Cumulant Ratios Research Articles

Cumulants of net-proton, net-kaon, and net-charge multiplicity distributions in Au + Au collisions atsNN=7.7, 11.5, 19.6, 27, 39, 62.4, and 200 GeV within the UrQMD model

Fluctuations of conserved quantities are sensitive observables to probe the signature of QCD phase transition and critical point in heavy-ion collisions. With the UrQMD model, we have studied the centrality and energy dependence of various order cumulants and cumulant ratios (up to fourth order) of net-proton,net-charge and net-kaon multiplicity distributions in Au+Au collisions at $\sqrt{s_{NN}}$= 7.7, 11.5, 19.6, 27, 39, 62.4, 200 GeV. The model results show that the production mechanism of the particles and anti-particles have significant impacts on the cumulants of net-particles multiplicity distributions and show strong energy dependence. We also made comparisons between model calculations and experimental data measured in the first phase of the beam energy scan (BES) program by the STAR experiment at RHIC. The comparisons indicate that the baryon conservation effect strongly suppress the cumulants of net-proton distributions at low energies and the non-monotonic energy dependence for the net-proton {\KV} at the most central Au+Au collisions measured by the STAR experiment can not be described by the UrQMD model. Since there has no physics of QCD phase transition and QCD critical point implemented in the UrQMD, the model results provide us baselines and qualitative estimates about the non-critical background contributions to the fluctuations observables in heavy-ion collisions.

Scaling, cumulant ratios, and height distribution of ballistic deposition in 3+1 and 4+1 dimensions.

We investigate the origin of the scaling corrections in ballistic deposition models in high dimensions using the method proposed by Alves et al. [Phys. Rev. E 90, 052405 (2014)PLEEE81539-375510.1103/PhysRevE.90.052405] in d=2+1 dimensions, where the intrinsic width associated with the fluctuations of the height increments during the deposition processes is explicitly taken into account. In the present work, we show that this concept holds for d=3+1 and 4+1 dimensions. We have found that growth and roughness exponents and dimensionless cumulant ratios are in agreement with other models, presenting small finite-time corrections to the scaling, that in principle belong to the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang (KPZ) universality class in both d=3+1 and 4+1. Our results constitute further evidence that the upper critical dimension of the KPZ class, if it exists, is larger than 4.

Acceptance dependence of fluctuation measures near the QCD critical point

We argue that a crucial determinant of the acceptance dependence of fluctuation measures in heavy-ion collisions is the range of correlations in the momentum space, e.g., in rapidity, $\Delta y_{\rm corr}$. The value of $\Delta y_{\rm corr}\sim1$ for critical thermal fluctuations is determined by the thermal rapidity spread of the particles at freezeout, and has little to do with position space correlations, even near the critical point where the spatial correlation length $\xi$ becomes as large as $2-3$ fm (this is in contrast to the magnitudes of the cumulants, which are sensitive to $\xi$). When the acceptance window is large, $\Delta y\gg\Delta y_{\rm corr}$, the cumulants of a given particle multiplicity, $\kappa_k$, scale linearly with $\Delta y$, or mean multiplicity in acceptance, $\langle N\rangle$, and cumulant ratios are acceptance independent. While in the opposite regime, $\Delta y\ll\Delta y_{\rm corr}$, the factorial cumulants, $\hat\kappa_k$, scale as $(\Delta y)^k$, or $\langle N\rangle^k$. We demonstrate this general behavior quantitatively in a model for critical point fluctuations, which also shows that the dependence on transverse momentum acceptance is very significant. We conclude that extension of rapidity coverage proposed by STAR should significantly increase the magnitude of the critical point fluctuation signatures.

Multiplicity fluctuations in heavy-ion collisions using canonical and grand-canonical ensemble

We report the higher order cumulants and their ratios for baryon, charge and strangeness multiplicity in canonical and grand-canonical ensembles in ideal thermal model including all the resonances. When the number of conserved quanta is small, an explicit treatment of these conserved charges is required, which leads to a canonical description of the system and the fluctuations are significantly different from the grand canonical ensemble. Cumulant ratios of total charge and net-charge multiplicity as a function of collision energies are also compared in grand canonical ensemble.

Measurement of higher cumulants of net-charge multiplicity distributions inAu+Aucollisions atsNN=7.7–200GeV

We report the measurement of cumulants ($C_n, n=1\ldots4$) of the net-charge distributions measured within pseudorapidity ($|\eta|<0.35$) in Au$+$Au collisions at $\sqrt{s_{_{NN}}}=7.7-200$ GeV with the PHENIX experiment at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider. The ratios of cumulants (e.g. $C_1/C_2$, $C_3/C_1$) of the net-charge distributions, which can be related to volume independent susceptibility ratios, are studied as a function of centrality and energy. These quantities are important to understand the quantum-chromodynamics phase diagram and possible existence of a critical end point. The measured values are very well described by expectation from negative binomial distributions. We do not observe any nonmonotonic behavior in the ratios of the cumulants as a function of collision energy. The measured values of $C_1/C_2 = \mu/\sigma^2$ and $C_3/C_1 = S\sigma^3/\mu$ can be directly compared to lattice quantum-chromodynamics calculations and thus allow extraction of both the chemical freeze-out temperature and the baryon chemical potential at each center-of-mass energy.

Width and extremal height distributions of fluctuating interfaces with window boundary conditions.

We present a detailed study of squared local roughness (SLRDs) and local extremal height distributions (LEHDs), calculated in windows of lateral size l, for interfaces in several universality classes, in substrate dimensions d_{s}=1 and 2. We show that their cumulants follow a Family-Vicsek-type scaling, and, at early times, when ξ≪l (ξ is the correlation length), the rescaled SLRDs are given by log-normal distributions, with their nth cumulant scaling as (ξ/l)^{(n-1)d_{s}}. This gives rise to an interesting temporal scaling for such cumulants as 〈w_{n}〉_{c}∼t^{γ_{n}}, with γ_{n}=2nβ+(n-1)d_{s}/z=[2n+(n-1)d_{s}/α]β. This scaling is analytically proved for the Edwards-Wilkinson (EW) and random deposition interfaces and numerically confirmed for other classes. In general, it is featured by small corrections, and, thus, it yields exponents γ_{n} (and, consequently, α,β and z) in good agreement with their respective universality class. Thus, it is a useful framework for numerical and experimental investigations, where it is usually hard to estimate the dynamic z and mainly the (global) roughness α exponents. The stationary (for ξ≫l) SLRDs and LEHDs of the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang (KPZ) class are also investigated, and, for some models, strong finite-size corrections are found. However, we demonstrate that good evidence of their universality can be obtained through successive extrapolations of their cumulant ratios for long times and large l. We also show that SLRDs and LEHDs are the same for flat and curved KPZ interfaces.

Net-baryon number fluctuations across the chiral phase transition at finite density in strong-coupling lattice QCD

We investigate the net-baryon number fluctuations across the chiral phase transition at finite density in the strong coupling and chiral limit. Mesonic field fluctuations are taken into account by using the auxiliary field Monte-Carlo method. We find that the higher-order cumulant ratios, $S\sigma$ and $\kappa\sigma^2$, show oscillatory behavior around the phase boundary at $\mu/T\gtrsim 0.2$, and there exists the region where the higher-order cumulant ratios are negative. The negative region of $\kappa\sigma^2$ is found to shrink with increasing lattice size. This behavior agrees with the expectations from the scaling analysis.

Non-Gaussianities in the topological charge distribution of the SU(3) Yang-Mills theory

We study the topological charge distribution of the SU(3) Yang--Mills theory with high precision in order to be able to detect deviations from Gaussianity. The computation is carried out on the lattice with high statistics Monte Carlo simulations by implementing a naive discretization of the topological charge evolved with the Yang--Mills gradient flow. This definition is far less demanding than the one suggested from Neuberger's fermions and, as shown in this paper, in the continuum limit its cumulants coincide with those of the universal definition appearing in the chiral Ward identities. Thanks to the range of lattice volumes and spacings considered, we can extrapolate the results for the second and fourth cumulant of the topological charge distribution to the continuum limit with confidence by keeping finite volume effects negligible with respect to the statistical errors. Our best results for the topological susceptibility is t_0^2*chi=6.67(7)*10^-4, where t_0 is a standard reference scale, while for the ratio of the forth cumulant over the second we obtain R=0.233(45). The latter is compatible with the expectations from the large Nc expansion, while it rules out the theta-behavior of the vacuum energy predicted by the dilute instanton model. Its large distance from 1 implies that, in the ensemble of gauge configurations that dominate the path integral, the fluctuations of the topological charge are of quantum non-perturbative nature.

Recent results from high temperature lattice QCD

Recent results obtained from numerical computations in lattice regularized QCD are summarized. The write-up of the talk concentrates on the liberation of strange quarks in the vicinity of the chiral QCD transition and on certain ratios of cumulants of net electric charge fluctuations which can be used to determine freeze-out parameters by a comparison of experimental data from heavy ion collisions with lattice QCD results.

Finite-volume cumulant expansion in QCD-colorless plasma

Due to the finite size effects, the localisation of the phase transition in finite systems and the determination of its order, become an extremely difficult task, even in the simplest known cases. In order to identify and locate the finite volume transition point $T_{0}(V)$ of the QCD deconfinement phase transition to a Colorless QGP, we have developed a new approach using the finite size cumulant expansion of the order parameter and the $L_{mn}$-method. The first six cumulants $C_{1,2,3,4,5,6}$ with the corresponding under-normalized ratios(skewness $\Sigma$, kurtosis $\kappa$ ,pentosis $\Pi_{\pm}$ and hexosis $\mathcal{H}_{1,2,3}$) and three unnormalized combinations of them ($\mathcal{O}={\mathcal{\sigma }^{2} \mathcal{\kappa } }{\mathbf{\Sigma }^{-1} }$, $\mathcal{U} ={\mathcal{\sigma }^{-2} \mathbf{\Sigma }^{-1} }$, $\mathcal{N} = \mathcal{\sigma }^{2} \mathcal{\kappa }$) are calculated and studied as functions of $(T,V)$. A new approach, unifying in a clear and consistent way the definitions of cumulant ratios, is proposed. A numerical FSS analysis of the obtained results has allowed us to locate accurately the finite volume transition point. The extracted transition temperature value $T_{0}(V)$ agrees with that expected $T_{0}^{N}(V)$ from the order parameter and the thermal susceptibility $\chi _{T}\left( T,V\right)$, according to the standard procedure of localization to within about $2\%$. In addition to this, a very good correlation factor is obtained proving the validity of our cumulants method. The agreement of our results with those obtained by means of other models is remarkable.

Higher order fluctuations of strangeness and flavour hierarchy

We present a preliminary analysis on the sensitivity to the chemical freeze-out temperature of higher order moments of strange particle multiplicity distributions in heavy ion collisions. Within the Hadron Resonance Gas (HRG) model we evaluate ratios of cumulants for kaons (K±) and hyperons (Λ, Σ±, Ξ−,0, Ω−) as a function of the temperature and compare them to the sensitivity profiles obtained from ratios of particle yields. We show that ratios of higher order fluctuations of strange baryons could provide a useful tool to extract the range of freeze-out temperature, once experimental data are available. Finally, a connection to lattice data through the fourth to second cumulant ratio is made. The deconfinement transition on the lattice seems to indicate the possibility of a flavour hierarchy, namely strange quarks seem to deconfine at a higher temperature. We would like to test the possibility for the same scenario to occur at the chemical freeze-out and we show how the inclusion of multi-strange baryons in the evaluation of higher order cumulants might provide a sensitive observable to extract the freeze-out temperature.

The melting and abundance of open charm hadrons

Ratios of cumulants of conserved net charge fluctuations are sensitive to the degrees of freedom that are carriers of the corresponding quantum numbers in different phases of strong interaction matter. Using lattice QCD with 2+1 dynamical flavors and quenched charm quarks we calculate second and fourth order cumulants of net charm fluctuations and their correlations with other conserved charges such as net baryon number, electric charge and strangeness. Analyzing appropriate ratios of these cumulants we probe the nature of charmed degrees of freedom in the vicinity of the QCD chiral crossover region. We show that for temperatures above the chiral crossover transition temperature, charmed degrees of freedom can no longer be described by an uncorrelated gas of hadrons. This suggests that the dissociation of open charm hadrons and the emergence of deconfined charm states sets in just near the chiral crossover transition. Till the crossover region we compare these lattice QCD results with two hadron resonance gas models—including only the experimentally established charmed resonances and also including additional states predicted by quark model and lattice QCD calculations. This comparison provides evidence for so far unobserved charmed hadrons that contribute to the thermodynamics in the crossover region.

Cumulants in the 3-dimensional Ising, O(2) and O(4) spin models

Based on the universal properties of a critical point in different systems and that the QCD phase transitions fall into the same universality classes as the 3-dimensional Ising, O(2) or O(4) spin models, the critical behavior of cumulants and higher cumulant ratios of the order parameter from the three kinds of spin models is studied. We found that all higher cumulant ratios change dramatically the sign near the critical temperature. The qualitative critical behavior of the same order cumulant ratio is consistent in these three models.

Volume fluctuations and higher-order cumulants of the net baryon number

We consider the effect of volume fluctuations on cumulants of the net baryon number. Based on a general formalism, we derive universal expressions for the net baryon number cumulants in the presence of volume fluctuations with an arbitrary probability distribution. The relevance of these fluctuations for the baryon-number cumulants and in particular for the ratios of cumulants is assessed in the Polyakov loop extended quark-meson model within the functional renormalization group. We show that the baryon number cumulants are generally enhanced by volume fluctuations and that the critical behavior of higher-order cumulants may be modified significantly.

The Sixth-Order Cumulants of Net-proton Multiplicity Distributions Measured in STAR at RHIC

Abstract The ratios of different-order cumulants of conserved quantities have become important observables for probing the Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) phase diagram, due to their sensitivity to the correlation length of the system near the phase transition. It has been predicted that a sixth-order cumulant may change its sign if the freeze-out curve is close to the phase transition temperature. In this paper, preliminary results are presented on the ratios of sixth-order to second-order cumulants ( C 6 / C 2 ) of the net-proton multiplicity distributions at mid-rapidity ( | y | 0.5 ) measured in Au + Au collisions at s N N = 7.7 , 11.5 , 19.6 , 27 , 39 , 62.4 and 200 GeV .

Higher moments of net-proton multiplicity distributions in heavy ion collisions at chemical freeze-out

The first four cumulants and ratios of cumulants of net-proton multiplicity distributions are calculated within the hadron resonance gas model. Quantum statistics, resonance decay contributions and the van der Waals excluded volume corrections are taken into account in the model calculations. The corrections due to quantum statistics are small even at the lower RHIC energies. The van der Waals excluded volume procedure leads to a larger suppression of the particle number fluctuations, especially for higher order cumulants. The STAR most central data on the various order cumulants and moment products at the higher RHIC energies are generally below the Poisson expectations and better described by the van der Waals gas with a hadron radius around r=0.3fm.

Finite-size behaviour of a critical related observable

Abstract Accounting for the influence of system size in relativistic heavy ion collisions, the finite-size form of a critical related observable is suggested. The fixed-point and straight line methods are proposed in exploring the QCD critical point and phase boundary in relativistic heavy ion collisions. As an application, the finitesize behaviour of the ratios of higher net-proton cumulants, dynamical electric charge fluctuations, and transverse momentum correlations in Au + Au collisions at RHIC are examined.

Freeze-Out Conditions in Heavy Ion Collisions from QCD Thermodynamics

We present a determination of freeze-out conditions in heavy ion collisions based on ratios of cumulants of net electric charge fluctuations. These ratios can reliably be calculated in lattice QCD for a wide range of chemical potential values by using a next-to-leading order Taylor series expansion around the limit of vanishing baryon, electric charge and strangeness chemical potentials. From a computation of up to fourth order cumulants and charge correlations we first determine the strangeness and electric charge chemical potentials that characterize freeze-out conditions in a heavy ion collision and confirm that in the temperature range 150 MeV ≤ T ≤ 170 MeV the hadron resonance gas model provides good approximations for these parameters that agree with QCD calculations on the 5%-15% level. We then show that a comparison of lattice QCD results for ratios of up to third order cumulants of electric charge fluctuations with experimental results allows us to extract the freeze-out baryon chemical potential and the freeze-out temperature.

Acceptance corrections to net baryon and net charge cumulants

We show that the effect of finite acceptance drastically influences the net-baryon and net-charge cumulants, which are believed to be sensitive probes of the QCD phase diagram. We derive general formulas that relate the true cumulants ${K}_{n}$ which reflect the full dynamics of the system with the actually measured cumulants ${c}_{n}$ for a given acceptance, modeled by a binomial probability parameter $p$. We find that this relation involves additional moments which cannot be expressed by cumulants and should be measured in order to extract any potential information about the QCD critical point. We demonstrate that for a wide range of the true cumulant ratios ${K}_{n}/{K}_{m}$ the measured ratios ${c}_{n}/{c}_{m}$ quickly converge if $p&lt;1/2$, which makes the interpretation of the data very challenging, especially in case of the net-proton cumulants. Our study further suggests that the measurement of net-charge cumulants may be more advantageous for the investigation of the QCD phase diagram.

Critical behavior of higher cumulants of order parameter in the 3D-Ising universality class

QCD deconfinement phase transition is supposed to be the same universality class as the 3D-Ising model. According to the universality of critical behavior, the Binder-like ratios and ratios of higher cumulants of order parameter near the critical temperature in the 3D-Ising model are studied. The Binder-like ratio is shown to be a step function of temperature. The critical point is the intersection of the ratios of different system sizes between two platforms. The normalized cumulant ratios, like the Skewness and Kurtosis, do not diverge with correlation length, contrary to the corresponding cumulants. Possible applications of these characters in locating critical point in relativistic heavy ion collisions are discussed.