Membrane Protein Crystallization Research Articles

An automated platform for structural analysis of membrane proteins through serial crystallography

SummaryMembrane proteins are central to many pathophysiological processes, yet remain very difficult to analyze structurally. Moreover, high-throughput structure-based drug discovery has not yet been exploited for membrane proteins because of lack of automation. Here, we present a facile and versatile platform for in meso membrane protein crystallization, enabling rapid atomic structure determination at both cryogenic and room temperatures. We apply this approach to human integral membrane proteins, which allowed us to identify different conformational states of intramembrane enzyme-product complexes and analyze by molecular dynamics simulations the structural dynamics of the ADIPOR2 integral membrane protein. Finally, we demonstrate an automated pipeline combining high-throughput microcrystal soaking, automated laser-based harvesting, and serial crystallography, enabling screening of small-molecule libraries with membrane protein crystals grown in meso. This approach brings needed automation to this important class of drug targets and enables high-throughput structure-based ligand discovery with membrane proteins.

Glucose-Based Fluorinated Surfactants as Additives for the Crystallization of Membrane Proteins: Synthesis and Preliminary Physical-Chemical and Biochemical Characterization.

We report herein the synthesis of a series of fluorinated surfactants with a glucose moiety as a polar head group and whose alkyl chain was varied in length and in fluorine/hydrogen ratio. They were synthesized in two or four steps in 20 to 50% overall yields allowing gram-scale synthesis. Their solubility in water is between 0.2 and 13.8 g/L, which indicates low water solubility. Two derivatives of the series were found to form micelles in water at ∼11 mM. Their hydrophilic–lipophilic balance was determined both by Griffin’s and Davies’ methods; they may exhibit a “harsh” character toward membrane proteins. This, combined with their low water solubility, suggest that they could advantageously be used in detergent mixtures containing a “mild” detergent. Finally, the potency of one of the derivatives, F3H5-β-Glu, to act as an additive for the crystallization of AcrB was evaluated in detergent mixtures with n-dodecyl-β-d-maltopyranoside (DDM). Among the six crystallization conditions investigated, adding F3H5-β-Glu improved the crystallization for three of them, as compared to control drops without additives. Moreover, preliminary tests with other compounds of the series showed that none of them hampered crystallization and suggested improvement for three of them. These novel glucose-based fluorinated detergents should be regarded as potential additives that could be included in screening kits used in crystallization.

Maltose-bis(hydroxymethyl)phenol (MBPs) and Maltose-tris(hydroxymethyl)phenol (MTPs) Amphiphiles for Membrane Protein Stability.

Membrane protein structures provide a fundamental understanding of their molecular actions and are of importance for drug development. Detergents are widely used to solubilize, stabilize, and crystallize membrane proteins, but membrane proteins solubilized in conventional detergents are prone to denaturation and aggregation. Thus, developing novel detergents with enhanced efficacy for protein stabilization remains important. We report herein the design and synthesis of a class of phenol-derived maltoside detergents. Using two different linkers, we prepared two sets of new detergents, designated maltose-bis(hydroxymethyl)phenol (MBPs) and maltose-tris(hydroxymethyl)phenol (MTPs). The evaluation of these detergents with three transporters and two G-protein coupled receptors allowed us to identify a couple of new detergents (MBP-C9 and MTP-C12) that consistently conferred enhanced stability to all tested proteins compared to a gold standard detergent (DDM). Furthermore, the data analysis based on the detergent structures provides key detergent features responsible for membrane protein stabilization that together will facilitate the future design of novel detergents.

Stability of cubic phase and curvature tuning in the lyotropic system of branched chain galactose-based glycolipid by amphiphilic additives

Inverse bicontinuous cubic phases are among the most suitable nanostructures used as carriers of drugs, diagnostic agents, and as templates for crystallization of membrane protein. The versatility of their highly ordered internal nanostructures with large interfacial areas make them capable to accommodate hydrophobic, hydrophilic or amphiphilic guest molecules and specifically active pharmaceutical ingredients. Previous studies have shown that pure sugar-based lipid namely 2-hexyl-decyl α-D-galactopyranoside (α-Gal-OC10C6) self-assemble into bicontinuous cubic phases of gyroid type (Ia3d) at low water content and of the diamond type (Pn3m) in excess water. Herein, we report the effects of loading of the different types of amphiphilic additives (non-ionic and ionic surfactants) on the fully hydrated Pn3m phase of α-Gal-OC10C6 lipid. Moreover, the effect of adding cholesterol, a membrane stiffening agent on the lipidic cubic system was also inspected. The influence of these additives and their concentrations on the ternary α-Gal-OC10C6/additive/water system has been investigated using small angle X-ray scattering at 25 °C. The comparison of these observations in relation to the phase behavior, structural properties, and interfacial curvature are discussed. In general, addition of increasing amounts of the non-ionic and ionic additives promote phase transitions towards less negatively curved phases than the Pn3m phase in the resultant ternary mixture. On the contrary, the cholesterol induces phase transformations towards the highly negatively curved phases. This study contributes to a better understanding into the effects of additives on the lyotropic cubic phase-forming lipid and its curvature tunability useful for designer delivery system.

DNA-Mediated Stack Formation of Nanodiscs.

Membrane-scaffolding proteins (MSPs) derived from apolipoprotein A-1 have become a versatile tool in generating nano-sized discoidal membrane mimetics (nanodiscs) for membrane protein research. Recent efforts have aimed at exploiting their controlled lipid protein ratio and size distribution to arrange membrane proteins in regular supramolecular structures for diffraction studies. Thereby, direct membrane protein crystallization, which has remained the limiting factor in structure determination of membrane proteins, would be circumvented. We describe here the formation of multimers of membrane-scaffolding protein MSP1D1-bounded nanodiscs using the thiol reactivity of engineered cysteines. The mutated positions N42 and K163 in MSP1D1 were chosen to support chemical modification as evidenced by fluorescent labeling with pyrene. Minimal interference with the nanodisc formation and structure was demonstrated by circular dichroism spectroscopy, differential light scattering and size exclusion chromatography. The direct disulphide bond formation of nanodiscs formed by the MSP1D1_N42C variant led to dimers and trimers with low yield. In contrast, transmission electron microscopy revealed that the attachment of oligonucleotides to the engineered cysteines of MSP1D1 allowed the growth of submicron-sized tracts of stacked nanodiscs through the hybridization of nanodisc populations carrying complementary strands and a flexible spacer.

A day in the life of a biopharmaceutical senior scientist

Dr Jana Broecker is a senior scientist in the Biochemistry Department at Sosei Heptares in the UK, where she is part of a team that develops small-molecule therapeutics using protein structural information. Jana graduated as a Diploma Engineer from the Technical University Berlin (Germany) and did her PhD with the University of Kaiserslautern on the biophysical quantification of membrane-protein stability. She also completed post-doctoral research at the University of Toronto (Canada), where she spearheaded the optimization of membrane-protein crystallization using polymer-bound lipid nanodiscs and where she also developed a method that avoids crystal harvesting.

Studying Membrane Protein Structures by MicroED.

Microcrystal electron diffraction (MicroED) enables atomic resolution structures to be determined from vanishingly small crystals. Soluble proteins typically grow crystals that are tens to hundreds of microns in size for X-ray crystallography. But membrane protein crystals often grow crystals that are too small for X-ray diffraction and yet too large for MicroED. These crystals are often formed in thick, viscous media that challenge traditional cryoEM grid preparation. Here, we describe two approaches for preparing membrane protein crystals for MicroED data collection: application of a crystal slurry directly to EM grids, and focused ion beam milling in a Scanning Electron Microscope (FIB-SEM). We summarize the case of preparing an ion channel, NaK, and the workflow of focused ion-beam milling. By milling away the excess media and crystalline material, crystals of any size may be prepared for MicroED. Finally, an energy filter may be used to help minimize inelastic scattering leading to lower noise on recorded images.

Direct localization of detergents and bacteriorhodopsin in the lipidic cubic phase by small-angle neutron scattering.

Lipidic cubic phase (LCP) crystallization methods have been essential in obtaining crystals of certain membrane proteins, particularly G-protein-coupled receptors. LCP crystallization is generally optimized across a large number of potential variables, one of which may be the choice of the solubilizing detergent. A better fundamental understanding of the behavior of detergents in the LCP may guide and simplify the detergent selection process. This work investigates the distribution of protein and detergent in LCP using the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin (bR), with the LCP prepared from highly deuterated monoolein to allow contrast-matched small-angle neutron scattering. Contrast-matching allows the scattering from the LCP bilayer itself to be suppressed, so that the distribution and behavior of the protein and detergent can be directly studied. The results showed that, for several common detergents, the detergent micelle dissociates and incorporates into the LCP bilayer essentially as free detergent monomers. In addition, the detergent octyl glucoside dissociates from bR, and neither the protein nor detergent forms clusters in the LCP. The lack of detergent assemblies in the LCP implies that, upon incorporation, micelle sizes and protein/detergent interactions become less important than they would be in solution crystallization. Crystallization screening confirmed this idea, with crystals obtained from bR in the presence of most detergents tested. Thus, in LCP crystallization, detergents can be selected primarily on the basis of protein stabilization in solution, with crystallization suitability a lesser consideration.

Helical Membrane Protein Crystallization in the New Era of Electron Cryo-Microscopy.

Helical assemblies of proteins, which consist of a two-dimensional lattice of identical subunits arranged with helical symmetry, are a common structural motif in nature. For membrane proteins, crystallization protocols can induce helical arrangements and take advantage of the symmetry found in these assemblies for the structural determination of target proteins. Modern advances in the field of electron cryo-microscopy (cryo-EM), in particular the advent of direct electron detectors, have opened the potential for structure determination of membrane proteins in such assemblies at high resolution. The nature of the symmetry in helical crystals of membrane proteins means that a single image potentially contains enough information for three-dimensional structural determination. With the current direct electron detectors, we have never been closer to making this a reality. Here, we present a protocol detailing the preparation of helical crystals, with an emphasis on further cryo-EM analysis and structural determination of the sarco(endo)plasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase in the presence of regulatory subunits such as phospholamban.

A fully automated crystallization apparatus for small protein quantities.

In 2003, a fully automated protein crystallization and monitoring system (PXS) was developed to support the structural genomics projects that were initiated in the early 2000s. In PXS, crystallization plates were automatically set up using the vapor-diffusion method, transferred to incubators and automatically observed according to a pre-set schedule. The captured images of each crystallization drop could be monitored through the internet using a web browser. While the screening throughput of PXS was very high, the demands of users have gradually changed over the ensuing years. To study difficult proteins, it has become important to screen crystallization conditions using small amounts of proteins. Moreover, membrane proteins have become one of the main targets for X-ray crystallography. Therefore, to meet the evolving demands of users, PXS was upgraded to PXS2. In PXS2, the minimum volume of the dispenser is reduced to 0.1 µl to minimize the amount of sample, and the resolution of the captured images is increased to five million pixels in order to observe small crystallization drops in detail. In addition to the 20°C incubators, a 4°C incubator was installed in PXS2 because crystallization results may vary with temperature. To support membrane-protein crystallization, PXS2 includes a procedure for the bicelle method. In addition, the system supports a lipidic cubic phase (LCP) method that uses a film sandwich plate and that was specifically designed for PXS2. These improvements expand the applicability of PXS2, reducing the bottleneck of X-ray protein crystallography.

A guide to membrane protein X-ray crystallography.

Membrane proteins play critical physiological roles in all organisms, from ion transport and signal transduction to multidrug resistance. Elucidating their 3D structures is essential for understanding their functions, and this information can also be exploited for structure-aided drug discovery efforts. In this regard, X-ray crystallography has been the most widely used technique for determining the high-resolution 3D structures of membrane proteins. However, the success of this technique is dependent on efficient protein extraction, solubilization, stabilization, and generating diffracting crystals. Each of these steps can impose great challenges for membrane protein crystallographers. In this review, the process of generating membrane protein crystals from protein extraction and solubilization to structure determination is discussed. In addition, the current methods for precrystallization screening and a few strategies to increase the chance of crystallizing challenging membrane proteins are introduced.

2D Electron Crystallography of Membrane Protein Single-, Double-, and Multi-Layered Ordered Arrays.

The electron cryo-microscopy (cryo-EM) approach of 2D electron crystallography allows for structure determination of two-dimensional (2D) crystals of soluble and membrane proteins, employing identical principles and methods once 2D crystals are obtained. Two-dimensional crystallization trials of membrane proteins can result in multiple outcomes of ordered arrays, which may be suited for either 2D electron crystallography, helical analysis, or MicroED.The membrane protein 2D crystals used for 2D electron crystallography are either single- or double-layered ordered proteoliposome vesicles or sheet-like membranes. We have developed a cryo-EM grid preparation approach, which allows for the analysis of stacked 2D crystals that are neither suitable for MicroED nor for directly applying 2D electron crystallography. This new grid preparation approach, the peel-blot, uses the capillary force generated by submicron filter paper and mechanical means for the separation of stacked 2D crystals into single-layered 2D crystals, for which standard 2D electron crystallography can then be employed. The preparation of 2D crystals, the peel-blot grid preparation, and the structure determination by 2D electron crystallography are described here.

9.8 MAG: A New Host Lipid for In Meso (Lipid Cubic Phase) Crystallization of Integral Membrane Proteins

Monoolein, also referred to as 9.9 MAG, is the most commonly used monoacylglycerol for crystallizing membrane proteins by the in meso method. However, 9.9 MAG does not work for all proteins. Theref...

Isoprenoid-chained lipid EROCOC17+4: a new matrix for membrane protein crystallization and a crystal delivery medium in serial femtosecond crystallography

In meso crystallization of membrane proteins relies on the use of lipids capable of forming a lipidic cubic phase (LCP). However, almost all previous crystallization trials have used monoacylglycerols, with 1-(cis-9-octadecanoyl)-rac-glycerol (MO) being the most widely used lipid. We now report that EROCOC17+4 mixed with 10% (w/w) cholesterol (Fig. 1) serves as a new matrix for crystallization and a crystal delivery medium in the serial femtosecond crystallography of Adenosine A2A receptor (A2AR). The structures of EROCOC17+4-matrix grown A2AR crystals were determined at 2.0 Å resolution by serial synchrotron rotation crystallography at a cryogenic temperature, and at 1.8 Å by LCP-serial femtosecond crystallography, using an X-ray free-electron laser at 4 and 20 °C sample temperatures, and are comparable to the structure of the MO-matrix grown A2AR crystal (PDB ID: 4EIY). Moreover, X-ray scattering measurements indicated that the EROCOC17+4/water system did not form the crystalline LC phase at least down to − 20 °C, in marked contrast to the equilibrium MO/water system, which transforms into the crystalline LC phase below about 17 °C. As the LC phase formation within the LCP-matrix causes difficulties in protein crystallography experiments in meso, this feature of EROCOC17+4 will expand the utility of the in meso method.

Structural insights into the membrane receptor ShuA in DDM micelles and in a model of gram-negative bacteria outer membrane as seen by SAXS and MD simulations

Successful crystallization of membrane proteins in detergent micelles depends on key factors such as conformational stability of the protein in micellar assemblies, the protein-detergent complex (PDC) monodispersity and favorable protein crystal contacts by suitable shielding of the protein hydrophobic surface by the detergent belt. With the aim of studying the influence of amphiphilic environment on membrane protein structure, stability and crystallizability, we combine molecular dynamics (MD) simulations with SEC-MALLS and SEC-SAXS (Size Exclusion Chromatography in line with Multi Angle Laser Light Scattering or Small Angle X-ray Scattering) experiments to describe the protein-detergent interactions that could help to rationalize PDC crystallization. In this context, we compare the protein-detergent interactions of ShuA from Shigella dysenteriae in n-Dodecyl-β-D-Maltopyranoside (DDM) with ShuA inserted in a realistic model of gram-negative bacteria outer membrane (OM) containing a mixture of bacterial lipopolysaccharide and phospholipids. To evaluate the quality of the PDC models, we compute the corresponding SAXS curves from the MD trajectories and compare with the experimental ones. We show that computed SAXS curves obtained from the MD trajectories reproduce better the SAXS obtained from the SEC-SAXS experiments for ShuA surrounded by 268 DDM molecules. The MD results show that the DDM molecules form around ShuA a closed belt whose the hydrophobic thickness appears slightly smaller (~22 Å) than the hydrophobic transmembrane domain of the protein (24.6 Å) suggested by Orientations of Proteins in Membranes (OPM) database. The simulations also show that ShuA transmembrane domain is remarkably stable in all the systems except for the extracellular and periplasmic loops that exhibit larger movements due to specific molecular interactions with lipopolysaccharides (LPS). We finally point out that this detergent behavior may lead to the occlusion of the periplasmic hydrophilic surface and poor crystal contacts leading to difficulties in crystallization of ShuA in DDM.

Demonstration of electron diffraction from membrane protein crystals grown in a lipidic mesophase after lamella preparation by focused ion beam milling at cryogenic temperatures.

Electron crystallography of sub-micrometre-sized 3D protein crystals has emerged recently as a valuable field of structural biology. In meso crystallization methods, utilizing lipidic mesophases, particularly lipidic cubic phases (LCPs), can produce high-quality 3D crystals of membrane proteins (MPs). A major step towards realizing 3D electron crystallography of MP crystals, grown in meso, is to demonstrate electron diffraction from such crystals. The first task is to remove the viscous and sticky lipidic matrix that surrounds the crystals without damaging the crystals. Additionally, the crystals have to be thin enough to let electrons traverse them without significant multiple scattering. In the present work, the concept that focused ion beam milling at cryogenic temperatures (cryo-FIB milling) can be used to remove excess host lipidic mesophase matrix is experimentally verified, and then the crystals are thinned to a thickness suitable for electron diffraction. In this study, bacteriorhodopsin (BR) crystals grown in a lipidic cubic mesophase of monoolein were used as a model system. LCP from a part of a hexagon-shaped plate-like BR crystal (∼10 µm in thickness and ∼70 µm in the longest dimension), which was flash-frozen in liquid nitro-gen, was milled away with a gallium FIB under cryogenic conditions, and a part of the crystal itself was thinned into a ∼210 nm-thick lamella with the ion beam. The frozen sample was then transferred into an electron cryo-microscope, and a nanovolume of ∼1400 × 1400 × 210 nm of the BR lamella was exposed to 200 kV electrons at a fluence of ∼0.06 e Å-2. The resulting electron diffraction peaks were detected beyond 2.7 Å resolution (with an average peak height to background ratio of >2) by a CMOS-based Ceta 16M camera. The results demonstrate that cryo-FIB milling produces high-quality lamellae from crystals grown in lipidic mesophases and pave the way for 3D electron crystallography on crystals grown or embedded in highly viscous media.

Advances in Crystal Growth Techniques of Biological Macromolecules

The structural knowledge of some biological macromole- cules helps to understand their mechanisms of working and their role on health sciences, food science and even their effect on the econo- my. In this work, some recent solutions to crystallogenesis for struc- tural analysis (convective transport, counter-diffusion, the challenge of membrane protein crystallization, and high throughput techniques) are described. Finally, investigations on microgravity, crystal growth under magnetic and electric fields, as well as crystal growth in mesophases (lipid membranes) and microfluidics are carefully revised.

Promoting crystallization of intrinsic membrane proteins with conjugated micelles

A new technique for promoting nucleation and growth of membrane protein (MP) crystals from micellar environments is reported. It relies on the conjugation of micelles that sequester MPs in protein detergent complexes (PDCs). Conjugation via amphiphilic [metal:chelator] complexes presumably takes place at the micelle/water interface, thereby bringing the PDCs into proximity, promoting crystal nucleation and growth. We have successfully applied this approach to two light-driven proton pumps: bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and the recently discovered King Sejong 1–2 (KS1–2), using the amphiphilic 4,4′-dinonyl-2,2′-dipyridyl (Dinonyl) (0.7 mM) chelator in combination with Zn2+, Fe2+, or Ni2+ (0.1 mM). Crystal growth in the presence of the [metal–chelator] complexes leads to purple, hexagonal crystals (50–75 µm in size) of bR or pink, rectangular/square crystals (5–15 µm) of KS1–2. The effects of divalent cation identity and concentration, chelator structure and concentration, ionic strength and pH on crystal size, morphology and process kinetics, are described.

Effects of 2-monoacylglycerol on in meso crystallization and the crystal structures of integral membrane proteins

Monoacylglycerols (MAGs) are the lipids most commonly used for crystallizing membrane proteins by the in meso method. The acyl chain and glycerol components of MAGs are ester-linked at the sn-1 hyd...

Pendant-bearing glucose-neopentyl glycol (P-GNG) amphiphiles for membrane protein manipulation: Importance of detergent pendant chain for protein stabilization

Glucoside detergents are successfully used for membrane protein crystallization mainly because of their ability to form small protein-detergent complexes. In a previous study, we introduced glucose neopentyl glycol (GNG) amphiphiles with a branched diglucoside structure that has facilitated high resolution crystallographic structure determination of several membrane proteins. Like other glucoside detergents, however, these GNGs were less successful than DDM in stabilizing membrane proteins, limiting their wide use in protein structural study. As a strategy to improve GNG efficacy for protein stabilization, we introduced two different alkyl chains (i.e., main and pendant chains) into the GNG scaffold while maintaining the branched diglucoside head group. Of these pendant-bearing GNGs (P-GNGs), three detergents (GNG-2,14, GNG-3,13 and GNG-3,14) were not only notably better than both DDM (a gold standard detergent) and the previously described GNGs at stabilizing all six membrane proteins tested here, but were also as efficient as DDM at membrane protein extraction. The results suggest that the C14 main chain of the P-GNGs is highly compatible with the hydrophobic widths of membrane proteins, while the C2/C3 pendant chain is effective at strengthening detergent hydrophobic interactions. Based on the marked effect on protein stability and solubility, these glucoside detergents hold significant potential for membrane protein structural study. Furthermore, the independent roles of the detergent two alkyl chains first introduced in this study have shed light on new amphiphile design for membrane protein study. Statement of significanceDetergent efficacy for protein stabilization tends to be protein-specific, thus it is challenging to find a detergent that is effective at stabilizing multiple membrane proteins. By incorporating a pendant chain into our previous GNG scaffold, we prepared pendant chain-bearing GNGs (P-GNGs) and identified three P-GNGs that were highly effective at stabilizing all membrane proteins tested here including two GPCRs. In addition, the new detergents were as efficient as DDM at extracting membrane proteins, enabling use of these detergents over the multiple steps of protein isolation. The key difference between the P-GNGs and other glucoside detergents, the presence of a pendant chain, is likely to be responsible for their markedly enhanced protein stabilization behavior.