There is a need to investigate novel strategies in order to create an effective, broadly protective vaccine for current and future severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) outbreaks. The currently available vaccines demonstrate compromised efficacy against emerging SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern (VOCs), short-lived immunity, and susceptibility to immune imprinting due to frequent boosting practices. In this study, we examined the specificity of cross-reactive IgG antibody responses in mRNA-vaccinated, AstraZeneca-vaccinated, and unvaccinated donors to identify potentially conserved, cross-reactive epitopes to target in order to create a broadly protective SARS-CoV-2 vaccine. Our study provides evidence for cross-reactive IgG antibodies specific to eight different spike (S) variants. Furthermore, the specificities of these cross-variant IgG antibody titers were associated to some extent with spike S1- and S2-subunit-derived epitopes P1 and P2, respectively. In addition, nucleocapsid (N)- and membrane (M)-specific IgG antibody titers correlated with N- and M-derived epitopes conserved across beta-CoVs, P3-7. This study reveals conserved epitopes of viral antigens, targeted by natural and/or vaccine-induced human immunity, for future designs of next-generation COVID-19 vaccines.