When extracting amorphous silicon from fly ash using a strong alkaline solution, other elements such as Al also enter the silicon extraction solution in the form of AlOH4−. To systematically investigate the impact of AlOH4− on the synthesis of typical calcium silicate hydrate crystals in a silicon extraction solution, a specific amount of AlOH4− was added to the silicon extraction solution, and calcium silicate was hydrothermally synthesized at 90℃ and 230℃. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and Brunner−Emmet−Teller (BET) analysis revealed that with the increasing in AlOH4− content, microporous calcium silicate gradually loses its microporous morphology. While the specific surface area shows no significant change, the median pore diameter first increases from 1.47 nm to 1.58 nm and then decreases to 1.55 nm. The xonotlite fibers underwent a gradual refinement, diminishing from 0.28 to 0.15 µm. Simultaneously, the specific surface area increases from 28.87 to 56.8 m2/g. At an AlOH4− concentration of 3 mol/L, the microscopic morphology transforms into a sheet-like structure. X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis reveals that AlOH4− promotes the formation of tobermorite while inhibiting the further development of calcium silicate. Additionally, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) and nuclear magnetic resonance indicate that Al can replace Si in the calcium silicate hydrate system, primarily substituting positions the Q2 and Q3 sites. Qualitatively, it is suggested that with the increasing incorporation of Al, the polymerization degree of the silicon-oxygen tetrahedra decreases. According to experimental results, the concentration of AlOH4− should be below 0.05 mol/L when synthesizing microporous calcium silicate hydrate and less than 0.2 mol/L when synthesizing fibrous xonotlite-type calcium silicate hydrate.