The swelling of clay minerals within shale formations during oil and gas exploration, and within compacted bentonite barriers for radioactive waste containment, presents a number of challenges to operators. Whilst much work has been devoted to understanding the interlayer swelling properties of clay mineral crystals, significantly less has been devoted to understanding coupled pore and interlayer swelling in reactive shale/compacted clay minerals. Here we study the swelling of compacted clay mineral tablets on exposure to a range of organic solvents, selected so that the effect of key solvent properties such as dielectric constant, density, octanol-water partition coefficient, viscosity and surface tension can be correlated with the swelling observed. We use a novel non-contact swelling meter to carry out the swelling tests, allowing us to access information on rate of swelling. Short-term swelling rate showed the strongest correlation to the solvent octanol-water partition coefficient. In long term swelling, good correlation was found between total linear swelling and viscosity, and the octanol-water partition coefficient.