The Editorial Board of Weed Research conducted an online discussion during the summer of 2017, reviewing the status of the journal and responding to questions on the impact, scope and potential improvements for the journal for the future. My vision as Editor-in-Chief has always been that Weed Research should be the journal of choice for weed scientists and for it to have the highest impact it can. Whilst the impact metrics for the journal have been reasonable in the past, the last three years have seen a decline that needs addressing. Authors look to publish in the highest impact journals possible and the journal needs to act to improve its impact. Impact is largely down to citation metrics these days, so factors such as excellence, likely citation rate and attracting submissions of the best papers, including reviews, need careful attention. Amongst the Board, there is also clear concern that we need to broaden the scope of the journal to address some of these issues. It is essential that any changes to the journal are placed in the current scientific and publishing context. Scientifically, the traditional areas that the journal covers, notably weed biology and weed management in agriculture, are now mature science. As our vision is to publish work that advances science, we are at a pivotal moment for weed science and for the journal. The challenges we face as weed scientists are that the traditional approaches with simple control technologies are not sustainable, yet we need to feed an increasing world population. Pressures on land to achieve multifunctionality and to mitigate human impact on the planet are building. Increasingly, for production agriculture, horticulture and forestry, integrated crop management is required. This needs to be built around primary plant production and its interactions with biotic, abiotic, social and economic environments to develop long-term sustainability. Thus, we are expanding the scope of the journal to cover cross-cutting issues in integrated crop management and the interactions with the range of disciplines across production and crop protection, as well as integrated weed management. We invite scientists to submit manuscripts that address such issues and we welcome reviews on integrated crop and weed management. I am particularly keen that the journal covers uncropped land in its broadest sense, including natural and semi-natural habitats, alongside the ecology of agriculture, horticulture and forestry. The journal already covers vegetation management in its broadest sense, reflected in the strap line a ‘journal of weed biology, ecology and vegetation management’. Whilst this clearly covers invasive plants in all ecosystems, and many papers are published on such topics in Weed Research, I notice that there are relatively few contributions from forestry, horticulture, amenity and urban systems, or from rangelands or conservation sites. We welcome submissions from across these systems that address aspects of the interactions of the botanical components. Ecologically, plants form the primary producers upon which all food chains are based. The positive role of wild plants in production systems has only been appreciated relatively recently and we invite submissions that explore the services and disservices of such species and not just in production systems. We should also consider the plant interactions between the varied components of landscape mosaics, at scales ranging from dispersal dynamics at field edges to global spread. We also should cover conservation management and habitat recreation in the context of vegetation management. Thus, the scope of the journal will cover a broader range of topics than weed biology and control and better reflect the interests of the readership and the European Weed Research Society. In a previous editorial (2015; Weed Research 55, 437–440), we discussed the aims and policies of the journal. We will be relaxing those policies in relation to specific topics, such as allelopathy and herbicide resistance, to encourage more submissions. However, we will retain our aim of only publishing novel and innovative work. Further editorials in 2018 will discuss the means of increasing impact beyond broadening the scope of the journal, the role of the journal as a service for authors and the promotion of openness across the Editorial Board's work. Meanwhile, if you would like to comment on any aspect of the journal, please email me.
Read full abstract