to enable optimal ecological interactions. The outlined detailed curation of the CYP79 sequences used for building the phylogenetic tree made it appropriate to make a conservative phylogenetic tree-based revision of the naming of the sequences within this highly complex cytochrome P450 family. The same approach may be used in other complex P450 subfamilies. The detailed phylogeny of the CYP79 family will enable further exploration of the evolution of function in these enzymes.