The article analyses software tools for simulation of electric field of insulators. The necessity of solving this problem is dictated by the fact that inaccuracy of simulation software allows stating that the simulation model cannot be improved correctly due to calculation errors in the program itself. Design features of different types of insulators, first of all, the most widespread and used - porcelain and glass insulators, are considered. The change of electric field in a glass and porcelain insulator operating in an AC network without contamination is described. Numerous calculation methods such as boundary element method, finite element method, integral equation method and others have been analysed. It is revealed, that from the point of view of functionality and expediency of application for solution of field problems relevant to electric power industry the finite difference method and finite element method are the most universal ones. The results of insulator electric field modelling using Ansoft Maxwell, CST EM Studio and Elcut software are given. Among Ansys, FEMLAB, Ansoft Maxwell, CST EM Studio, IES Coulomb and Elcut that were analyzed, the software Ansoft Maxwell and CST EM, where the finite element method is implemented, were chosen to solve the given problem. It was found out, which one of the software complies better with the given requirements as to accuracy (by calculation of error of deviation of mathematical modelling and experimental data) and in terms of the method incorporated in the algorithms of the software. Experimental data are compared with simulation results. The possibility of diagnosing insulators by electric field tension parameters has been revealed.
Read full abstract